Best team ever traded...

[Milan Faletic]

Rodney Galt
Grant Thomas hehe
Michael Roberts
Sean Simpson
The Cowans twins (SA)
Tony Brown (SA)
Daniel Healy (WA)

[mad saint guy]

Brent Guerra isn't too bad these days.

Delisted, not traded

[sax]

Did we trade Sziller to Richmond or was he delisted?

[sax]

OK, let's try this one... Along with our boom recruiting, we also traded a few stars in our time. So I've had a crack at a team of players we let go over the years.

Feel free to add.

B: Wakelin,D. Shanahan. Malthouse
HB: Elliott, R. Perovic. Wakelin, D
C: Trott. Elliott,G. Rae (?)
HF: Lappin. Greene. Rice
F: Hall. Lockett. O'Brien

R: Ditteritch, Fletcher, Stewart

INT: J Smith.

Can't recall who else. I think we traded Galt to Carlton and Grambeau to Melbourne from memory.

I think Mat Lappin was delisted!

[chook23]

Cazaly.......

[bergholt]

Did we trade Sziller to Richmond or was he delisted?

delisted and picked up by the tiges at pick 57 in 2000 - the pick they traded mark merenda to west coast for.

[bergholt]

I think Mat Lappin was delisted!

Nah, we traded Lappin and 58 to Carlton for 22 and 53 in 1998.

22: James Begley
53: Troy Schwarze
58: Ian Prendergast

[saintbob]

Rodney Galt
Grant Thomas hehe
Michael Roberts
Sean Simpson
The Cowans twins (SA)
Tony Brown (SA)
Daniel Healy (WA)

That would be the Gowans twins, James and Chris, who have gone on to have tremendous careers at Central Districts. I actually think they've have played in the last 8 premierships sides!!!

Did we delist:

Joel Smith
Joey McClaren

[groupie1]

I don't think we ended up trading Grant.

i thought we did, and this site agrees:

http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/pc-m ... avid-grant

unfortunately he played 7 games for melbourne after being pretty much a champion at st kilda. 184cm! i remember him a bit taller than that.

We traded Grant. Disgraceful how they handled it. Shame, he was a gem, and fell out after being offered for the Greg Williams effort.

Anyone list Russell Jeffrey.

Worst trade BY FAR was Russell Greene.

[plugger66]

I don't think we ended up trading Grant.

i thought we did, and this site agrees:

http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/pc-m ... avid-grant

unfortunately he played 7 games for melbourne after being pretty much a champion at st kilda. 184cm! i remember him a bit taller than that.

We traded Grant. Disgraceful how they handled it. Shame, he was a gem, and fell out after being offered for the Greg Williams effort.

Anyone list Russell Jeffrey.

Worst trade BY FAR was Russell Greene.

I reckon Ian Stewart has that covered. He won the brownlow in 1971 for Richmond. We lost by less than a kick to Hawthorn in the GF that year. I think we can work out what that trade cost us.

[bobmurray]

I had number 6 on my jumper as a kid but it was for an old fullback we had,not someone from a more modern era like David Grant....

[groupie1]

I don't think we ended up trading Grant.

i thought we did, and this site agrees:

http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/pc-m ... avid-grant

unfortunately he played 7 games for melbourne after being pretty much a champion at st kilda. 184cm! i remember him a bit taller than that.

We traded Grant. Disgraceful how they handled it. Shame, he was a gem, and fell out after being offered for the Greg Williams effort.

Anyone list Russell Jeffrey.

Worst trade BY FAR was Russell Greene.

I reckon Ian Stewart has that covered. He won the brownlow in 1971 for Richmond. We lost by less than a kick to Hawthorn in the GF that year. I think we can work out what that trade cost us.

Fair call mate.