Who to bring in for the Pies...

[borderbarry]

Who to bring in for the Pies.?....
From yesterdays game..
Best...Casey Scorpions: R.Clarke Armitage Steven O'Bryan Howard Dunne

[plugger66]

Who to bring in for the Pies.?....
From yesterdays game..
Best...Casey Scorpions: R.Clarke Armitage Steven O'Bryan [Howard[/u] Dunne

[/u][/b]

None of them but maybe Birss and X for Bally and Geary.

[Eastern]

In: Armitage (with a rocket)

Out: Ball

!!

[Moorabbin Saints]

In: Armo and possibly Baker & X Clarke if fit
Out: No idea?

[saintsRrising]

How did X go????

Otherwise Birss and Armo.

Birrs to play on Shaw again.

With Ball out we need another inside mid - Armo.

[borderbarry]

Apparently Jones and Lenny may be injured. In any case, it was Rafael, NOT Xavier, who had the good game.

[saintsRrising]

Apparently Jones and Lenny may be injured. In any case, it was Rafael, NOT Xavier, who had the good game.

I know that Raph was BOG...but my question was how did X go as he was not discussed that I have seen?

[Eastern]

Apparently Jones and Lenny may be injured. In any case, it was Rafael, NOT Xavier, who had the good game.

Barry !!

Give yourself an uppercut. It's RAPHAEL !!

[saintsRrising]

Also I forgot about Max...how bad was his calf?

Originally they said they would give him up till Friday for this week...so I assume that he is a likely starter for next week?

[Stephen Theodore]

Hudgton - 2 weeks

[perfectionist]

In Clarkes and Birss
Out Geez where do you start? Maybe nowhere if injuries take a hand, but Gilbo and Eddyo should join Armo. Can't run, can't kick and so, can't play.

[Stephen Theodore]

perfectionist wrote:
Out Geez where do you start? Maybe nowhere if injuries take a hand, but Gilbo and Eddyo should join Armo. Can't run, can't kick and so, can't play.

Gilbert, cant run, cant kick, cant play. Tough comment, I reckon, at 6' 4" I reckon he's mobile with a hell of a lot of upside for a inexperienced player, who gets handed big responsibilities every week. Watch him more carefully !

[degruch]

In Clarkes and Birss
Out Geez where do you start? Maybe nowhere if injuries take a hand, but Gilbo and Eddyo should join Armo. Can't run, can't kick and so, can't play.

Eddy was fine...took a great mark, showed some run and some courage. Agree, Birss has got to get a go...perfect to take on the Pies.

[Otiman]

Birss in, Geary stays in because he'll have a good matchup down there on their forward line.

Out: Ball
In: Birss

If Jones is out, Armo in also.

Would love to see Jack Steven get a gig this year, but I don't think it will happen.

[Bernard Shakey]

Why would you consider bringing in Armitage?

He contests alright, but cannot go the distance at the Shed.

Failed miserably at Subi.

Why would he be able to handle the MCG at the moment?

He will be OK, but not this year.

[perfectionist]

Gilbert... I reckon he's mobile with a hell of a lot of upside for a inexperienced player, who gets handed big responsibilities every week. Watch him more carefully !

Watch him: kick along the ground, push players in the back, grab players arouind the neck, grab players around the legs, miss marks, get caught.

They say rugby players can never make an AFL player - he proves the rule.

Armo and Gilbo for Browno. A win-win; we get a champ, they get two duds.

[saintjake]

not x.
not yet,
give him a few more games.
make him earn it with a couple more BOG efforts.
if we bring him in to early he will jsut break down as usual

[nathan000]

To me Milney was a bit disappointing today. I'd push either X, Bakes or Armo in for Ball. And consider another one of them 3 for Milne.

[plugger66]

To me Milney was a bit disappointing today. I'd push either X, Bakes or Armo in for Ball. And consider another one of them 3 for Milne.

Sack Milne as well.

[jonesy]

To me Milney was a bit disappointing today. I'd push either X, Bakes or Armo in for Ball. And consider another one of them 3 for Milne.

Turn it up!

Has a bad game and he's off to the magoo's?

On that basis we'd be dropping a lot of players each week

[nathan000]

It's a suggestion. He has had more then one bad game for the year.

[jonesy]

It's a suggestion. He has had more then one bad game for the year.

I'd say Schneider,Fiora, Gwilt,Geary,Eddy and co have had just a few more than poor old Milnedog

[nathan000]

And they have all been dropped more then once apart from Eddy, who i think has been great since being included in our firsts. Maybe not drop Milney this week, but if the game is on the line next week and he does nothing once again i would consider it.

[degruch]

They'd never drop Milney against the Pies...he does a reasonable job against them, got a couple lazy goals in a pretty avaerage team display last time. If we fire, he'll bag 4!

[The Saintsational Man]

To me Milney was a bit disappointing today. I'd push either X, Bakes or Armo in for Ball. And consider another one of them 3 for Milne.

The ball just didn't bounce Milne's way today.

Some games it does and he looks awesome.

Some games it doesn't, like 2day.

He's a great crumber and when on song, his energy gets the whole crowd into the game.

Milne ain't going anywhere.