Gardiner out?

Wolfpak · Post: # 777359Post **Wolfpak** » Sat 18 Jul 2009 3:44pm

Heard on sen that GArdiner could be out of Stklida Team. Any confirmations?

Nattens · Post: # 777361Post **Nattens** » Sat 18 Jul 2009 3:45pm

Wolfpak wrote:Heard on sen that GArdiner could be out of Stklida Team. Any confirmations?

I confirm that he will play since your source saying otherwise is SEN.

I heard that on Triple J earlier.

mick13 · Post: # 777363Post **mick13** » Sat 18 Jul 2009 3:46pm

Eek. He was having a lot of work done on his legs last week. May be purely precautionary. With Edwards and VB out we may feel more comfortable dropping him, specially with King back and their lack of decent rucks...

Still...if it's true, hopefully just to rest him.

Wolfpak · Post: # 777364Post **Wolfpak** » Sat 18 Jul 2009 3:46pm

i hope so. No reason why he wouldn't play

jonesy · Post: # 777366Post **jonesy** » Sat 18 Jul 2009 3:56pm

Someone said his hammy was being iced at training wednesday. Thought that sounded a bit dodgy at the time

ausfatcat · Post: # 777367Post **ausfatcat** » Sat 18 Jul 2009 4:00pm

I think when people quote stuff from SEN they should stipulate where from at SEN.

a commentator?
News report
or rumor file

Obvious a news report it would have a lot merit behind and commentator makes it a possibility but from the rumor file makes it absolutely worthless.

evertonfc · Post: # 777369Post **evertonfc** » Sat 18 Jul 2009 4:03pm

ausfatcat wrote:I think when people quote stuff from SEN they should stipulate where from at SEN.

a commentator?
News report
or rumor file

Obvious a news report it would have a lot merit behind and commentator makes it a possibility but from the rumor file makes it absolutely worthless.

Good call.

asiu · Post: # 777372Post **asiu** » Sat 18 Jul 2009 4:08pm

Good call.

2nd'd

evertonfc · Post: # 777377Post **evertonfc** » Sat 18 Jul 2009 4:12pm

gazrat wrote:
Good call.

2nd'd

Motion passed. When referring to SEN, please state if it's a presenter/reporter or caller putting the information out there.

A lot of talkback gets passed off as "being on SEN".

ausfatcat · Post: # 777378Post **ausfatcat** » Sat 18 Jul 2009 4:12pm

maybe even put it in the rules?

Wolfpak · Post: # 777412Post **Wolfpak** » Sat 18 Jul 2009 5:58pm

who gives a stuff where it come from, was mentioned.. in fact i hope im right so u can doublt all other calls

asiu · Post: # 777415Post **asiu** » Sat 18 Jul 2009 6:00pm

ausfatcat · Post: # 777419Post **ausfatcat** » Sat 18 Jul 2009 6:14pm

Wolfpak wrote:who gives a stuff where it come from, was mentioned.. in fact i hope im right so u can doublt all other calls

We all do some people ring up SEN and say some ludicrous things (like everytime the saints have a big game someone rings up and say he is out), where in SEN it comes from is important if it was a commentator has a lot more credance than a random person that rings up with wishful thiking.

The Saintsational Man · Sat 18 Jul 2009 6:17pm

Wolfpak wrote:who gives a stuff where it come from, was mentioned.. in fact i hope im right so u can doublt all other calls

Calm down rookie.

saintsRrising · Sat 18 Jul 2009 6:22pm

Wolfpak wrote:
who gives a stuff where it come from,

Anyone with any common sense...for as already posted by others one can assess how accurate the "mention" was by the credibility of the source.

Wolfpak wrote:
was mentioned.. in fact i hope im right so u can doublt all other calls

Whether the source was "right' or not is irrelevant to your statement.

As already asked who "mentioned" it... a caller.... a panelist.....a guest medico...Ross Lyon?

Junior · Post: # 777427Post **Junior** » Sat 18 Jul 2009 6:38pm

No idea if he is playing or not, but worth noting that on Thursday McEvoy was dropped out of the team not even in the squad.

Last night however when the final team was announced he was all of a sudden listed as an emergency.

My guess would be that Gardiner must be at least under an injury cloud, why else would they bring McEvoy into the 25?

St Fidelius · Sat 18 Jul 2009 7:06pm

saintsRrising wrote:
Wolfpak wrote:
who gives a stuff where it come from,

Anyone with any common sense...for as already posted by others one can assess how accurate the "mention" was by the credibility of the source.

Wolfpak wrote:
was mentioned.. in fact i hope im right so u can doublt all other calls
Whether the source was "right' or not is irrelevant to your statement.

As already asked who "mentioned" it... a caller.... a panelist.....a guest medico...Ross Lyon?

I have no problem with Wolfpak starting this thread, but I agree with sRs...

If you are going to start up a thread please state just who mentioned it...

Yes Wolfpak, you heard it on SEN, but who actually stated it???

iwantmeseats · Sat 18 Jul 2009 7:37pm

Be nice if Wolftool would come back with some further info as requested

evertonfc · Post: # 777493Post **evertonfc** » Sat 18 Jul 2009 11:36pm

iwantmeseats wrote:Be nice if Wolftool would come back with some further info as requested

Even if he's right about Gardy, he sounds like a jibberer.

SainterK · Post: # 777498Post **SainterK** » Sun 19 Jul 2009 12:00am

Anymore news on this one?

JABBER · Post: # 777583Post **JABBER** » Sun 19 Jul 2009 11:55am

Sunday morning on SEN Richo told Hatrford Gardiner might miss if that is the case who will come in Gwilt,Armo or Ball

saint66au · Post: # 777584Post **saint66au** » Sun 19 Jul 2009 12:01pm

JABBER wrote:Sunday morning on SEN Richo told Hatrford Gardiner might miss if that is the case who will come in Gwilt,Armo or Ball

Or maybe one of the ACTUAL emergencies...Armo, Geary or McEvoy

saintbrat · Post: # 777585Post **saintbrat** » Sun 19 Jul 2009 12:01pm

mcEvoy as stated above

given the work done on his legs etc during the last quarter of the game last week- I mentioned to someone post game I thought Big ben may get a couple more games if they rest

Gardi in the lead up to the finals
it also give Ben more big game time and experience.

perfectionist · Sun 19 Jul 2009 12:30pm

If he doesn't play today he will be badly missed. Not only is his ruck work 2nd to none at the moment but he also pushes forward AND is an excellent kick for goal. Adelaide is $3.25 at the moment, which must be the best bet this year. I reckon it's almost even money, all things considered. Our defences are on a par, our midfield is better (or was before Luke Ball was omitted) and our forwards are better. BUT, they kick slightly better than we do. I realise that one result of winning 15 straight is that the "it's got to happen sooner or later" syndrome can out weigh more cerebral analysis. But there you have it.

Quixote · Post: # 777592Post **Quixote** » Sun 19 Jul 2009 1:04pm

Junior wrote:No idea if he is playing or not, but worth noting that on Thursday McEvoy was dropped out of the team not even in the squad.

Last night however when the final team was announced he was all of a sudden listed as an emergency.

My guess would be that Gardiner must be at least under an injury cloud, why else would they bring McEvoy into the 25?

Cheers for that.

Should post more.

Gardiner out?

Gardiner out?

Re: Gardiner out?

gardiner out

Re: gardiner out