Who will be the most improved player for 2005?

Tue 01 Mar 2005 4:40pm

You can vote here and on the homepage at www.saintsational.com

If there's a question you would like to see in next week's poll just send a PM to me and I'll pick one each week.

Only players with between one and 40 games have been listed.

Personally, I think Montagna will be very keen to earn a spot in the side each week and since he has bulked up over the pre-season he could be in for a great year.

sainterforlife · Tue 01 Mar 2005 4:51pm

Sorry, to tough.

....all of them!

Moose · Post: # 79734Post **Moose** » Tue 01 Mar 2005 6:26pm

sainterforlife wrote:Sorry, to tough.
....all of them!

Gees, seeing I'm the second vote cast, it's not hard to see who you voted for.

St Fidelius · Post: # 79944Post **St Fidelius** » Wed 02 Mar 2005 7:27pm

Well on pre season form, I would have to say Fiora, but he is not an option

saintbrat · Post: # 79945Post **saintbrat** » Wed 02 Mar 2005 7:37pm

St Fidelius wrote:Well on pre season form, I would have to say Fiora, but he is not an option

hehehehe

too true Fid

oversight?
as ackland and Mcgough are?

I agree with s4l too hard

riccardo · Post: # 79980Post **riccardo** » Wed 02 Mar 2005 9:10pm

The dude on the left!

As long as those in charge of depressing injuries lose his casefile, that is!

poochy · Post: # 80201Post **poochy** » Fri 04 Mar 2005 8:10am

Surpised not too see Fiora or Bj on this poll?

Fri 04 Mar 2005 8:12am

poochy wrote:Surpised not too see Fiora or Bj on this poll?

Only players with between one and 40 games have been listed... Fiora - 78, Goddard - 42.

Munga · Post: # 80255Post **Munga** » Fri 04 Mar 2005 3:16pm

Gram if the poor bugga can stay on the park!

Sam23 · Post: # 80524Post **Sam23** » Sat 05 Mar 2005 2:32pm

Agree with Munga.

HydePark · Post: # 81142Post **HydePark** » Mon 07 Mar 2005 5:47pm

I am surprised that Murray only has 2% thus far...
I reckon he will be the big improver this year, he saw the big wins last year and he will definitely work very very hard to be a part of the success this year; he's been there long enough. A few years ago Andrew Thompson was at the crossroads but he re-invented (hate that word) himself and is a valuable member of the team. Murray could be the same.
All the young talent will keep the pressure on him to be better and better.

evertonfc · Post: # 462562Post **evertonfc** » Mon 24 Sep 2007 2:07pm

4/11 thus far have kicked on, and we were questioning them at the start of 2005 (effectively three years ago by the start of next year's pre-season).

A fair indicator of how little we've managed to develop our list and make progress in three years of football?

I think most of us would have been hoping for 60-70% success rate by now. A few have dropped off and still, too many remain unproven.

st_Trav_ofWA · Mon 24 Sep 2007 2:09pm

3 i count 4 in our rgular side
joey
fish
chips
grammy

Sam23 · Post: # 462572Post **Sam23** » Mon 24 Sep 2007 2:18pm

+ you could argue Raph Clarke?

evertonfc · Post: # 462577Post **evertonfc** » Mon 24 Sep 2007 2:22pm

st_Trav_ofWA wrote:3 i count 4 in our rgular side
joey
fish
chips
grammy

Corrected - although I originally left out L Fisher because whilst he might have played quite a few games, he hasn't really kicked on to be part of our first choice 22. With a full pre-season, that might change in 2008. Hope so.

And no, Sam23, Raph Clarke cannot be included yet, but I fancy he will make it.

I suppose the point of digging up this thread - just saw it whilst perusing - is to ascertain how well we have rejuvanated our list over a three year cycle, given we've just lost a whole stack of players crucial to our 2004-05 camapign.

markinUSA · Post: # 463071Post **markinUSA** » Tue 25 Sep 2007 6:16am

The poll is still open... I'd like people to change the results. Let's all vote for Alan Murray!

ben_fff · Post: # 463177Post **ben_fff** » Tue 25 Sep 2007 11:42am

I voted for Nick Stone yesterday, noone believed in him! LOOK AT HIM NOW!