St Kilda depth vs Filth

[goods]

This is how I rate our team from most important to the other end of the scale:

Can someone show me the filth team and how they rate it, I want to see the depth in both teams I dont believe they have more quality than us as speculated in the media.

Also make changes to the numbering if you feel like it its just my opinion.


1) 12 Riewoldt
2) 18 Goddard
3) 7 Hayes
4) 26 Dal Santo
5) 11 Montagna
6) 1 Gram
7) 15 Gardiner
8) 13 Schneider
9) 19 Gilbert
10) 44 Milne
11) 10 Baker
12) 25 Fisher
13) 4 Jones
14) 40 Gwilt
15) 27 Blake
16) 30 Peake
17) 23 Koschitzke
18) 6 Dawson
19) 22 Ray
20) 40 Eddy
21) 5 McEvoy
22) 32 McQualter
23) 24 Dempster
24) 3 Steven
25) 14 Geary


*Inj. Raf.

[HSVKing]

IMO

1) 12 Riewoldt
2) 7 Hayes
3) 18 Goddard
4) 25 Fisher
5) 11 Montagna
6) 4 Jones
7) 44 Milne
8) 26 Dal Santo
9) 15 Gardiner
10) 5 McEvoy
11) 23 Koschitzke
12) 1 Gram
13) 13 Schneider
14) 19 Gilbert
15) 10 Baker
16) 22 Ray
17) 40 Gwilt
18) 27 Blake
19) 30 Peake
20) 6 Dawson
21) 40 Eddy
22) 32 McQualter
23) 24 Dempster
24) 3 Steven
25) 14 Geary


Collingwood

Scott Pendlebury
Alan Didak
Dane Swan
Heath Shaw
Travis Cloke
Darren Jolly
Dayne Beams
Luke Ball
Leigh Brown
Dale Thomas
Ben Johnson
Sharrod Wellingham
Jarryd Blair
Leon Davis
Alan Toovey
Brent Macaffer
Steele Sidebottom
Nick Maxwell
Harry O'Brien
Ben Reid
Chris Dawes
Tyson Goldsack
Nathan Brown
Josh Fraser
Paul Medhurst

[goods]

Thanks so out of those two teams, who are:

1) elite player
2) class player
3) workhorse
4) developing

[HSVKing]

Thanks so out of those two teams, who are:

1) elite player
2) class player
3) workhorse
4) developing

That would require an entirely different scale.

I put them in order of how important to the side they are. Either as a player who inspires the side, or who needs to fire for the side to succeed.

[goods]

Thanks so out of those two teams, who are:

1) elite player
2) class player
3) workhorse
4) developing

That would require an entirely different scale.

I put them in order of how important to the side they are. Either as a player who inspires the side, or who needs to fire for the side to succeed.

On my scale I would say

Elite 1-7
Class 8 - 16
Workhorse 17, 18, 19, 22, 23
Developing - 20, 21, 24, 25

I'm not sure the filth have a better list..