McQualter has to go

[saintkid]

Couldn't help posting this from my phone. This guy's efforts so far today have been pathetic. He needs to be dropped. Armo is pretty average too but McQualter worse. Can't afford passengers not sharing the load.

[henno]

tend to agree but has schnieder been any better?

[joffaboy]

No Raph No Saints.

You lt got what you qwanted and we still lost.

Now its Mini's fault

[Buckets]

tend to agree but has schnieder been any better?

drop both. have been very poor all year the two of them. But that wont happen due to zac getting weeks. Will be 1 forced change and 1 omission at best.

[WinnersOnly]

Schneider must go first...both have been ordinary but I think Schneider has been terrible.

[Buckets]

No Raph No Saints.

You lt got what you qwanted and we still lost.

Now its Mini's fault

Ok JB out of that game other than Zac who will not be playing due to suspension who would you drop?

[BigMart]

JB - Raph got dropped last week because he was inept...

Mini and Zac will go this week...

[joffaboy]

JB - Raph got dropped last week because he was inept...

Mini and Zac will go this week...

Yes, but I've been told constantly that everything was Raphs fault, every single thing that occurs on the football field can be related to Raph.

All we had to do was drop Raph and our second flag was in the bag, what happened?

[joffaboy]

No Raph No Saints.

You lt got what you qwanted and we still lost.

Now its Mini's fault

Ok JB out of that game other than Zac who will not be playing due to suspension who would you drop?

If we had anyone to come in, which we dont, Schneider, Milne, McQualter, Dal Santo, Geary, and Ray.

None deserve a spot in the seniors, but everything is good cause Raph got dropped.

[jonesy]

No Raph No Saints.

You lt got what you qwanted and we still lost.

Now its Mini's fault

Ok JB out of that game other than Zac who will not be playing due to suspension who would you drop?

If we had anyone to come in, which we dont, Schneider, Milne, McQualter, Dal Santo, Geary, and Ray.

None deserve a spot in the seniors, but everything is good cause Raph got dropped.

Dal Santo? Fair dinkum...

[Buckets]

No Raph No Saints.

You lt got what you qwanted and we still lost.

Now its Mini's fault

Ok JB out of that game other than Zac who will not be playing due to suspension who would you drop?

If we had anyone to come in, which we dont, Schneider, Milne, McQualter, Dal Santo, Geary, and Ray.

None deserve a spot in the seniors, but everything is good cause Raph got dropped.

Dal Santo? Fair dinkum...

Was thinkin the same. He was alot better compared to last week.

[joffaboy]

No Raph No Saints.

You lt got what you qwanted and we still lost.

Now its Mini's fault

Ok JB out of that game other than Zac who will not be playing due to suspension who would you drop?

If we had anyone to come in, which we dont, Schneider, Milne, McQualter, Dal Santo, Geary, and Ray.

None deserve a spot in the seniors, but everything is good cause Raph got dropped.

Dal Santo? Fair dinkum...

Was thinkin the same. He was alot better compared to last week.

Yup Dal Santo.

I know he is a forum darling, but has been out of form for weeks and weeks.

He wont get dropped, either will most of the others because we have nobody at all pushing for selection.

[Spinner]

Has not elevated from last year.... Gone backwards if anything.


Needs to be dropped along with others.... But we'd only be replacing average players with average players.

[kaos theory]

Bring Steven for mini.

mini has been treading water all year. He lacks pace. Lat year his hardness, confidence and decision making kept him in the 22. This yr, that has droped off, and he has been exposed.

Steven will give as much hardness, but also more skill & pace than mini.

[saintkid]

Bring Steven for mini.

mini has been treading water all year. He lacks pace. Lat year his hardness, confidence and decision making kept him in the 22. This yr, that has droped off, and he has been exposed.

Steven will give as much hardness, but also more skill & pace than mini.

I agree, he is the most skillful option we have at Sandy and he is also faster which we badly need. Eddy tries hard but lacks too much skill to make a difference.

[SainterK]

What is annoying, is that Dal and Mini were promoted to the leadership group this year, and I assume it was because they have the ability to lead by example.

Maybe this will cause them to have another week, but I would actually like to see Eddy in for Mini.

[kalsaint]

Bring Steven for mini.

mini has been treading water all year. He lacks pace. Lat year his hardness, confidence and decision making kept him in the 22. This yr, that has droped off, and he has been exposed.

Steven will give as much hardness, but also more skill & pace than mini.

I agree, he is the most skillful option we have at Sandy and he is also faster which we badly need. Eddy tries hard but lacks too much skill to make a difference.

Loved Mini's 2009 effort but his tackle count has dropped massively so his effort is not effective now. Maybe someone else for a while is needed.

[battye]

What is annoying, is that Dal and Mini were promoted to the leadership group this year, and I assume it was because they have the ability to lead by example.

Maybe this will cause them to have another week, but I would actually like to see Eddy in for Mini.

Eddy is not the answer!

At least McQualter can kick a goal, but with all of the problems we have in our forward line he has hardly had an opportunity.

[3rd generation saint]

Hate to say this but Armitage is a worry too.
Just doesn't get the ball enough.

[SainterK]

What is annoying, is that Dal and Mini were promoted to the leadership group this year, and I assume it was because they have the ability to lead by example.

Maybe this will cause them to have another week, but I would actually like to see Eddy in for Mini.

Eddy is not the answer!

At least McQualter can kick a goal, but with all of the problems we have in our forward line he has hardly had an opportunity.

Can he though, 3 goals at the end of round 8?

I really like him, I am happy to be wrong if I am missing something because I never like to heap it on anyone.

[Hurricane]

Wont need to be dropped as it looks like his little head shot might get him a week or two holiday.

I am usually Mini's biggest fan and defender but he has been down recently but he certianly has not been the worst and he is not alone either.

If we drop Dawson, Schnider, Milne, Kosi, Dal, Gwilt and McEvoy......we replace them with who? Untried rookies? Players who are just making up the numbers at Sandy? Get real

BANG BANG

[battye]

What is annoying, is that Dal and Mini were promoted to the leadership group this year, and I assume it was because they have the ability to lead by example.

Maybe this will cause them to have another week, but I would actually like to see Eddy in for Mini.

Eddy is not the answer!

At least McQualter can kick a goal, but with all of the problems we have in our forward line he has hardly had an opportunity.

Can he though, 3 goals at the end of round 8?

I really like him, I am happy to be wrong if I am missing something because I never like to heap it on anyone.

Last year he was a solid one-goal-a-week contributor almost without fail.

Since Riewoldt has gone done the forward line has fallen apart - it's only been this week with Kosi looking to be something of a reliable target that the structure seemed to return somewhat. And it doesn't surprise me that as a result of it, McQualter got his 1 goal (by finding space much in the same fashion that he got most of his goals last year).

[SainterK]

What is annoying, is that Dal and Mini were promoted to the leadership group this year, and I assume it was because they have the ability to lead by example.

Maybe this will cause them to have another week, but I would actually like to see Eddy in for Mini.

Eddy is not the answer!

At least McQualter can kick a goal, but with all of the problems we have in our forward line he has hardly had an opportunity.

Can he though, 3 goals at the end of round 8?

I really like him, I am happy to be wrong if I am missing something because I never like to heap it on anyone.

Last year he was a solid one-goal-a-week contributor almost without fail.

Since Riewoldt has gone done the forward line has fallen apart - it's only been this week with Kosi looking to be something of a reliable target that the structure seemed to return somewhat. And it doesn't surprise me that as a result of it, McQualter got his 1 goal (by finding space much in the same fashion that he got most of his goals last year).

Fair enough, like I said, I am happy to be wrong.

[battye]

What is annoying, is that Dal and Mini were promoted to the leadership group this year, and I assume it was because they have the ability to lead by example.

Maybe this will cause them to have another week, but I would actually like to see Eddy in for Mini.

Eddy is not the answer!

At least McQualter can kick a goal, but with all of the problems we have in our forward line he has hardly had an opportunity.

Can he though, 3 goals at the end of round 8?

I really like him, I am happy to be wrong if I am missing something because I never like to heap it on anyone.

Last year he was a solid one-goal-a-week contributor almost without fail.

Since Riewoldt has gone done the forward line has fallen apart - it's only been this week with Kosi looking to be something of a reliable target that the structure seemed to return somewhat. And it doesn't surprise me that as a result of it, McQualter got his 1 goal (by finding space much in the same fashion that he got most of his goals last year).

Fair enough, like I said, I am happy to be wrong.

My post above is just how I see it.

I'm not saying you're wrong

[Saint Bev]

Mini has been average all year, bar for 5 minutes at the end of the Dogs game. 3 goals is not good enough and he makes way to many mistakes. Can't drop the whole team, but Mini needs a rest.