in and outs

[Gehrigs_son]

i think at this stage
in: lenny Gardiner
out: c gardiner eddy

[Teflon]

i think at this stage
in: lenny Gardiner
out: c gardiner eddy

Football is a game to be enjoyed. Just let them play. I think Ross will know the answers. Lets not talk anymore till he tells us.

Goodbye.

[Otiman]

i think at this stage
in: lenny Gardiner
out: c gardiner eddy

I think we need to leave the team the way it is, for gatheredness.

[saint patrick]

i think at this stage
in: lenny Gardiner
out: c gardiner eddy

Football is a game to be enjoyed. Just let them play. I think Ross will know the answers. Lets not talk anymore till he tells us.

Goodbye.

Still a bit of harmless speculation is what GS is suggesting Tef

In:Hayes,M.Gardiner.

Out:C.Gardiner ,Macqualter.

[djsburke]

i think at this stage
in: lenny Gardiner
out: c gardiner eddy

Eddy played for Casey today so looks like he might be out this week, wouldn't expect him to play Friday night after a Sunday game

[ausfatcat]

depends on how much game time he had, quite a few others played as well, and at least one or two of them need to play or we wont have a side.

[Saints Premiers 2008]

mini stays...the way he threw himself at the pill and made a contest and assisted us was priceless

great to see him come good

[Gehrigs_son]

i think at this stage
in: lenny Gardiner
out: c gardiner eddy

I think we need to leave the team the way it is, for gatheredness.

i think at this stage
in: lenny Gardiner
out: c gardiner eddy

Football is a game to be enjoyed. Just let them play. I think Ross will know the answers. Lets not talk anymore till he tells us.

Goodbye.

good points, i mentioned a similar things on another thread. though i still think lenny will at least come in, but this i think will help the gatheredness of the team

[Gehrigs_son]

mini stays...the way he threw himself at the pill and made a contest and assisted us was priceless

great to see him come good

yeh i cant say i was happy to see him come into the team, but hes doin ok so far

[borderbarry]

Geary may have earnt his place woth todays effort.

[Gehrigs_son]

Geary may have earnt his place woth todays effort.

in the bests was he? i still doubt he will come in with lenny and possibly gards already, but ya never know

[mick13]

Dont think Geary will come back in, theres a couple ahead of him (Hayes, Birss).

I wouldnt be too worried, he's only 19 inne? Expect him to cement his spot in the side within a couple of years.

[midas_touch]

In: Lenny, M Gardiner, Baker
Out: C Gardiner, Eddy, Mini

Alternately, leave Mini in the side whilst Bakes has another week with Casey.

i think at this stage
in: lenny Gardiner
out: c gardiner eddy

I think we need to leave the team the way it is, for gatheredness.

No offense, but you must have rocks in your head if you don't want our best midfielder in Lenny Hayes over a 2 game player in Eddy. No disrespect to him, since I believe he will be a 100+ game player, but you must go with the beat team you have available at your disposal.

[plugger66]

i think at this stage
in: lenny Gardiner
out: c gardiner eddy

Eddy played for Casey today so looks like he might be out this week, wouldn't expect him to play Friday night after a Sunday game

So Armo would be dropped as well.

[saint66au]

Would have thought Gardy might have played a half for the Scorps this week if they were looking at bringing him back Fri night

In: Lenny
Out: Charlie G

Not like for like but gives Allen a chance to step up and play a genuine 2nd forward marking option...Id be keeping him and Kosi (when not rucking) inside 50 and telling em to stay there!!!

[St.Walker]

I would drop allen before c.gardener....

Allen done nothing...CG although not the special can play a rool to release roo and kosi.

[Saints94]

IN: Hayes M.Gardiner

OUT: C.Gardiner J.Allen

[spert]

Mini earned his spot, so probably Eddy for Birss I think.

[super dooper]

If Bakes is fit he simply has to play. His role in the team is pivotal and is one person i enjoy playing the negating role for the team as he barely gets beaten and he has that mungrel about him that no one else in the side seems to have.

Lenny also if fit must come in - enough said

These two players are both top 10 players on our list and must play.

Although i havent yet been able to watch the game from saturday night being overseas for the match, the likes of J.Allen and C.Gardiner could easily make way to create a better mix against our quick opponents, who when on song provide a lot of run.

[Ralphy]

INS:
Gardy, Lenny,

OUTS:
Minnie, Gwilt

Charlie gardiner has done enough in my opinion, he is good a target up forward with the likes of kosi, Roo, Allen

Gwilt & minnie to be retained on the list this year,

[Otiman]

No offense, but you must have rocks in your head

It's called extracting the urine.

[Batnoe]

One of Allen or C Gardiner must play, it lets Roo play further up the ground

the last 2 weeks we have won, both times Roo best on ground, both times he hasnt played in the fwd 50 for the whole game, Having another tall player gives our team a certain dimension

[terry smith rules]

i think if we are playing horses for courses then there is no place for gardiner, m

we need a more mobile big man set up

therefore I think gardiner,c should be given another go

he is a genuine option up forward if waite gets on top of nick r

[AlpineStars]

In Lenny , Baker

Out Gwilt, Mini

[Sobraz]

seriously noone thinks C. Gardiner should be retained... He has been deplorable in the last 2 matches, and has no upside..

My god, the guy is a dud... Im surprised by posters on here saying he has done enough, should be retained etc... He's a cheap kick getter who's also a squib... Honestly think he is the softest player at the club...

Out: Charlie
In: ANYONE... (lenny)