This week at the Tribunal .....

SaintDippa · Post: # 757339Post **SaintDippa** » Sat 13 Jun 2009 1:53am

Would have thought a couple of Blues would be more than a touch worried.

Q1 - Simpson pinning his arms and burying Goddard's head into the Docklands concrete, after he saw BJ had released the ball, should be 2 weeks reduced to 1 after pleading guilty.

Q1 - Murphy smacking Montagna with a forearm to the head well after he released the ball. (Negligent contact = 1, High contact = 2, Low impact = 1 = 4 weeks). He will no doubt plead guilty and cop the 2 weeks.

What's not looking good for either is after both whacks, Goddard and Joey needed to go off to recover.

plugger66 · Post: # 757363Post **plugger66** » Sat 13 Jun 2009 2:05am

Nothing in either.

James · Post: # 757368Post **James** » Sat 13 Jun 2009 2:10am

Both foul, disgusting dog acts.

SaintDippa · Post: # 757370Post **SaintDippa** » Sat 13 Jun 2009 2:11am

Just watching the replay on FOX....

Simpson will be in trouble as he saw Goddard did not have the ball and continued to bury his head into the concrete.

Murphy will be in trouble as he saw Joey had released the ball, took two steps to his right to line him up and proceeded to swing a forearm into his head.

Plenty in both.

plugger66 · Post: # 757371Post **plugger66** » Sat 13 Jun 2009 2:11am

James wrote:Both foul, disgusting dog acts.

Sorry you have changed my mind. Life for both.

SaintDippa · Post: # 757377Post **SaintDippa** » Sat 13 Jun 2009 2:13am

Life may be a little drastic, harsh and very knee jerk.

mick13 · Post: # 757403Post **mick13** » Sat 13 Jun 2009 2:31am

SaintDippa wrote:Life may be a little drastic, harsh and very knee jerk.

Reminds me of that league the Saints play in...

saintbrat · Post: # 757405Post **saintbrat** » Sat 13 Jun 2009 2:32am

as long as there are no Saints there....

bigcarl · Post: # 757413Post **bigcarl** » Sat 13 Jun 2009 2:35am

SaintDippa wrote:Q1 - Simpson pinning his arms and burying Goddard's head into the Docklands concrete, after he saw BJ had released the ball, should be 2 weeks reduced to 1 after pleading guilty.

that really put bj out of business for the first three quarters. i saw him being helped off and he was virtually unconscious.

could have cost us the match and i hope someone files it away for next time.

unfortunately for the blues, juddy had to come off for a blood nose and it probably cost them the win. ironically it was bj who alerted the umpire to this potentially dangerous situation.

karma is a real bitch like that.

saintly_safes · Sat 13 Jun 2009 4:44am

They are the savoir of the afl no case to answer!! Mark my words

Griggsy · Post: # 757491Post **Griggsy** » Sat 13 Jun 2009 4:59am

I thought it was BJs arm that was hurt. Was pinned and driven into the turf straight. Looked liked he was trying to not move his right arm when coming off. Maybe it was his head, or both i dunno.

I didnt see the other one, only saw Joey on the bench recovering.

Moccha · Post: # 757493Post **Moccha** » Sat 13 Jun 2009 5:04am

plugger66 wrote:
James wrote:Both foul, disgusting dog acts.
Sorry you have changed my mind. Life for both.

add Nick Stevens in there, he's a dog!

ace · Post: # 757501Post **ace** » Sat 13 Jun 2009 8:05am

They are all SCUM.

ace · Post: # 757502Post **ace** » Sat 13 Jun 2009 8:07am

plugger66 wrote:
James wrote:Both foul, disgusting dog acts.
Sorry you have changed my mind. Life for both.

Plugger, you flip-flop.

Eastern · Post: # 757508Post **Eastern** » Sat 13 Jun 2009 8:53am

What about Fevola mistaking the surface for a shop window at 1/4 Time?

SaintWal · Post: # 757512Post **SaintWal** » Sat 13 Jun 2009 9:26am

Eastern wrote:What about Fevola mistaking the surface for a shop window at 1/4 Time?

Your not serious?

He could not be that dumb???

Oh, then again

plugger66 · Post: # 757522Post **plugger66** » Sat 13 Jun 2009 9:49am

SaintWal wrote:
Eastern wrote:What about Fevola mistaking the surface for a shop window at 1/4 Time?
Your not serious?

He could not be that dumb???

Oh, then again

If you dont think many players do that you are mistaken. Without seeing in Saints players last night I would suggest we probably did it as well at one of the breaks. And I dont mean half time.

SaintWal · Post: # 757526Post **SaintWal** » Sat 13 Jun 2009 9:56am

plugger66 wrote:
SaintWal wrote:
Eastern wrote:What about Fevola mistaking the surface for a shop window at 1/4 Time?
Your not serious?

He could not be that dumb???

Oh, then again
If you dont think many players do that you are mistaken. Without seeing in Saints players last night I would suggest we probably did it as well at one of the breaks. And I dont mean half time.

I must admit I have not seen it at AFL level for a long time. VFL and all comps under it, definitely all the time.

SaintDippa · Post: # 757702Post **SaintDippa** » Sat 13 Jun 2009 1:09pm

Anyone know when the MRP meet? And how to find out the outcomes of their review?

More than interested to find out how they deal with the thuggery of Murphy (laying a beautiful forearm into Montagna's head) and Simpson (who tried to take BJ out of the game by pinning his arms and burying his head into the Docklands concrete even after he saw Goddard had released the ball).

Would be shocked if Murphy did'nt have a case to answer. Joey looked very dazed on the boundary and Murphy made sure he got him. Looking at the replay Montagna released the ball then a good time passed before Murphy moved to his right to deliver a swinging arm that would not have been out of place in a League game.

Let's see if Carlton gets any special treatment.

Thinline · Post: # 757707Post **Thinline** » Sat 13 Jun 2009 1:11pm

James wrote:Both foul, disgusting dog acts.

Unlike, of course, Gardiner's elbow to the back of Jamar's head...

Simpson on Goddard, for mine there was definitely a second movement and Goddard was obviously semi-concussed afterwards so I suspect he;ll go up on a rough conduct charge. Didn't see Montagna.

But in the end, it's them, who cares...

SaintDippa · Post: # 757711Post **SaintDippa** » Sat 13 Jun 2009 1:13pm

I think gardiner was slotted for that!

Thinline · Post: # 757713Post **Thinline** » Sat 13 Jun 2009 1:15pm

Making the point that just because hel;s a saint didn't make it any less a fould disgusting dog act...

SaintDippa · Post: # 757714Post **SaintDippa** » Sat 13 Jun 2009 1:16pm

Agree - all acts of thuggery need to be dealt with.

oh when · Post: # 757763Post **oh when** » Sat 13 Jun 2009 2:09pm

And I bet Mark Robinson will be writing an article on why they should get 4 weeks.

Hurricane · Post: # 757768Post **Hurricane** » Sat 13 Jun 2009 2:13pm

Griggsy wrote:I thought it was BJs arm that was hurt. Was pinned and driven into the turf straight.

Agree with that, looked like a shoulder injury to me when he went off. Thankfully he came back on and played a part in the win. Simpson should get 2 but knowing the MRP he wont even get cited

BANG BANG

This week at the Tribunal .....

This week at the Tribunal .....

Re: This week at the Tribunal .....