Saintsational Fan Forum - A passionate community of St Kilda Football Club fans discussing news, history, players, trade rumours, results, AFL stats and more.
and back to the OP
apart from the fact that I disagree wholeHarvily about Gwilt's performance.
The logic that he should be replaced falls flat on its face.
When King comes back, it wont mean Gwilt will go.
The forward line on a good day will Roo, Kosi and Milne. (Goddard will still play down back as his role as desginated kickin cant be replaced ATM.)
SO that puts two - three forward line spots up for grabs. I dont think we can play Roo, Kosi AND McEvoy, he has to be better than King or Gardiner to get a game. Gwilt and Schneider are holding their spots at the moment, but only if the kids dont suddenly become AFL players, and put some pressure on the list. WHICH by all accounts, and sadly, is a long way off.
Stamping your foot and crying to play the kids is futile, as they must earn their spot. And at this point the best players are getting picked.
Go Gwilt
sunsaint wrote:and back to the OP
apart from the fact that I disagree wholeHarvily about Gwilt's performance.
The logic that he should be replaced falls flat on its face.
When King comes back, it wont mean Gwilt will go.
The forward line on a good day will Roo, Kosi and Milne. (Goddard will still play down back as his role as desginated kickin cant be replaced ATM.)
SO that puts two - three forward line spots up for grabs. I dont think we can play Roo, Kosi AND McEvoy, he has to be better than King or Gardiner to get a game. Gwilt and Schneider are holding their spots at the moment, but only if the kids dont suddenly become AFL players, and put some pressure on the list. WHICH by all accounts, and sadly, is a long way off.
Stamping your foot and crying to play the kids is futile, as they must earn their spot. And at this point the best players are getting picked.
Go Gwilt
fantastic post.
agree 35%
if Gwilt is not playing his role, he will get dropped,
for someone playing that role better in the vfl.
bringing in the best in the vfl, wont always work
as just because they are the best
doesnt mean they can play the position