Good Call Bad Call

skeptic · Post: # 766305Post **skeptic** » Wed 01 Jul 2009 4:09pm

Saw this thread on bigfooty and thought it would be a bit of fun.

Just like on Footy Classified. You make a statement and the following person responds Good call or bad call and justifies there response with a sentence or 2 (at most)

they then make a statement of their own

to try to save confusion, quote what you're answering and in the event 2 forumites answer at the same time, can the next in line try to answer both statements.

i'll start

Good call, bad call

There isn't room for all 3 of Dawson, Hudghton and Blake in the team at the same time?

plugger66 · Post: # 766315Post **plugger66** » Wed 01 Jul 2009 4:15pm

Good call.

I am glad Max is injured for this game.

robbo_25 · Post: # 766317Post **robbo_25** » Wed 01 Jul 2009 4:17pm

good call

Marcus1232 · Post: # 766319Post **Marcus1232** » Wed 01 Jul 2009 4:18pm

skeptic wrote:There isn't room for all 3 of Dawson, Hudghton and Blake in the team at the same time?

Good call one will have to give way.

Robert Harvey retiring was the best thing that happened to the st.kilda midfield?

Beej · Post: # 766324Post **Beej** » Wed 01 Jul 2009 4:27pm

Marcus1232 wrote:
skeptic wrote:There isn't room for all 3 of Dawson, Hudghton and Blake in the team at the same time?
Good call one will have to give way.

Robert Harvey retiring was the best thing that happened to the st.kilda midfield?

Bad call, Marcus. Terrible call, disrespecful call.

Who's to say the penny wouldn't have dropped had our greatest player still been here.

The AFL need to clarify the rushed behind rule for everyone instead of players running around having no clear idea what they can and can't do.

This is supposed to be a professional sport FFS.

plugger66 · Post: # 766328Post **plugger66** » Wed 01 Jul 2009 4:31pm

OLB wrote:
Marcus1232 wrote:
skeptic wrote:There isn't room for all 3 of Dawson, Hudghton and Blake in the team at the same time?
Good call one will have to give way.

Robert Harvey retiring was the best thing that happened to the st.kilda midfield?
Bad call, Marcus. Terrible call, disrespecful call.

Who's to say the penny wouldn't have dropped had our greatest player still been here.

The AFL need to clarify the rushed behind rule for everyone instead of players running around having no clear idea what they can and can't do.

This is supposed to be a professional sport FFS.

Bad call. Very obvious rule.

The Saints must get close or win this week so their confidence isnt destroyed com finals time.

Marcus1232 · Post: # 766332Post **Marcus1232** » Wed 01 Jul 2009 4:33pm

I dont think it matters either just wanted to hear what somebody else had to say on it :p

OLB wrote:
Bad call, Marcus. Terrible call, disrespecful call.

Who's to say the penny wouldn't have dropped had our greatest player still been here.

The AFL need to clarify the rushed behind rule for everyone instead of players running around having no clear idea what they can and can't do.
.

Good call fantastic call its a good rule but it was rushed into fast wasnt properly thought through

Kosi is as important to the side as Nick Riewoldt

rocksolid · Post: # 766334Post **rocksolid** » Wed 01 Jul 2009 4:35pm

The Saints must get close or win this week so their confidence isnt destroyed com finals time.

Good Call!
Can't afford to get blown away, doesn't really matter if we lose.

Might be even a bigger build up for game if Goose was playing his 100th

Beej · Post: # 766338Post **Beej** » Wed 01 Jul 2009 4:38pm

Marcus1232 wrote:I dont think it matters either just wanted to hear what somebody else had to say on it :p

OLB wrote:
Bad call, Marcus. Terrible call, disrespecful call.

Who's to say the penny wouldn't have dropped had our greatest player still been here.

The AFL need to clarify the rushed behind rule for everyone instead of players running around having no clear idea what they can and can't do.
.

Good call fantastic call its a good rule but it was rushed into fast wasnt properly thought through

Kosi is as important to the side as Nick Riewoldt

Bad call, Markus. Disgraceful call, horrible call.

Well, not that bad a call because a fit and firing Kosi is vital to our chances of September success but every player plays second fiddle to Riewoldt in terms of importance to the side IMO.

Not winning a flag this year will hurt more than any other year.

skeptic · Post: # 766339Post **skeptic** » Wed 01 Jul 2009 4:38pm

Plugger
Good call... a win gives us the incentive, a close loss tells them we're here

Marcus1232 wrote: Kosi is as important to the side as Nick Riewoldt

Good call, gives our midfield choices, eases the pressure of Roo and gives our small forwards chances

James Gwilt is our best option for HFF?

rocksolid · Post: # 766341Post **rocksolid** » Wed 01 Jul 2009 4:42pm

Not winning a flag this year will hurt more than any other year.

BAD Call

Still getting over 97

Winning the flag is going to heal all wounds

Beej · Post: # 766342Post **Beej** » Wed 01 Jul 2009 4:42pm

To stay true to the Classified version of Good call/Bad call, from now on, when you respond, you need to use two other adjectives to describe the call.

Marcus1232 · Post: # 766344Post **Marcus1232** » Wed 01 Jul 2009 4:43pm

skeptic wrote:James Gwilt is our best option for HFF?

Good call at the moment he is our best option.

Beating Geelong will hurt them more than if they beat us

Beej · Post: # 766346Post **Beej** » Wed 01 Jul 2009 4:46pm

rocksolid wrote:Not winning a flag this year will hurt more than any other year.

BAD Call

Still getting over 97

Winning the flag is going to heal all wounds

Good call, rocksolid. Emphatic call, precise call.

A flag and everything will have been worth it. They say you can't truly appreciate the good until you've experienced the bad.

Robert Harvey, deep down inside, was just as happy St Kilda beat Carlton as we all were.

#1GILL · Post: # 766366Post **#1GILL** » Wed 01 Jul 2009 5:19pm

OLB wrote:
rocksolid wrote:Not winning a flag this year will hurt more than any other year.

BAD Call

Still getting over 97

Winning the flag is going to heal all wounds
Good call, rocksolid. Emphatic call, precise call.

A flag and everything will have been worth it. They say you can't truly appreciate the good until you've experienced the bad.

Robert Harvey, deep down inside, was just as happy St Kilda beat Carlton as we all were.

Good Call....He is a Saints man through and through

Leigh Montagna will be St Kilda highest vote getter in the 2009 Brownlow Medal

Moods · Post: # 766377Post **Moods** » Wed 01 Jul 2009 5:29pm

[quote="rocksolid"]Not winning a flag this year will hurt more than any other year.

Bad call. Still reckon we're the under dogs. Would be a good call if no cats in the comp. Cats are still most ppl's pick for the GF o/s of stKildal ppl.

Ross Lyon should stop playing cloak and daggers with training and injuries to players. It's hurting the stkilda brand and serves no real purpose.

Good call or bad call?

skeptic · Post: # 766379Post **skeptic** » Wed 01 Jul 2009 5:30pm

#1GILL wrote: Leigh Montagna will be St Kilda highest vote getter in the 2009 Brownlow Medal

Good call, has been an absolute gun this season... become 1 of the elite of the AFL

The Saints are an ANdrew Lovett style midfielder away from being unbeatable?

MC Gusto · Post: # 766406Post **MC Gusto** » Wed 01 Jul 2009 5:56pm

skeptic wrote:
#1GILL wrote: Leigh Montagna will be St Kilda highest vote getter in the 2009 Brownlow Medal
Good call, has been an absolute gun this season... become 1 of the elite of the AFL

The Saints are an ANdrew Lovett style midfielder away from being unbeatable?

bad call i think brendan goddard

SainterK · Post: # 766411Post **SainterK** » Wed 01 Jul 2009 5:59pm

skeptic wrote:
#1GILL wrote: Leigh Montagna will be St Kilda highest vote getter in the 2009 Brownlow Medal
Good call, has been an absolute gun this season... become 1 of the elite of the AFL

The Saints are an ANdrew Lovett style midfielder away from being unbeatable?

Bad Call, terrible call, shocking call!!!

We haven't been beaten, on top of the ladder, one could say we are unbeatable

Jarryn Geary to be virtually unstoppable for the remaining 10 rounds and win the NAB rising star?

MC Gusto · Post: # 766412Post **MC Gusto** » Wed 01 Jul 2009 5:59pm

roger fox is missed on this site

MC Gusto · Post: # 766414Post **MC Gusto** » Wed 01 Jul 2009 6:00pm

ohwhenthesaints! wrote:
skeptic wrote:
#1GILL wrote: Leigh Montagna will be St Kilda highest vote getter in the 2009 Brownlow Medal
Good call, has been an absolute gun this season... become 1 of the elite of the AFL

The Saints are an ANdrew Lovett style midfielder away from being unbeatable?
Bad Call, terrible call, shocking call!!!

We haven't been beaten, on top of the ladder, one could say we are unbeatable

Jarryn Geary to be virtually unstoppable for the remaining 10 rounds and win the NAB rising star?

good call. if he is eligble i reckon you could be right

#1GILL · Post: # 766431Post **#1GILL** » Wed 01 Jul 2009 6:21pm

Lenny and Max deserve a premiership as much as Harvey Did

evertonfc · Post: # 766433Post **evertonfc** » Wed 01 Jul 2009 6:26pm

#1GILL wrote:Lenny and Max deserve a premiership as much as Harvey Did

Bad call. Nobody deserved a premiership like Robert Harvey. It is a blight on this football club that we couldn't bring him one.

Call: Sam Fisher is an excellent defender but he could be absolutely outstanding if he was able to use his left foot.

#1GILL · Post: # 766437Post **#1GILL** » Wed 01 Jul 2009 6:35pm

evertonfc wrote:
#1GILL wrote:Lenny and Max deserve a premiership as much as Harvey Did
Bad call. Nobody deserved a premiership like Robert Harvey. It is a blight on this football club that we couldn't bring him one.

Call: Sam Fisher is an excellent defender but he could be absolutely outstanding if he was able to use his left foot.

Bad call, but not a shocking one...I think it would make little difference either way.

Call: St Kilda has little to no chance of winning the flag this yr if they lose this week by 60+

saint3d · Post: # 766445Post **saint3d** » Wed 01 Jul 2009 6:50pm

#1GILL wrote:Call: St Kilda has little to no chance of winning the flag this yr if they lose this week by 60+

Bad call. Presumptuous call. Lazy call. You wouldn't say the same of Geelong if they lost by 60+.

It was impossible to answer the Herald Sun's survey question 'who is the toughest player in the AFL' as Luke Ball was not listed as an option.

Good Call Bad Call

Good Call Bad Call

Re: Good Call Bad Call

Re: Good Call Bad Call

Re: Good Call Bad Call

Re: Good Call Bad Call

Re: Good Call Bad Call

Re: Good Call Bad Call

Re: Good Call Bad Call