VOTES vs Collingwood

[Eastern]

5. L. Montagna

4. S. Fisher

3. B. Goddard

2. C. Jones

1. J. Geary

!!

[saintsrule]

5.Montagna
4.Fisher
3.Goddard
2.Gilbert
1.Hayes

[Moods]

It's a tough one today, for the wrong reasons sadly...

5. Hayes
4. Pattison
3. Fisher
2. Riewoldt
1. Steven

and some on here want him dropped for next week and favour Mac instead...

Patto has some rubbish said towards him for his whole time with us and it really is unwarranted IMO

For me..

5. Joey
4. CJ
3. Patto
2. Geary
1. BJ

I voted for consistency Lenny went missing in the first half

Fisher was a loose man in defence and he played well but had no opponent

Patto was our best ruck for the day and continues to improve IMO

15 disposals and 11 hitouts...

Has Big Mac ever done that?

But some here want him dropped and replaced with Mac...

WHY

Actually, Big Mac did better than that merely 1 week before, against the Lions, but yet was dropped... 16 disposals and a goal... Including a few strong contested marks...

Sure, Patto did him for hitouts, but the reality is they are of little significance...

I have nothing against Patto, but I dont really rate him either... But for some reason your seem to have a real dislike for Big Ben, which is unfair and unwarrented..

Clearly he is a talent and has more upside than Patto... Patto tries but will never be more than that, a trier... Ben could and should be a gun...

Perfectly summed up Sobraz

[Sainter_Dad]

98 Fisher
84 Montagna
61 Goddard
39 Hayes
27 Gwilt
26 Gilbert
17 Pattison
16 Jones
15 Geary
8 Steven
6 Gardiner
4 Peake
2 Riewoldt
1 Blake

Therefore:
5 Fisher
4 Montagna
3 Goddard
2 Hayes
1 Gwilt