INS & OUTS FOR ROUND 15

mohannair · Post: # 952889Post **mohannair** » Mon 05 Jul 2010 6:24pm

I think Gram may come in for next round. But not sure who will miss out. Also I think the Lions will be without both Fev & Brown.

dcstkfc · Post: # 952890Post **dcstkfc** » Mon 05 Jul 2010 6:26pm

Assume Dawson will stay for Fev.

If Grammy is ready he'll come in for Dempster, and Kosi will come in for Patto if he's ready.

Legendary · Post: # 952895Post **Legendary** » Mon 05 Jul 2010 6:59pm

Gram will play.

Kosi will also be back.

So need two outs.

Obviously Pattison. Second out? Someone will be very stiff. Personally I think Dawson, but he will stay.
So probably one of Geary or Dempster. Unless they rest Gardiner this week.

Thinline · Post: # 952896Post **Thinline** » Mon 05 Jul 2010 7:00pm

dcstkfc wrote:Assume Dawson will stay for Fev.

If Grammy is ready he'll come in for Dempster, and Kosi will come in for Patto if he's ready.

Fevless and Brownless is my mail.

Really, if ever a side was to succumb to our game plan, it is the Lions this week.

They don't have the leg speed to take on the corridor and they have no grunt up front.

Still, why do I think of it as a bit of a danger game?

meher baba · Post: # 952904Post **meher baba** » Mon 05 Jul 2010 7:15pm

How far away is Raph from playing again?

(I'm assuming he'll come back through the Zebras, but I'd be interested to know when this will be.)

borderbarry · Mon 05 Jul 2010 7:26pm

meher baba, Why is it assumed that Raph will come back via the Zebras, but Gram who has missed twice as many games doesnt, nor does Roo?

borderbarry · Mon 05 Jul 2010 7:28pm

Kosi and Gram back, Dawson (last man in, first man out), and Paterson out. If raph is ready, add Dempster to the outs.

saintslegendLH · Mon 05 Jul 2010 7:39pm

I've previously disliked dempster whenever he has played, and have always prefered eddy, but the last few matchs, while he has been in, ive been quite impressed with his form. i reckon he almost diserves to stay in the side infront of geary, even though i have loved geary's work for the last 2 years

AlpineStars · Mon 05 Jul 2010 7:50pm

In Rooey, Gramy, Kosi (I Hope)
Out Patto, Demo and Zaco.

Thinline · Post: # 952928Post **Thinline** » Mon 05 Jul 2010 8:19pm

In - Roo, Gram, Kosi
Out - Pattison, Geary, Dawson

If Roo's ready accg to the Doc then play him up there. Collingwood the following week will become a bloody circus otherwise.

Dempster's done enough to warrant ongoing faith. I strongly wish otherwise - I've tried mounting a case in my head - but Geary just hasn't.

saintly · Post: # 952937Post **saintly** » Mon 05 Jul 2010 8:37pm

In Gram, Kosi

Out Pattison, McQualter

Mcqualter again did not much except for laying a few tackles unlike round 13 where he played a good game.just becuase of their good form.
geary and dempster should stay ,

dawson will most likely stay a) becuase of Fev andb) becuase Lyon wants a proper full back to play on the big blokes. and he needs Dawson get some form in.

Milan Faletic · Mon 05 Jul 2010 8:43pm

dcstkfc wrote:Assume Dawson will stay for Fev.

If Grammy is ready he'll come in for Dempster, and Kosi will come in for Patto if he's ready.

Agree if Grammy and Kosi are ready. Maybe Geary out instead of Dempster

saint66au · Post: # 952959Post **saint66au** » Mon 05 Jul 2010 8:54pm

In: Roo, Kosi, Gram

Out: Stanley, Pattinson, Dempster

Was a tossup between Dempster and Geary, but I think Gram will play more half back and less midfield being his first game back..so can take Dempsters place. Geary is finding plenty of the footy and running to good areas, even if his decision making and disposal are letting him down too often.

Pattinson stays if, God forbid, Gardy doesnt come up.

Eastern · Post: # 952961Post **Eastern** » Mon 05 Jul 2010 8:57pm

I'm not sure you could justify dropping Dempster based on his form over the two weeks that he's been back in the side.

IN: Kosi, Grammy;

OUT: Patto, Mini or Gears

!!

stinger · Post: # 953055Post **stinger** » Tue 06 Jul 2010 12:22am

Eastern wrote:I'm not sure you could justify dropping Dempster based on his form over the two weeks that he's been back in the side.

...he can't kick...not sure we can afford him.....

SainterK · Post: # 953074Post **SainterK** » Tue 06 Jul 2010 12:58am

stinger wrote:
Eastern wrote:I'm not sure you could justify dropping Dempster based on his form over the two weeks that he's been back in the side.

...he can't kick...not sure we can afford him.....

Have loved his attack on the ball though, I seem to recall he saved a few players from being caught 'holding the ball' by ripping it out of there. The same aspect of Peake's game that has been so encouraging.

Shows that competition for spots is very much alive, and I don't envy the decision makers.

older saint · Tue 06 Jul 2010 11:05am

A no risk approach with injuries is clearly being taken therefore it would not surprise me to see:

In: Kosi,

Out: Gardiner,

If they play Gram straight in to the 1sts then i would think perhaps a Pattison may go out

RL has indicated he wants to get Zac games so he will stay. Geary maybe under pressure although does his role well and Peake and McQ have been much improved in the last few weeks.

My gut due to travel and the rock ground called the Gabba no Roo this week.

mohannair · Post: # 953174Post **mohannair** » Tue 06 Jul 2010 1:27pm

Aparently Roey to play against the Lions. This makes it very intresting. May be Kosi, Gram & Roey all in. That will force us to make 3 changes may be even 4 if Ralph is fit.

Good headace to have at this stage of the competition.

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/r ... 5888353210

TazzieSaintGirl83 · Tue 06 Jul 2010 1:43pm

Would be excellent to see Roo, Kosi and Gram all back in the side this week.
Hate to think of the boys who have to make way

No doubt we will have to wait till club takes all factors in to account ie fitness level, ground conditions etc before we know which way they will jump.

Ralphy · Post: # 953181Post **Ralphy** » Tue 06 Jul 2010 1:46pm

mohannair wrote:Aparently Roey to play against the Lions. This makes it very intresting. May be Kosi, Gram & Roey all in. That will force us to make 3 changes may be even 4 if Ralph is fit.

Good headace to have at this stage of the competition.

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/r ... 5888353210

Ralph? OH im playing am i?

Spinner · Post: # 953183Post **Spinner** » Tue 06 Jul 2010 1:57pm

In: Gram Riewoldt Koschitzke

Out: Patterson Stanley McQualter

Steven keeps his spot.

bigcarl · Post: # 953185Post **bigcarl** » Tue 06 Jul 2010 2:07pm

Spinner wrote:Steven keeps his spot.

he'd be pretty stiff to lose it. a star in the making.

Ralphy · Post: # 953186Post **Ralphy** » Tue 06 Jul 2010 2:08pm

Spinner wrote:In: Gram Riewoldt Koschitzke

Out: Patterson Stanley McQualter

Steven keeps his spot.

Yeah id go with this.

Thinline · Post: # 953189Post **Thinline** » Tue 06 Jul 2010 2:17pm

Ralphy wrote:
Spinner wrote:In: Gram Riewoldt Koschitzke

Out: Patterson Stanley McQualter

Steven keeps his spot.
Yeah id go with this.

Surely Mini's been better than Geary.

older saint · Tue 06 Jul 2010 2:30pm

If Roo plays i don't think Gram can come straight in.

We would then be bringing in 2 players which have not played for around 10 weeks each on a hard fast surface - huge chance of running out of legs in the last quarter.
Get some game time in to Gram in Sandy and bring him in the week after. puts more pressure also on Geary, McQ, Steven, Peake etc to continue to perform