Who In PSD?

Batnoe · Post: # 849870Post **Batnoe** » Fri 16 Oct 2009 8:44pm

I think this year there will be a few players that will go in PSD, so i would assume we will save a pick to get someone

Who is worthy of a pick albeit we will be near the end, but some teams would rather kids, our window is now and we must pick up someone that will suit us

Players of note:
Bradshaw
Ball
McDonald
Tuck
Brown
Robertson
Buckley

I know there will be more, but does anyone else know any other players that will enter this draft that could be worth a punt?

ausfatcat · Post: # 849873Post **ausfatcat** » Fri 16 Oct 2009 8:58pm

we wont get anyone in the PSD.

skeptic · Post: # 849875Post **skeptic** » Fri 16 Oct 2009 9:14pm

Batnoe wrote:
Players of note:
Bradshaw
Ball
McDonald
Tuck
Brown
Robertson
Buckley

Luke?
He quits or is delisted and we redraft?

Batnoe · Post: # 849877Post **Batnoe** » Fri 16 Oct 2009 9:27pm

skeptic wrote:
Batnoe wrote:
Players of note:
Bradshaw
Ball
McDonald
Tuck
Brown
Robertson
Buckley
Luke?
He quits or is delisted and we redraft?

Just saying there are a few quality players, not that we will pick them up

We wont pick Luke if he quits obvioulsy

undecided · Post: # 849921Post **undecided** » Fri 16 Oct 2009 11:00pm

Buckely please.

Leo.J · Post: # 849936Post **Leo.J** » Fri 16 Oct 2009 11:31pm

Tennace?

kosifantutti23 · Fri 16 Oct 2009 11:36pm

Batnoe wrote:I think this year there will be a few players that will go in PSD, so i would assume we will save a pick to get someone

Who is worthy of a pick albeit we will be near the end, but some teams would rather kids, our window is now and we must pick up someone that will suit us

Players of note:
Bradshaw
Ball
McDonald
Tuck
Brown
Robertson
Buckley

I know there will be more, but does anyone else know any other players that will enter this draft that could be worth a punt?

I can think of quite a few but I'm going to start a new thread for each player who has been delisted.

MCG-Unit · Post: # 849938Post **MCG-Unit** » Fri 16 Oct 2009 11:37pm

Batnoe wrote:I think this year there will be a few players that will go in PSD, so i would assume we will save a pick to get someone

Who is worthy of a pick albeit we will be near the end, but some teams would rather kids, our window is now and we must pick up someone that will suit us

Players of note:
Bradshaw
Ball
McDonald
Tuck
Brown
Robertson
Buckley

I know there will be more, but does anyone else know any other players that will enter this draft that could be worth a punt?

If you mean Shane Tuck, I think he's still contracted for a year at Tigerland

Don't think the bigtime Hawker would tip out Travis Tuck

Iceman234 · Post: # 849939Post **Iceman234** » Fri 16 Oct 2009 11:38pm

kosifantutti23 wrote:
Batnoe wrote:I think this year there will be a few players that will go in PSD, so i would assume we will save a pick to get someone

Who is worthy of a pick albeit we will be near the end, but some teams would rather kids, our window is now and we must pick up someone that will suit us

Players of note:
Bradshaw
Ball
McDonald
Tuck
Brown
Robertson
Buckley

I know there will be more, but does anyone else know any other players that will enter this draft that could be worth a punt?
I can think of quite a few but I'm going to start a new thread for each player who has been delisted.

LOL too late methinks...

Milan Faletic · Sat 17 Oct 2009 2:28am

Leo.J wrote:Tennace?

Tenace

Schillaci · Post: # 849982Post **Schillaci** » Sat 17 Oct 2009 7:14am

Batnoe wrote:I think this year there will be a few players that will go in PSD, so i would assume we will save a pick to get someone

Who is worthy of a pick albeit we will be near the end, but some teams would rather kids, our window is now and we must pick up someone that will suit us

Players of note:
Bradshaw
Ball
McDonald
Tuck
Brown
Robertson
Buckley

I know there will be more, but does anyone else know any other players that will enter this draft that could be worth a punt?

Jonathan Brown.

Brisbane no room for him and Bradshaw with the Fev eh?

Batnoe · Post: # 850050Post **Batnoe** » Sat 17 Oct 2009 12:22pm

Jesse Smith

Daniel Harris

SaintHomer · Post: # 850635Post **SaintHomer** » Mon 19 Oct 2009 6:01pm

Batnoe wrote:I think this year there will be a few players that will go in PSD, so i would assume we will save a pick to get someone

Who is worthy of a pick albeit we will be near the end, but some teams would rather kids, our window is now and we must pick up someone that will suit us

Players of note:
Bradshaw
Ball
McDonald
Tuck
Brown
Robertson
Buckley

I know there will be more, but does anyone else know any other players that will enter this draft that could be worth a punt?

there seems to be a common denominator here.... injury

bradshaw - carry some and in the later part of his career
ball - hampered the past 3 years or so
brown - didn't play a lot this year
robertson - has had plenty as well

i'm still undecided if we should keep ball, but wouldn't touch the other three (or harris, or smith, or tenace)

most are delisted and there for a reason...

WinnersOnly · Mon 19 Oct 2009 6:18pm

IMO Scott Harding Brisbane Lions is the man we should target. Would give us run and carry, can play inside or out and has pace and kicks long goals. I think he suffered at the Lions through not having a consistent go at it. I cant believe they delisted him ???

If he is not available then McDONALD or TENACE would provide good depth to our medium sized mids....

plugger66 · Post: # 850669Post **plugger66** » Mon 19 Oct 2009 7:09pm

Dont think we will get PSD pick.

St Fidelius · Mon 19 Oct 2009 7:37pm

plugger66 wrote:Dont think we will get PSD pick.

agreed.

We have picked up two players from other Clubs and I feel we will look at youth in draft picks and rookies

SainterK · Post: # 850709Post **SainterK** » Mon 19 Oct 2009 8:51pm

Not sure if it's true, but I think Nathan Brown has now retired off that list?

Thinline · Post: # 850715Post **Thinline** » Mon 19 Oct 2009 9:04pm

WinnersOnly wrote:IMO Scott Harding Brisbane Lions is the man we should target. Would give us run and carry, can play inside or out and has pace and kicks long goals. I think he suffered at the Lions through not having a consistent go at it. I cant believe they delisted him ???

If he is not available then McDONALD or TENACE would provide good depth to our medium sized mids....

Agree, although I reckon Tenace will wind up in amateurs or something. Some guys just aren't quite good enough.

McDonald and Harding would both be good but you;d reckon they'd be gone before we got a chance at them.

Milan Faletic · Mon 19 Oct 2009 9:09pm

Depends a lot on Ball.

If we lose Ball, we may take McDonald if no one else takes him. I reckon Hawthorn will get him. They need him more than us.

I have a feeling the recruitment guys have one surprise up their sleeves.

Hurricane · Post: # 851274Post **Hurricane** » Wed 21 Oct 2009 9:14am

Milan Faletic wrote:
Leo.J wrote:Tennace?
Tenace

I reckon he will go in teh national draft. Late pick

I dont think we will enter the PSD, IMHO our National Draft will be uneventful as it is with our list looking pretty good for 2010

BANG BANG

borderbarry · Wed 21 Oct 2009 11:43am

I am sure that we have enough recycled players now.

Mr Magic · Post: # 851309Post **Mr Magic** » Wed 21 Oct 2009 11:47am

borderbarry wrote:I am sure that we have enough recycled players now.

So I take it that you wouldn't be interested in any more if they managed to appear in future years, unless we delist some of those we already have?

ace · Post: # 851357Post **ace** » Wed 21 Oct 2009 1:44pm

Should we really be contemplating taking the 15th best reject/rebel in the pre-season draft.
14 other clubs overlooked him or did not want him but St Kilda does.
Who are you kidding.

St Kilda will not participate in the pre-season draft except if they use it to have another look at which youngsters remain after the national draft.

Who In PSD?

Who In PSD?

Re: Who In PSD?

Re: Who In PSD?

Re: Who In PSD?

Re: Who In PSD?

Re: Who In PSD?

Re: Who In PSD?

Re: Who In PSD?

Draft Scott HARDING...

Re: Draft Scott HARDING...