Saintsational Fan Forum - A passionate community of St Kilda Football Club fans discussing news, history, players, trade rumours, results, AFL stats and more.
WESTERN BULLDOGS
B: Jarrod Harbrow, Brian Lake, Ryan Hargrave
HB: Liam Picken, Dale Morris, Lindsay Gilbee
C: Shaun Higgins, Matthew Boyd, Daniel Cross
HF: Brad Johnson, Mitch Hahn, Robert Murphy
F: Jason Akermanis, Will Minson, Scott Welsh
Foll: Ben Hudson, Adam Cooney, Ryan Griffen
Int: Tim Callan, Nathan Eagleton, Daniel Giansiracusa, Callan Ward
Emg: Dylan Addison, Andrejs Everitt, Josh Hill
In: Callan
Out: Hill
BRISBANE
B: Ashley McGrath, Daniel Merrett, James Hawksley
HB: Joel Patfull, Josh Drummond, Jed Adcock
C: Jared Brennan, Simon Black, Daniel Rich
HF: Michael Rischitelli, Jonathan Brown, James Polkinghorne
F: Sam Sheldon, Daniel Bradshaw, Tim Notting
Foll: Mitch Clark, Luke Power, Justin Sherman
Int: Rhan Hooper, Matt Austin, Travis Johnstone, Jack Redden
Emg: Bradd Dalziell, Joel Macdonald, Cheynee Stiller
In: Josh Drummond, Jed Adcock, Tim Notting
Out: Jason Roe (omit), Cheynee Stiller (omit), Scott Harding (foot)
I have a feeling that we might be playing Brisbane...
What are your thoughts
Last edited by St Fidelius on Thu 10 Sep 2009 10:14pm, edited 1 time in total.
Don't wait for the light at the end of the tunnel to appear, run down there and light the bloody thing yourself!
saint66au wrote:nah its all good..one of em will be playing us in a prelim final next week so it can stay
Drummond and Adcock are huge ins for Brissy. Might be a bit closer than I thought
Still reckon the Doggies might be a shade too good. Brissy pretty sore after that game last week..plus factor in travel and a 6 day break
The Lions in Reincarnated's opinion. The dogs have no good tall forward, one average ruckman and a below average vfl ruckman
Yeah, Mitch Clark is in good form and if Drummond and Adcock hold up I just have a feeling that we will play Brisbane in the Prelim.
I hope Max gets a gig on Bradshaw if Brisbane win
So you are happy for Zac to be dropped. Surely he has done as well if not better than max this year and deserves a crack at bradshaw.
Even if we did not have Max in reserve Reincarnated would be crapping his/her's/gt's pants with the idea of Zac lining up on either of those players ever again
saint66au wrote:nah its all good..one of em will be playing us in a prelim final next week so it can stay
Drummond and Adcock are huge ins for Brissy. Might be a bit closer than I thought
Still reckon the Doggies might be a shade too good. Brissy pretty sore after that game last week..plus factor in travel and a 6 day break
The Lions in Reincarnated's opinion. The dogs have no good tall forward, one average ruckman and a below average vfl ruckman
Yeah, Mitch Clark is in good form and if Drummond and Adcock hold up I just have a feeling that we will play Brisbane in the Prelim.
I hope Max gets a gig on Bradshaw if Brisbane win
So you are happy for Zac to be dropped. Surely he has done as well if not better than max this year and deserves a crack at bradshaw.
Even if we did not have Max in reserve Reincarnated would be crapping his/her's/gt's pants with the idea of Zac lining up on either of those players ever again
saint66au wrote:nah its all good..one of em will be playing us in a prelim final next week so it can stay
Drummond and Adcock are huge ins for Brissy. Might be a bit closer than I thought
Still reckon the Doggies might be a shade too good. Brissy pretty sore after that game last week..plus factor in travel and a 6 day break
The Lions in Reincarnated's opinion. The dogs have no good tall forward, one average ruckman and a below average vfl ruckman
Yeah, Mitch Clark is in good form and if Drummond and Adcock hold up I just have a feeling that we will play Brisbane in the Prelim.
I hope Max gets a gig on Bradshaw if Brisbane win
So you are happy for Zac to be dropped. Surely he has done as well if not better than max this year and deserves a crack at bradshaw.
Even if we did not have Max in reserve Reincarnated would be crapping his/her's/gt's pants with the idea of Zac lining up on either of those players ever again
What did he do wrong last time on Bradshaw.
Bradshaw was moved to fullback to assist against Roo and Kosi as the Lions had concerns.
Zac has looked increasingly lost in games as the year as progressed. He too easily loses his man in and out of traffic, this is not a good thing
plugger66 wrote:
Then it must be Blake because we will not play Blake, Zac and max in the same side again this year.
RL stated the Max is still a chance this year in playing.
I believe that Brisbane is the side that RL was thinking about (just my opinion)
Brisbane is a far taller side than the Bulldogs and maybe all those three will play at the expense of may be Eddy or Clarke.
So please tell me why you think that we will not play Blake, Zac and max in the same side again this year???
It surely depends on match ups and I feel that Max is more suited to Bradshaw than Zac and that Zac is more suited to Notting
If Max is suited to Bradshaw then Zac will not play. He isnt going to play on Notting. They will not have those 3 in the same side again. It stops our run from the backline.
plugger66 wrote:
Then it must be Blake because we will not play Blake, Zac and max in the same side again this year.
RL stated the Max is still a chance this year in playing.
I believe that Brisbane is the side that RL was thinking about (just my opinion)
Brisbane is a far taller side than the Bulldogs and maybe all those three will play at the expense of may be Eddy or Clarke.
So please tell me why you think that we will not play Blake, Zac and max in the same side again this year???
It surely depends on match ups and I feel that Max is more suited to Bradshaw than Zac and that Zac is more suited to Notting
If Max is suited to Bradshaw then Zac will not play. He isnt going to play on Notting. They will not have those 3 in the same side again. It stops our run from the backline.
Well that's your opinion and good on you, but I feel that if Brisbane wins Max may get his chance.
I really don't see any other match up that RL was referring to.
Maybe we will just have to wait and see who wins and take it from there
Don't wait for the light at the end of the tunnel to appear, run down there and light the bloody thing yourself!
Not a bad side the Lions have put in,whether they all play is another thing. If they're 100% fit then they are capable of pulling one out of the hat and winning this if the dogs choke.
However I expect the dogs to win by about 40.....if so hopefully 3-4 key injuries in the process. Namely Cross,Higgins,Akermanis and Lake
I'm still thinkin the dogs.... it looks more likely that the crows will beat the pies too, and hopefully soften up but not beat the cats in the prelim.
No doubt that on papaer the Bulldogs should win, and thats where my money will be. Brisbane are not without their chances of course, there good players are very capable of having a huge impact, Brown, Bradshaw, Black, Power, Rich, Johnstone, Sherman, Adcock and Drummond. Handy names.
Hill getting dropped was a surprise to me, thought he pulled out of a couple of contests last week but was to important to drop. A lot of people had him as an important impact player for the doggies finals campaign???
They experienced a loss against Geelong in a final last week, and will be desperate to redeem themselves in the knowledge that their coach's head will explode if they don't.
I personally think the Dogs, maybe a little too quick for Brisbane (though I admit I haven't really watched Brisbane this year) and both teams tend to finish well so I think Dogs will get up at the startand Lions probably won't be able to catch them after that.
