Love Raph ... he can seriously play.
Happy to argue against anyone who thinks otherwise.
Raph Clarke?
Moderators: Saintsational Administrators, Saintsational Moderators
-
LondonSaint
- Club Player
- Posts: 61
- Joined: Tue 24 Mar 2009 12:58am
It's a touchy topic indeed. Raph has been a whipping boy on this forum for a while (sometimes for good reason I might add).. At the moment the boy is playing ok, so, any negativity towards him is unwarranted.. especially when Gwilt and Maxy have not set the world on fire either.
To me, Raph is a frustrating talent.
Strength:
- can read the play quite well? that's why he's often the loose man down back.
- can provide run and carry
- reasonable skills when there is no pressure.
- finals experience (he plays better as a loose man.. )
- Good height.. however, he is in between sizes.. not tall enough to play a key position, not quick enough to play on a crumber, leading small forward)
Weakness
- Go to ground a fair bit, not strong enough?
- Not overly accountable (often see him trailing behind his man at marking contest)
- Contested ball? (our other backs all can win contested ball very well (Fisher, Glibert, Ray even Blake)
- decision making, skills can be very suspect when under pressure (this is highlighted even more in a backman.. Blake has improved in this area out of sight in my opinion)
I think a lot of Raph's weaknesses are masked when he's playing the loose man.. although when he does make mistakes, it's magnified because they often lead to goals unfortunately..
He can definitely improve as a player.. and if we have a solid rebounding small back in the mould of Wirrapunda, Hodge, Gilbee, Raph wouldn't be playing..
So, that's Raph in a nut shell.. I will be shouted down no doubt.. look at this as highlighting areas Raph can improve on.. Hopefully he can.. after 6 years and only 53 games to his name.. he needs to and do it quickly.
To me, Raph is a frustrating talent.
Strength:
- can read the play quite well? that's why he's often the loose man down back.
- can provide run and carry
- reasonable skills when there is no pressure.
- finals experience (he plays better as a loose man.. )
- Good height.. however, he is in between sizes.. not tall enough to play a key position, not quick enough to play on a crumber, leading small forward)
Weakness
- Go to ground a fair bit, not strong enough?
- Not overly accountable (often see him trailing behind his man at marking contest)
- Contested ball? (our other backs all can win contested ball very well (Fisher, Glibert, Ray even Blake)
- decision making, skills can be very suspect when under pressure (this is highlighted even more in a backman.. Blake has improved in this area out of sight in my opinion)
I think a lot of Raph's weaknesses are masked when he's playing the loose man.. although when he does make mistakes, it's magnified because they often lead to goals unfortunately..
He can definitely improve as a player.. and if we have a solid rebounding small back in the mould of Wirrapunda, Hodge, Gilbee, Raph wouldn't be playing..
So, that's Raph in a nut shell.. I will be shouted down no doubt.. look at this as highlighting areas Raph can improve on.. Hopefully he can.. after 6 years and only 53 games to his name.. he needs to and do it quickly.
<shrug> we are doing really well this year and all folks can do is find fault with everything.
I understand criticism when we are s***, god knows i've been there, but im really enjoing this year and the misery of our foes
I understand criticism when we are s***, god knows i've been there, but im really enjoing this year and the misery of our foes
Bewaire krime, da krimson bolt is comeing to yure nayborhood to smach krime
SHUT UP KRIME!
SHUT UP KRIME!
-
Bernard Shakey
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 11240
- Joined: Sun 18 Mar 2007 11:22pm
- Location: Down By The River 1989, 2003, 2009 & 2013
- Has thanked: 126 times
- Been thanked: 137 times
-
LondonSaint
- Club Player
- Posts: 61
- Joined: Tue 24 Mar 2009 12:58am
Dan,
I understand what you are saying. Negativity for negativity sake is not constructive.. especially when the team is playing unbelievable football (albeit the last two weeks). I am more than satisfied with the team's performance and really enjoying it.. (getting up 7/8 am on the weekend to watch the boys live has never felt so good, i'm in London btw).
Even if we don't win the premiership.. i'm happy.. (will be dissapointed obviously at first)... this is because winning a premiership requires a lot of things going for you.. a good team, luck (draw), injury among other things.. so, we can only do the best we can.. this team has came a long way.. and is playing team football for the first time in years.. having said that we need to grab the chance while we can.. just look at Hawthorn.
I was just trying to analyse why Raph has been such a maligned player among supporters... i think the fact that he is a top 10 pick, have been inconsistent (53 games in 6 years) and some decision making had a lot to do with it.. but no one's perfect.. so, Hopeflly i didn't come across as too negative and Raph can improve from here and star for us in the finals.
Go Saints.
I understand what you are saying. Negativity for negativity sake is not constructive.. especially when the team is playing unbelievable football (albeit the last two weeks). I am more than satisfied with the team's performance and really enjoying it.. (getting up 7/8 am on the weekend to watch the boys live has never felt so good, i'm in London btw).
Even if we don't win the premiership.. i'm happy.. (will be dissapointed obviously at first)... this is because winning a premiership requires a lot of things going for you.. a good team, luck (draw), injury among other things.. so, we can only do the best we can.. this team has came a long way.. and is playing team football for the first time in years.. having said that we need to grab the chance while we can.. just look at Hawthorn.
I was just trying to analyse why Raph has been such a maligned player among supporters... i think the fact that he is a top 10 pick, have been inconsistent (53 games in 6 years) and some decision making had a lot to do with it.. but no one's perfect.. so, Hopeflly i didn't come across as too negative and Raph can improve from here and star for us in the finals.
Go Saints.
-
bobmurray
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 7910
- Joined: Mon 03 Oct 2005 11:08pm
- Location: In the stand at RSEA Park.
- Has thanked: 538 times
- Been thanked: 244 times
He should have drank more then he would have caredThe Fireman wrote:Must admit George never got aggressive even when Eric nicked his wife.bobmurray wrote:sometimes it's quite obvious people are posting after a few frothies..
they are normally aggressive........
Will we pick up a player in the SSP window 
-
Sainterman
- Club Player
- Posts: 1497
- Joined: Wed 24 Mar 2004 11:45am
Raph has been getting better every week. Usually takes him a few games on end to get going. IMO he was our best player in last years finals series, and there are plenty of reasons to have him there. He certainly isn't slow, i think it is his running style that makes people think this.
Playing in defence highlights any errors so when he makes one it does stand out. He is still relatively young and I think he has his best footy in front of him. Happy with him in the side and think he adds run and carry, and breaks the lines from time time too.
Maybe this all makes me part of the pro Raph group, just can't see why he is constantly singled out.
Playing in defence highlights any errors so when he makes one it does stand out. He is still relatively young and I think he has his best footy in front of him. Happy with him in the side and think he adds run and carry, and breaks the lines from time time too.
Maybe this all makes me part of the pro Raph group, just can't see why he is constantly singled out.
clarky449 wrote:Directed to Joffa boy buddy, how do you know he is a troll, he asked why does Ross Lyon pick Raph over Gwilt etc, i dont think that is being a troll. Some of you need to get there head out of there ass and stop thinking you own this site.stinger wrote:you can join him..if you think it is okay for a f****** troll to come on here and bag raph....clarky449 wrote:You have no right to tell this poster to piss off and die, you are not more important and if they want to come on here well it is up to them.
ps...and you have no right to try and correct me.... and......where did i actually tell him to die...although i wish i had thought of that first....
including you it would seem......wtf did i say that i owned this site......i am sick to death of idiots coming on here with the sole intention of bagging raph
sorry about the mistake though...i don't normally read jb's posts so i missed that..........
oh.and..he's a troll alright.....but ..as you say it's a free forum ..so i don't have to answer to you or give you an explanation......
Last edited by stinger on Sat 29 Aug 2009 12:47am, edited 2 times in total.
.everybody still loves lenny....and we always will
"Freedom of expression is the cornerstone of a free society,"
However, freedom of expression is not encouraged in certain forums.
"Freedom of expression is the cornerstone of a free society,"
However, freedom of expression is not encouraged in certain forums.
-
asiu
some of us might wanna slow down , express clearlySome of you need to get there head out of there ass and stop thinking you own this site.
then , pick the biggest target and go hard young man
the site needs more larger than life characters ....
i told the ex mother in law that , no , thats not quite true ...i actually told her to stick her head up her arse...talk about the death look from the him reamer ....fair dinkum , what a pillick....
oh yea , nice read londonsaint ...ta
-
ralphsmith
- SS Hall of Fame
- Posts: 2420
- Joined: Sat 25 Jul 2009 10:36pm
- Has thanked: 3 times
- Been thanked: 17 times