Years end de-listings

[SaintSimmo]

at the end of the year we should delist:

riewoldt
fisher
dal santo
hayes
montagna
mcevoy
steven

they are all duds

[borderbarry]

We are going to have to make room for 2 or 3 to be upgraded from the rookie list, and last year we picked up 6 in the draft. I am not suggesting that we need to get rid of 9, but maybe as many as 7 may have go one way or another.

[St Nick]

At seasons end I would think that we need a full rebuild. That being the case, these are the players that should go....

Retire
1. Gardiner
2. Baker
3. Blake
4. Koschitzke

Trade for a pick in the top 10
1. Gilbert

De-List
1. Peake
2. McQualter
3. Polo
4. Gamble
5. Geary

Elevate
1. Walsh

[noob]

Apparently this year's draft will be average. So I wouldn't be removing 10-12 players from the list.. That will effectively mean we will have picks like 18-36-54-72-90-108-109-110-111-112-113-114-115 etc.
Few will retire leaving not many delisted.

[goddardisgod]

At seasons end I would think that we need a full rebuild. That being the case, these are the players that should go....

Retire
1. Gardiner
2. Baker
3. Blake
4. Koschitzke

[u]Trade for a pick in the top 10[/u]
1. Gilbert

De-List
1. Peake
2. McQualter
3. Polo
4. Gamble
5. Geary

Elevate
1. Walsh

Red = Lol

For starters, no ones going to give a top ten pick for Gilbert.

Secondly, Peake is in fantastic form, while Geary hasn't had a shot this year, getting injured early in both the Nab cup and regular season.

Thirdly, both Kosi and Blake are deserving of a spot on the list. While pushing Baker and Gardi may be fine, these two should not retire unless they request it.

IMO:

Retire:
Gardiner
Bakes

Delist:
McQualter
Cahill
Heyne
Polo
Gamble

Promote:
Walsh
Archer

Rookie Delist:
Eddy
Gaertner

That gives us 5 picks in the national draft, and 4 in the rookie draft, one of which will be used on Heyne as a lifeline/pay out contract.

[spert]

at the end of the year we should delist:

riewoldt
fisher
dal santo
hayes
montagna
mcevoy
steven

they are all duds

How have Reiwoldt, Montagna and NDS gone in the last three GFs?

[BigMart]

So your admitting you have no idea plugger.....gold


At least you got that right......

[St Nick]

Gilbert is definitely worth a top 10 pick.

[plugger66]

So your admitting you have no idea plugger.....gold


At least you got that right......

Still got you covered which doesnt say much for your knowledge. Most know that though.

[GrumpyOne]

IMO:

Retire:
Gardiner
Bakes

Delist:
McQualter
Cahill
Heyne
Polo
Gamble

Promote:
Walsh
Archer

Rookie Delist:
Eddy
Gaertner

That gives us 5 picks in the national draft, and 4 in the rookie draft, one of which will be used on Heyne as a lifeline/pay out contract.

Reckon you're spot on the money there.

[Stillwaiting]

IMO:

Retire:
Gardiner
Bakes

Delist:
McQualter
Cahill
Heyne
Polo
Gamble

Promote:
Walsh
Archer

Rookie Delist:
Eddy
Gaertner

That gives us 5 picks in the national draft, and 4 in the rookie draft, one of which will be used on Heyne as a lifeline/pay out contract.

Reckon you're spot on the money there.

I thought Gardiner was going to play next year, I hope he does. Other than that its seems to be perfect.

[skeptic]

Retire:
Gardiner
Bakes

Delist:
McQualter
Cahill
Heyne
Polo
Gamble

Promote:
Walsh
Archer

Rookie Delist:
Eddy
Gaertner

That gives us 5 picks in the national draft, and 4 in the rookie draft, one of which will be used on Heyne as a lifeline/pay out contract.

I'd give Cahill to the end of the season to prove his worth

I'd also give Jones until the end of the season to give us a reason not to cut him

[plugger66]

Retire:
Gardiner
Bakes

Delist:
McQualter
Cahill
Heyne
Polo
Gamble

Promote:
Walsh
Archer

Rookie Delist:
Eddy
Gaertner

That gives us 5 picks in the national draft, and 4 in the rookie draft, one of which will be used on Heyne as a lifeline/pay out contract.

I'd give Cahill to the end of the season to prove his worth

I'd also give Jones until the end of the season to give us a reason not to cut him

Are you serious about Jones. If he goes then we are getting rid of about 15 others. Skills are poor but gives us value elsewhere. Certainly more than many other players and I arent his biggest fan. Not by a long shot.

[saint tash]

I'm being delisted.

I will delist u instead. Go and find yourself a new club.

I will de-rookie myself.

[GrumpyOne]

I'd give Cahill to the end of the season to prove his worth

I'd also give Jones until the end of the season to give us a reason not to cut him

Cahill has had several seasons to prove that.

We still need Jones for fast tagging roles.

[degruch]

Jones! There'd be 16 other teams salivating over that one...2009 we were giving away free midfielders, last year we were giving away free picks, next year free taggers for all!

[Verdun66]

Not that he's done any good, but I would have thought they had given Gamble at least a 2 year deal.

Heyne has been disappointing.

[skeptic]

LOL

rose coloured glasses

a turnover machine that beats his opponent every 3rd week

maybe we should see if we can trade the world's greatest tagger for Judd.

Lets offer him to 16 other teams and c who would take him

elite teams have good taggers... no one like Jones

[To the top]

Cahill is 20 years of age, 192cm and 87kg with forward KPP potential.

Who are you going to replace him with in a compromised draft?

If Gardiner feels he can contribute he will go on - and he will be requested to go on.

[bobmurray]

Cahill is 20 years of age, 192cm and 87kg with forward KPP potential.

Who are you going to replace him with in a compromised draft?

If Gardiner feels he can contribute he will go on - and he will be requested to go on.

keep them all you reckon...who cares if we're less than competitive....who cares where we finish....show the faith

[skeptic]

Cahill started the year on fire at Sandy b4 injuring himself... he's looking ok.

I'd be happy to let him play for his life over the next 9 weeks and decide at the end of the season

[degruch]

LOL

rose coloured glasses

a turnover machine that beats his opponent every 3rd week

maybe we should see if we can trade the world's greatest tagger for Judd.

Lets offer him to 16 other teams and c who would take him

elite teams have good taggers... no one like Jones

Yeah...you stick with that...we'll keep Jones.

[gringo]

I think guys like Eddy, Cahill, Heyne would be feeling pretty nervous. I wouldn't be surprised if we offer an early second round pick for Stanley, he seems to have lost favour from Lyon. It is going to be a hard year to work out who to drop from the list -we have got promising and established not much in between and it will be interesting to see who goes.

[skeptic]

LOL

rose coloured glasses

a turnover machine that beats his opponent every 3rd week

maybe we should see if we can trade the world's greatest tagger for Judd.

Lets offer him to 16 other teams and c who would take him

elite teams have good taggers... no one like Jones

Yeah...you stick with that...we'll keep Jones.

yep

was great in the GFs... all 3 of them

what a star

[degruch]

LOL

rose coloured glasses

a turnover machine that beats his opponent every 3rd week

maybe we should see if we can trade the world's greatest tagger for Judd.

Lets offer him to 16 other teams and c who would take him

elite teams have good taggers... no one like Jones

Yeah...you stick with that...we'll keep Jones.

yep

was great in the GFs... all 3 of them

what a star

...and Roo, out he goes too. KP forwards going cheap! Get 'em while they're hot!!!