Coaches Votes 2011

[bergholt]

squeezing up a bit behind joey. dal and chips obviously the two most consistent. 18 of the 36 we've used have received votes.

25 Leigh Montagna (votes in 3 games)
24 Nick Dal Santo (6)
15 Brendon Goddard (3)
14 Sam Fisher (5)
10 Nick Riewoldt (2)
8 Clinton Jones (2)
7 Jack Steven (2)
5 David Armitage (2), James Gwilt (3), Lenny Hayes (1)
4 Zac Dawson (2), Sam Gilbert (1), Stephen Milne (1), Brett Peake (1), Adam Schneider (2)
3 Farren Ray (2)
2 Sean Dempster (1)
1 Jason Gram (1)

[saintbrat]

http://aflca.com.au/index.php?id=14&tx_ ... 0cf852d3ff

rd 16
Port vs St. Kilda

10 Dal Santo (St K),
7 Steven (St K),
4 Goddard (St K),
3 McEvoy (St K),
2 Gwilt (St K),
2 Riewoldt (St K),
1 Gilbert (St K),
1 Hartlett (Port).


so Primus or lyon give Hartlett 1?

[Mr Magic]

And one coach gave Goddard 4 whilst the other coach gave him nothing?

In fact, only Dal and Steven were given votes by both coaches.

[saintbrat]

compared to Age votes
PORT ADELAIDE v ST KILDA
Ashley Porter
Nick Dal Santo (St Kilda) 8
Brendon Goddard (St Kilda) 8
James Gwilt (St Kilda) 8
Jack Steven (St Kilda) 7
Ryan Gamble (St Kilda) 7

Read more: http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/a ... z1RmQ3mhPe

[borderbarry]

Interesting. First votes for McEvoy and Gilbert. Jack has now caught up with Sam Fisher.

[perfectionist]

Coach 1
5. Nick Dal Santo
4. Jack Steven
3. Ben McEvoy
2. Nick Riewoldt
1. Hamish Hartlett

Coach 2
5. Nick Dal Santo
4. Brendon Goddard
3. Jack Steven
2. James Gwilt
1. Sam Gilbert

The 1s and 2s could swap. The interesting vote was Sam Gilbert. One coach was impressed with the close hard tagging but few possessions game, probably his best role at the moment - the less he gets it, the less chance there is that he will butcher it.

[saintbrat]

Round 17
St. Kilda vs West Coast

10 Montagna (St K),
4 Clarke (St K),
4 Gram (St K),
3 Naitanui (WCE),
3 Schneider (St K),
2 Dal Santo (St K),
2 Fisher (St K),
1 Dawson (St K),
1 Priddis (WCE).

Well done Raph and Grammy
http://aflca.com.au/index.php?id=14&tx_ ... 212ef20e78

[maverick]

So do you think Ross gave Raph or Grammy the votes?

[Bernard Shakey]

So do you think Ross gave Raph or Grammy the votes?

I would think Ross went:
Joey;
Gram (bombed away as usual);
Schneider (he was ordinary);
Chips;
Dawson (his love child).

Which says to me Worsefold has a better perception of the game.

[SainterK]

I disagree, Ross acknowledged Raphs game in the presser, and then said he wouldn't individualise any more than that....quite the praise really.

[maverick]

I disagree, Ross acknowledged Raphs game in the presser, and then said he wouldn't individualise any more than that....quite the praise really.

Well that's interesting, I reckon he went for Raph.

[Bernard Shakey]

I disagree, Ross acknowledged Raphs game in the presser, and then said he wouldn't individualise any more than that....quite the praise really.

If that's the case, he's smarter than I thought.

[SainterK]

I disagree, Ross acknowledged Raphs game in the presser, and then said he wouldn't individualise any more than that....quite the praise really.

If that's the case, he's smarter than I thought.

Here you go....after the Yabby tribute

http://www.sportal.com.au/mediaplayer/a ... eans-10877

Edit, actually a bit later than that...but it's all worth listening to

[Mr Magic]

Interesting that neither coacvhing panel gave Cox a vote - at odds with the media's view - Mark Stevens in The Age gave him 2nd best on the ground.
Also only one player, Joey, was rated by both coaches.

It just goes to show that coaches obviously can rate players totally differently to media and spectators.

It might also explain why some selections are made which spectators/fans just cannot comprehend.

[bergholt]

dal has received votes in six of the last seven games to hit the lead - at this rate, the best and fairest is his to lose.

raph and b-mac enter the list, so now 20 of the 36 have received votes.

36 Nick Dal Santo (votes in 8 games)
35 Leigh Montagna (4)
19 Brendon Goddard (3)
16 Sam Fisher (6)
14 Jack Steven (3)
12 Nick Riewoldt (2)
8 Clinton Jones (2)
7 James Gwilt (4), Adam Schneider (3)
5 David Armitage (2), Zac Dawson (3), Sam Gilbert (2), Jason Gram (2), Lenny Hayes (1)
4 Raphael Clarke (1), Stephen Milne (1), Brett Peake (1)
3 Ben McEvoy (1), Farren Ray (2)
2 Sean Dempster (1)

[terry smith rules]

So do you think Ross gave Raph or Grammy the votes?

I would think Ross went:
Joey;
Gram (bombed away as usual);
Schneider (he was ordinary);
Chips;
Dawson (his love child).

Which says to me Worsefold has a better perception of the game.

wow what an insight Bernard, clearly you have watched the game

I think you will find that many people (including respected football commentators) have rated Gram Schneider and Dawson as having very good games (especially Dawson)

but never mind your immature and dated biases obviously give you a better view of the game

[Bernard Shakey]

wow what an insight Bernard, clearly you have watched the game

I think you will find that many people (including respected football commentators) have rated Gram Schneider and Dawson as having very good games (especially Dawson)

but never mind your immature and dated biases obviously give you a better view of the game

Wow respected football commentators, who would they be? All commentators are bagged on this forum. Good to see you regard them highly.
I called it as I saw it and I'm not alone in my observations, which are not immature, dated nor biased. They are my opinions, not anyone else's.

[kosifantutti23]

So do you think Ross gave Raph or Grammy the votes?

I would think Ross went:
Joey;
Gram (bombed away as usual);
Schneider (he was ordinary);
Chips;
Dawson (his love child).

Which says to me Worsefold has a better perception of the game.

So you're slamming Ross based on your guess of what the votes were.

[Bernard Shakey]

So do you think Ross gave Raph or Grammy the votes?

I would think Ross went:
Joey;
Gram (bombed away as usual);
Schneider (he was ordinary);
Chips;
Dawson (his love child).

Which says to me Worsefold has a better perception of the game.

So you're slamming Ross based on your guess of what the votes were. :roll:

If you say so.

[kosifantutti23]

Yeah, I say so.

[saintbrat]

Round 18

AFLCA Champion Player of the Year Award votes
Monday, July 25, 2011 - 5:22 PM
St. Kilda vs Adelaide

9 Milne (St K),
8 Dal Santo (St K),
6 Schneider (St K),
3 Montagna (St K),
2 Dempster (St K),
1 Armitage (St K),
1 Riewoldt (St K).



as compared to the Age
St Kilda v Adelaide
Rohan Connolly
Stephen Milne (St Kilda) 9
Nick Dal Santo (St Kilda) 8
Brendon Goddard (St Kilda) 7
Adam Schneider (St Kilda) 7
Nick Riewoldt (St Kilda) 6


Read more: http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/a ... z1T6wHOjJU

[perfectionist]

Coach 1

5. Stephen Milne
4. Adam Schneider
3. Nick Dal Santo
2. Sean Dempster
1. Nick Riewoldt

Coach 2

5. Nick Dal Santo
4. Stephen Milne
3. Leigh Montagna
2. Adam Schneider
1. David Armitage

The two 1 votes could swap.

[bergholt]

ok, so now we've played 16 games and dal has received votes in 9 of them - 56% of our games. he's surely unbeatable for the b&f.

44 Nick Dal Santo (votes in 9 games)
38 Leigh Montagna (5)
19 Brendon Goddard (3)
16 Sam Fisher (6)
14 Jack Steven (3)
13 Stephen Milne (2), Nick Riewoldt (3), Adam Schneider (4)
8 Clinton Jones (2)
7 James Gwilt (4)
6 David Armitage (3)
5 Zac Dawson (3), Sam Gilbert (2), Jason Gram (2), Lenny Hayes (1)
4 Raphael Clarke (1), Sean Dempster (2), Brett Peake (1)
3 Ben McEvoy (1), Farren Ray (2)

[saintbrat]

Thought they may have gone ' in camera' but just late

9 Dal Santo (St K), 5 + 4
8 G Ablett (GC), 5 + 3
5 Bock (GC), 3 + 2
4 Goddard (St K), 4
2 Harbrow (GC), 2
1 Peake (St K), 1
1 Prestia (GC). 1

3 Saints and 4 Suns

[perfectionist]

Probably:

Coach 1

5. Nick Dal Santo
4. Brendon Goddard
3. Gary Ablett
2. Nathan Bock
1. Brett Peake

Coach 2

5. Gary Ablett
4. Nick Dal Santo
3. Nathan Bock
2. Jarrod Harbrow
1. Dion Prestia

Coach 2 needs to take the blinkers off.