Round 11 Team

St DAC · Post: # 936277Post **St DAC** » Thu 03 Jun 2010 6:11pm

St Kilda

B: Steven Baker, James Gwilt, Sam Gilbert
HB: Raphael Clarke, Sam Fisher, Jason Blake
C: Brendon Goddard, Nick Dal Santo, Farren Ray
HF: Clinton Jones, Rhys Stanley, Adam Schneider
F: Ben McEvoy, Justin Koschitzke, Stephen Milne
Foll: Michael Gardiner, Lenny Hayes, Leigh Montagna

I/C: Robert Eddy, Jarryn Geary, Andrew McQualter, Brett Peake
Emg: Adam Pattison, David Armitage, Jack Steven

In: Jarryn Geary
Out: Zac Dawson (ankle)

Richmond

B: Will Thursfield, Luke McGuane, Jake King
HB: Chris Newman, Brett Deledio, Shane Edwards
C: Richard Tambling, Ben Cousins, Jeromey Webberley
HF: Matt White, Jack Riewoldt, Ben Nason
F: Robin Nahas, Ben Griffiths, David Astbury
Foll: Angus Graham, Trent Cotchin, Dustin Martin
I/C: Mitch Farmer, Andrew Collins, Troy Simmonds, Shane Tuck
Emg: Mitch Morton, Alex Rance, Tyrone Vickery

In: Will Thursfield, Troy Simmonds
Out: Graham Polak, Kelvin Moore (leg)

plugger66 · Post: # 936280Post **plugger66** » Thu 03 Jun 2010 6:12pm

If nothing RL is consistant. A back out and a back in.

SainterK · Post: # 936282Post **SainterK** » Thu 03 Jun 2010 6:13pm

Welcome back Jarryn, well done to Peake Rhys and Eddy for continuing to hold their spot.

Milan Faletic · Thu 03 Jun 2010 6:13pm

plugger66 wrote:If nothing RL is consistant. A back out and a back in.

You nearly had it right with your Round 10 thread

saintspremiers · Thu 03 Jun 2010 6:14pm

Eddy still in?

The mind boggles!

saintlee · Post: # 936286Post **saintlee** » Thu 03 Jun 2010 6:15pm

saintspremiers wrote:Eddy still in?

The mind boggles!

I wouldn't say Eddy was shocking last week, but he would want to get a bit more of it this week or I reckon he will make way for Armo or Steven.

clarky449 · Post: # 936287Post **clarky449** » Thu 03 Jun 2010 6:21pm

I really hope Armo can make it back, is his contract up at years end?

plugger66 · Post: # 936288Post **plugger66** » Thu 03 Jun 2010 6:24pm

clarky449 wrote:I really hope Armo can make it back, is his contract up at years end?

I think it is his 4th year so you would think so.

realdeal · Post: # 936289Post **realdeal** » Thu 03 Jun 2010 6:25pm

Somewhat surprised that Armo misses again, would've thought that he'd shown alot more than Geary and Eddy have in their respective games this season..

Oh well, the coaches know best, lets see how they all go then..

saintly · Post: # 936290Post **saintly** » Thu 03 Jun 2010 6:31pm

clarky449 wrote:I really hope Armo can make it back, is his contract up at years end?

yes his contract is up at the end of the year.

Solar · Post: # 936291Post **Solar** » Thu 03 Jun 2010 6:34pm

if the team plays well then there is a good chance of no change going over for the freo game.

Armo needs to start working as hard as gears does in the VFL.

Solar · Post: # 936293Post **Solar** » Thu 03 Jun 2010 6:34pm

btw how the hell is pattison an emergency? He was TERRIBLE last week for sandy!

plugger66 · Post: # 936297Post **plugger66** » Thu 03 Jun 2010 6:50pm

Solar wrote:btw how the hell is pattison an emergency? He was TERRIBLE last week for sandy!

Yep Heyney must have done a bad job as the emergency who didnt play last week. Couldnt even make the 25 this week.

saintsrus · Post: # 936299Post **saintsrus** » Thu 03 Jun 2010 6:57pm

saintly wrote:
clarky449 wrote:I really hope Armo can make it back, is his contract up at years end?
yes his contract is up at the end of the year.

He will be at Gold Coast with Gazza

Ghost Like · Post: # 936300Post **Ghost Like** » Thu 03 Jun 2010 6:58pm

The 'revolving doors' dominate our bench...I thought this was an excellent opportunity to continue with Steven's development or pit Armo against an up and coming midfield, perhaps even test A. Smith in the real stuff, try Lynch as the lead up 3rd forward or let J. Smith feel the pace of AFL again.

Nothing against Geary, Eddy or Mcqualter but I just feel at times we are treading water with them in our side.

StPeter · Post: # 936301Post **StPeter** » Thu 03 Jun 2010 7:00pm

How does Eddy keep his place? If his game last week was enough to retain his place how bad does he have to play to lose it?
Seven possessions and 4 clangers says it all. But then this was up to his normal standard.

IluvHarvey · Post: # 936303Post **IluvHarvey** » Thu 03 Jun 2010 7:08pm

As Ross the Boss has shown quite a few times this year he will keep Players in for a few weeks before dropping them.

Saint Bev · Post: # 936312Post **Saint Bev** » Thu 03 Jun 2010 7:25pm

I can't believe everyone is so quick to write of Eddy, how many seasons has he played? And Geary, only very slightly more experienced.

Gee you people are alway going on about blooding players, I would have thought that was what we are doing. These guys are very young and inexperienced, they will not be champions overnight. For Gods sake, give them a fair go.

Seriously what is with people having a go at players all the time

bakes · Post: # 936315Post **bakes** » Thu 03 Jun 2010 7:28pm

Hi everyone,

I didn't watch the games last week, but everybody here seems to be judging Eddy on his low possession count. He is known for his large tank so I assume he played a midfield run-with type role.

Has anyone considered that he may have played a shut-down role on the opposition and perhaps did a very good job?

Like I said, I didn't watch the game, but let's just try and put performances into perspective by looking at which opposition player they played on, the quality of the opposition player, and their performance, before we judge.

I also watched last week's VFL game on TV and Armitage was the only player who looked up to AFL standard, however his endurance was questionable.

starsign · Post: # 936318Post **starsign** » Thu 03 Jun 2010 7:32pm

Ghost Like wrote:The 'revolving doors' dominate our bench...I thought this was an excellent opportunity to continue with Steven's development or pit Armo against an up and coming midfield, perhaps even test A. Smith in the real stuff, try Lynch as the lead up 3rd forward or let J. Smith feel the pace of AFL again.

Nothing against Geary, Eddy or Mcqualter but I just feel at times we are treading water with them in our side.

obviously they are not ready

the interchange is a vital component nowadays and too have "ifs" in there can put you straight behind the 8 ball if one or more aren't up to it or breakdown during the course of the game

good on them for having the virtue of patience with those you mention
and good on RL for his conservative steady format where team roles are paramount and " banking the 4 points" is the main aim

3rd generation saint · Thu 03 Jun 2010 7:37pm

Actually, losing Moore is bad for the Tigers.

35...LEGEND · Thu 03 Jun 2010 7:39pm

3rd generation saint wrote:Actually, losing Moore is bad for the Tigers.

KOSI !!!!............noone to stop the big fella.

bergholt · Post: # 936335Post **bergholt** » Thu 03 Jun 2010 7:51pm

bakes wrote:Has anyone considered that he may have played a shut-down role on the opposition and perhaps did a very good job?

he was at chf on bock in the first half, when bock had about 18 possessions. it looked like a shutdown job, but it also looked like he failed.

clarky449 · Post: # 936344Post **clarky449** » Thu 03 Jun 2010 8:04pm

bakes wrote:Hi everyone,

I didn't watch the games last week, but everybody here seems to be judging Eddy on his low possession count. He is known for his large tank so I assume he played a midfield run-with type role.

Has anyone considered that he may have played a shut-down role on the opposition and perhaps did a very good job?

Like I said, I didn't watch the game, but let's just try and put performances into perspective by looking at which opposition player they played on, the quality of the opposition player, and their performance, before we judge.

I also watched last week's VFL game on TV and Armitage was the only player who looked up to AFL standard, however his endurance was questionable.

Maybe it is Eddy's skill, he is a terrible kick. Also I think Armo has worked on his endurance as seen in a few games this year

IluvHarvey · Post: # 936350Post **IluvHarvey** » Thu 03 Jun 2010 8:09pm

Quick Raph has played a couple of good games....

Umm Dawson is injured.......

Who can I hate, I need to hate a saint mmmm........

I KNOW LETS ALL HATE EDDY!!!!

Blah Blah .... crap.......poor disposal....... blah blah blah.

Can someone please tell me if Eddy plays well who we can turn on next week????

It's almost time for Milnes turn again. GRRRRR MILNEY!!!!