Maguire + McQualter + Geary + Gwilt?

[bigred]

This sounds like a plan that will surely provide years of security and on field success for St Kilda.

Bugger it, lets throw in Jack Steven just to sweeten the deal.

[BaysideSaint]

This sounds like a plan that will surely provide years of security and on field success for St Kilda.

Bugger it, lets throw in Jack Steven just to sweeten the deal.

or we could just say that our final offer is raphael and xavier.

[xander]

which premiership would that be again? oh yeah, that one.
we have a LOT of other guys that can come in .. mcevoys, armitages, etc etc etc etc..
our list is endless at this point we need to give a bit if we were to want.
i would take 55 from fev and five in a grand final and so would he.

Well that was an embarrassing error...
Anyway so you pretty much think that since we have such a huge list we can throw 4 guys to carlton to get fev. And if we want Lovett we can trade Raph, Dempster, Heyne & Stanley?
Sorry to tell this to you but clubs want quality not quantity. Carlton may be cheats but even they cannot sneak an extra 3 guys onto the field.

[vacuous space]

Sorry to tell this to you but clubs want quality not quantity.

My guess is the first priority for Carlton in any deal with us would be Tom Lynch. They're not overly in need of mids, they need KP talent - and that's before considering they're losing Fev. We don't have a lot to give in that area.

[st.byron]

FFS Bayside Saint. Get rid of Geary and Mini for a 29 year old with 2 or 3 seasons left in him- pfft! So much for develpoing young fellas.

[Iceman234]

What a bizarre OP.

[BaysideSaint]

FFS Bayside Saint. Get rid of Geary and Mini for a 29 year old with 2 or 3 seasons left in him- pfft! So much for develpoing young fellas.

yeah good point.

[matrix]