Carlton pursuing Maguire

philip · Post: # 652936Post **philip** » Wed 24 Sep 2008 2:32pm

I can tell you that my mail has Carlton making "enquiries" about goose at player and managment level.

What I can't tell you is what our club's response has been.

watch this space...

philip

maverick · Post: # 652938Post **maverick** » Wed 24 Sep 2008 2:38pm

What would we want for him out of interest?

saint patrick · Wed 24 Sep 2008 2:39pm

Fine.

For Jaryd Waite or Bryce Gibbs and we'll look at it..

Need Gosse with Maxy's departure imminant.

philip · Post: # 652941Post **philip** » Wed 24 Sep 2008 2:40pm

don't know and not aware of goose's response.

i could presume a 2nd round pick would be any trade asking price given he is still contracted.

philip

maverick · Post: # 652942Post **maverick** » Wed 24 Sep 2008 2:40pm

saint patrick wrote:Fine.

For Jaryd Waite or Bryce Gibbs and we'll look at it..

Need Gosse with Maxy's departure imminant.

Goose can't play FB, too slow and clumsy in contests....

S.A Saint · Post: # 652943Post **S.A Saint** » Wed 24 Sep 2008 2:42pm

second rounder plus jamison would be nice

Quixote · Post: # 652945Post **Quixote** » Wed 24 Sep 2008 2:44pm

Goose is the most interesting one of all during trade. Kosi and Dal aren't going anywhere - simple. But Goose...

Career riddled with severe injuries and distinct possibility he won't get back to where he was.

I'd say KEEP HIM, but if someone offered low picks, or a tough mid, well...

bigcarl · Post: # 652948Post **bigcarl** » Wed 24 Sep 2008 2:46pm

philip wrote:i could presume a 2nd round pick would be any trade asking price given he is still contracted.

straight swap for fev? not interested at all unless they are offering something really good.

injury-free, goose could be anything.

Batnoe · Post: # 652950Post **Batnoe** » Wed 24 Sep 2008 2:49pm

I would do it for Murphy

This better not be a Brad Fisher - Goose swap

S.A Saint · Post: # 652951Post **S.A Saint** » Wed 24 Sep 2008 2:49pm

the question is though, will he ever recover from all those leg injuries. and he has basically had two years out of the game. when he came back this year he looked too slow to hold a key defender spot. i would be happy with a 1st or 2nd rounder for goose.

bigcarl · Post: # 652955Post **bigcarl** » Wed 24 Sep 2008 2:54pm

carlton would plonk him at chf as they need another good mark to compliment fev. it is perhaps a role for him that we should be contemplating to compliment riewoldt.

injury free it could be a masterstroke by them.

they have been itching to get back at us for hamill for years.

i wouldn't do business with them. crooks and cheats.

JeffDunne · Post: # 652959Post **JeffDunne** » Wed 24 Sep 2008 2:59pm

Batnoe wrote:I would do it for Murphy

If you're going to be living in dreamland why not throw in Judd?

Goose doesn't have much trade value.

bigcarl · Post: # 652960Post **bigcarl** » Wed 24 Sep 2008 3:02pm

JeffDunne wrote:Goose doesn't have much trade value.

well if they're interested, he must have some.

S.A Saint · Post: # 652961Post **S.A Saint** » Wed 24 Sep 2008 3:04pm

i think that we will got no more than a second rounder for him. however if they are that interested they would possible add on one of their younger players like a browne or someone.

Winmar7Fan · Post: # 652964Post **Winmar7Fan** » Wed 24 Sep 2008 3:06pm

JeffDunne wrote:
Batnoe wrote:I would do it for Murphy
If you're going to be living in dreamland why not throw in Judd?

Goose doesn't have much trade value.

100 % on the money. IMO he's finished along with Bakes.

bigcarl · Post: # 652966Post **bigcarl** » Wed 24 Sep 2008 3:09pm

Winmar7Fan wrote:
JeffDunne wrote:
Batnoe wrote:I would do it for Murphy
If you're going to be living in dreamland why not throw in Judd?

Goose doesn't have much trade value.
100 % on the money. IMO he's finished along with Bakes.

let's just give him away for pick 96 then

these are the sort of deals that can come back to bite you,

Hurricane · Post: # 652967Post **Hurricane** » Wed 24 Sep 2008 3:10pm

We shoudl play absolute hard ball, why should we give up a player we have nurtured and developed to one of our main rivals for a song?

If we were to trade Goose I would want nothing less than a good player and a first round draft pick

BANG BANG

JeffDunne · Post: # 652968Post **JeffDunne** » Wed 24 Sep 2008 3:16pm

bigcarl wrote:
JeffDunne wrote:Goose doesn't have much trade value.
well if they're interested, he must have some.

Huh?

Just because you chase a player it doesn't mean you're willing to give up the earth for them.

bigcarl · Post: # 652969Post **bigcarl** » Wed 24 Sep 2008 3:17pm

JeffDunne wrote:
bigcarl wrote:
JeffDunne wrote:Goose doesn't have much trade value.
well if they're interested, he must have some.
Huh?

Just because you chase a player it doesn't mean you're willing to give up the earth for them.

they remember him at his barnstorming best a few years ago. he's more highly regarded at other clubs than he is at st kilda, i can tell you.

i'm already having nightmares of judd putting them down the throats of he and fev as they monster our defence.

JeffDunne · Post: # 652973Post **JeffDunne** » Wed 24 Sep 2008 3:23pm

I think you're jumping at shadows carl.

What makes you think St Kilda don't rate him?

Regardless, he doesn't have any real trade value because he's a big risk.

TimeToShineFellas · Wed 24 Sep 2008 3:25pm

Hurricane wrote: If we were to trade Goose I would want nothing less than a good player and a first round draft pick

BANG BANG

Hmm somehow don't think that's going to happen!

SENsei · Post: # 652978Post **SENsei** » Wed 24 Sep 2008 3:25pm

So far Carlton are trading for Daniel Kerr, Robert Warnock, Matt Maguire and Corey Jones.

Any others I am missing?

I'm tipping one, and only one, of those will come off.

Personally, I would've thought Carlton would be more interested in Kosi than Goose.

Con Gorozidis · Wed 24 Sep 2008 3:25pm

S.A Saint wrote:the question is though, will he ever recover from all those leg injuries. and he has basically had two years out of the game. when he came back this year he looked too slow to hold a key defender spot. i would be happy with a 1st or 2nd rounder for goose.

1st rounder? you must be kidding.

my mail (pretty good source) - says he will never be the same again. his injury was very very serious and horrific at times. he may never play again and if he does will be a shadow of his former self.

PS. PLEASE DELETE THIS MESSAGE BEFORE CARLTON READ IT. we should try to get something good for him from those scum bags.

Red · Post: # 652982Post **Red** » Wed 24 Sep 2008 3:28pm

At best he is a B grade player and he is soft.

HarveysDeciple · Wed 24 Sep 2008 3:41pm

Batnoe wrote:I would do it for Murphy

This better not be a Brad Fisher - Goose swap

I'd take that..