Long time reader, first time poster

dragit · Post: # 1093691Post **dragit** » Tue 21 Jun 2011 6:35pm

plugger66 wrote:
gringo wrote:Kosi and Mc Qualter were both in the team because they played roles. If in Kosi's case that was pulling a tall defender out to the wing so Rooey could work in space that was his job and did it with out complaint. So too Mini, did his job on the 50 tackling and running with the defensive link to effect turn overs, did it with great effect in 09 and once the opposition worked it out they would shepherd him or play an extra mid back for the link.
I have never seen Kosi on the wing when he has played forward. His job was to stay put and keep his defender on him.

The other thing he did in 2009 which people conveniently forget was kick 48 goals - what a dud hey?

Dr Spaceman · Tue 21 Jun 2011 6:37pm

gringo wrote:Kosi and Mc Qualter were both in the team because they played roles. If in Kosi's case that was pulling a tall defender out to the wing so Rooey could work in space that was his job and did it with out complaint. So too Mini, did his job on the 50 tackling and running with the defensive link to effect turn overs, did it with great effect in 09 and once the opposition worked it out they would shepherd him or play an extra mid back for the link.

Also, people should not relate their desire to not have Mini in the seniors with a lack of form at Sandy. He normally plays well at VFL level, which is not what the OP suggests.

Sainternist · Tue 21 Jun 2011 6:40pm

Welcome to the Saint-Asylum, Nick.

For the record, when was Rhys' last game?

I seem to recall seeing him late last year against North Melbourne or the Dees. He looked okay back then too.

Yet to watch him this year, as I haven't had the chance to watch any Sandy matches.

dragit · Post: # 1093695Post **dragit** » Tue 21 Jun 2011 6:42pm

Sainternist wrote:Welcome to the Saint-Asylum, Nick.

For the record, when was Rhys' last game?

I seem to recall seeing him late last year against North Melbourne or the Dees. He looked okay back then too.

Yet to watch him this year, as I haven't had the chance to watch any Sandy matches.

Round 5 V Brisbane
1 mark, 2 disposals

goddardisgod · Tue 21 Jun 2011 8:33pm

dragit wrote:
Sainternist wrote:Welcome to the Saint-Asylum, Nick.

For the record, when was Rhys' last game?

I seem to recall seeing him late last year against North Melbourne or the Dees. He looked okay back then too.

Yet to watch him this year, as I haven't had the chance to watch any Sandy matches.
Round 5 V Brisbane
1 mark, 2 disposals

That game was very disappointing. It certainly wasn't a night for key forwards, but be put in no effort at all. Kosi needed to be subbed off, he was really underdone. But he still offered more than Rhys. I think Ross has lost faith in him, because he was certainly happy last year.

Sainternist · Tue 21 Jun 2011 8:47pm

dragit wrote:
Sainternist wrote:Welcome to the Saint-Asylum, Nick.

For the record, when was Rhys' last game?

I seem to recall seeing him late last year against North Melbourne or the Dees. He looked okay back then too.

Yet to watch him this year, as I haven't had the chance to watch any Sandy matches.
Round 5 V Brisbane
1 mark, 2 disposals

That's right!

I had completely forgotten.

Thanks.

matrix · Post: # 1093867Post **matrix** » Tue 21 Jun 2011 11:48pm

is that you roo???

the captain is on SS!
ffs dont let ross know

Dr Spaceman · Tue 21 Jun 2011 11:50pm

matrix wrote:is that you roo???

the captain is on SS!
ffs dont let ross know

And he doesn't sound too chipper either

matrix · Post: # 1093881Post **matrix** » Wed 22 Jun 2011 12:19am

Dr Spaceman wrote:
matrix wrote:is that you roo???

the captain is on SS!
ffs dont let ross know
And he doesn't sound too chipper either

well he is in a slump
its understandable

he'll be right come august

St Nick · Post: # 1093919Post **St Nick** » Wed 22 Jun 2011 11:07am

Both Kosi and McQualter should be de-listed at the end of this year IMHO.

SaintPav · Post: # 1093925Post **SaintPav** » Wed 22 Jun 2011 11:28am

St Nick wrote:Both Kosi and McQualter should be de-listed at the end of this year IMHO.

How stupid do you think we all are troll..P!ss off...

Old Mate · Post: # 1093926Post **Old Mate** » Wed 22 Jun 2011 11:29am

Agreed that we need another forward in the team. I guess that's why Kosi came in but now he's suspended. With Rooey out of form and Kosi suspended I reckon Ross will bring in another forward. Won't be Stanley though because he's not cutting it at reserve level let alone AFL level. Walsh or Johnson will likely come in me thinks.

gringo · Post: # 1093938Post **gringo** » Wed 22 Jun 2011 12:15pm

I think Johnson will probably get a go. He has been very good at Sandy and must be due to get another game. I have huge hopes that Johnson will take a forward spot if he gets his confidence up. Hopefully he gets a couple of games to prove himself and no concussion. Otherwise I would like to see Archer get a go -at least he could pluck a few marks or bring the ball down and crash himself into the ruck.

bob__71 · Post: # 1093944Post **bob__71** » Wed 22 Jun 2011 12:50pm

St Nick wrote:Both Kosi and McQualter should be de-listed at the end of this year IMHO.

You may not have called anyone stupid. But I'm willing to call you stupid. I'm sure there are lots of other words I could have used.

P.S. collingwood trolls are so boring, I think its because they are so dumb.

SaintPav · Post: # 1093957Post **SaintPav** » Wed 22 Jun 2011 1:30pm

bob__71 wrote: P.S. collingwood trolls are so boring, I think its because they are so dumb.

apart from being petty minded theives, they are very dumb and they have no football knowledge what so ever.

stinger · Post: # 1093961Post **stinger** » Wed 22 Jun 2011 1:47pm

St Nick wrote:
dragit wrote:form

I'm sorry to say, but in my view that is a stupid response. .

you will go far....

meher baba · Wed 22 Jun 2011 2:27pm

St Nick wrote:You might want to read my thread again and tell me where I called you stupid???? From where I'm sitting, I didn't call you stupid. Correct me if I'm wrong.

This statement reminds me of someone...............................

GrumpyOne · Post: # 1093970Post **GrumpyOne** » Wed 22 Jun 2011 2:41pm

stinger wrote:
St Nick wrote:
dragit wrote:form

I'm sorry to say, but in my view that is a stupid response. .
you will go far....

Hopefully it will be as far as the Colon-wood Forum.

MCG-Unit · Post: # 1094005Post **MCG-Unit** » Wed 22 Jun 2011 3:42pm

meher baba wrote:
St Nick wrote:You might want to read my thread again and tell me where I called you stupid???? From where I'm sitting, I didn't call you stupid. Correct me if I'm wrong.
This statement reminds me of someone...............................

Definitely, and signed up not long after a certain poster was slammed for yet another offensive thread