How bout 2 duds?!saintsRrising wrote:We do? Who?markp wrote: and we have plenty to offer as trade bait.
WC will not takea dud for Kerr.
![Wink :wink:](./images/smilies/icon_wink.gif)
I think you put aside your non-negotiables and go for gold.....
Moderators: Saintsational Administrators, Saintsational Moderators
markp wrote:How bout 2 duds?!saintsRrising wrote:We do? Who?markp wrote: and we have plenty to offer as trade bait.
WC will not take a dud for Kerr.![]()
I think you put aside your non-negotiables and go for gold.....
And you took the words right out of my mouth... it must have been while you were kissing meThe Saintsational Man wrote:St Kilda send Nick Dal Santo to Essendon.
Essendon send picks to West Coast.
West Coast send us Daniel Kerr.
Joey is going no where, he'll be fine, will be very valuable.WayneJudson42 wrote:And you took the words right out of my mouth... it must have been while you were kissing meThe Saintsational Man wrote:St Kilda send Nick Dal Santo to Essendon.
Essendon send picks to West Coast.
West Coast send us Daniel Kerr.![]()
Kosi to the Dees? Take a look at lower 8 clubs and see what they need. And then see if we have it to offer them.
I'm actually reluctant to trade Dal unless he wants to go. I think he can do a great Mcleod type role for us down back.
Lenny and Ball will remain our insiders... Joey?
Keep Gram as an outsside runner... adds pace.
And will the status quo make us any better?St Igmata wrote:Not much depth around and an ageing list without too much elite talent coming through and the club should hand over the first pick and a player for a guy that played 10 games this year?
Is this a denial of where the club is at ?
Would Kerr minus Kosi and our first round draft pick help the club win a premiership against the likes of Geelong and Hawthorn?
Well at least that is plausible...The Saintsational Man wrote:St Kilda send Nick Dal Santo to Essendon.
Essendon send picks to West Coast.
West Coast send us Daniel Kerr.
You have to ask when are we aiming to have a crack at a flag?... do we want kerr?... what would they want/take for him?... kosi has really given us sfa and wont be missed.St Igmata wrote:Not much depth around and an ageing list without too much elite talent coming through and the club should hand over the first pick and a player for a guy that played 10 games this year?
Is this a denial of where the club is at ?
Would Kerr minus Kosi and our first round draft pick help the club win a premiership against the likes of Geelong and Hawthorn?
There are a few factors to consider.WayneJudson42 wrote:And will the status quo make us any better?St Igmata wrote:Not much depth around and an ageing list without too much elite talent coming through and the club should hand over the first pick and a player for a guy that played 10 games this year?
Is this a denial of where the club is at ?
Would Kerr minus Kosi and our first round draft pick help the club win a premiership against the likes of Geelong and Hawthorn?
Would not give a 1st round pick... unless you get one from another club.
If Kerr is out of contract, then WCE won't have much leverage IMO.
What they ask for and what they get... all talk and bluster.
Anyone who understands the first thing about negotiation will know that you start with the highest price... then work it down until you get a fair deal.
To say that there's no way we can get him... is ludicrous. If the club sees him as an important part of our future, and they believe that some of our better players are dispensible, they'll throw what they need to at WCE.
CJ to Freeo?SainterX wrote:Well I am sure there are plenty of WA boys in Melbourne who might not mind going home to play![]()
And a lot of sucker teams around who may just value our fringe players a little higher then we do
Wasn't aware of his contract TBH.St Igmata wrote:There are a few factors to consider.WayneJudson42 wrote:And will the status quo make us any better?St Igmata wrote:Not much depth around and an ageing list without too much elite talent coming through and the club should hand over the first pick and a player for a guy that played 10 games this year?
Is this a denial of where the club is at ?
Would Kerr minus Kosi and our first round draft pick help the club win a premiership against the likes of Geelong and Hawthorn?
Would not give a 1st round pick... unless you get one from another club.
If Kerr is out of contract, then WCE won't have much leverage IMO.
What they ask for and what they get... all talk and bluster.
Anyone who understands the first thing about negotiation will know that you start with the highest price... then work it down until you get a fair deal.
To say that there's no way we can get him... is ludicrous. If the club sees him as an important part of our future, and they believe that some of our better players are dispensible, they'll throw what they need to at WCE.
1) Kerr is under contract and his only option is not StKilda.
2)Would Kerr go to a club with no home ground training facilities?
3)You're dreaming if you think WC would let Kerr go for not much.
If Kerr and maybe Cousins came in we would have to get rid of 1.kaos theory wrote:IF we are to trade to get Kerr, then we must NOT trade away quality mids to get him. This will leave us back to where we started from.
I would not trade any of:
- Lenny
- Ball
- Dal
- Monty
- Gram
etc...
We need to ADD to this with more QUALITY mids.
Getting Kerr to add to this would be great, Getting Kerr & Cousins would be even better....