Should Schnieder be DROPPED? !!

Life Long Saint · Tue 29 Jul 2008 11:02am

The main reason why Schneider should be dropped is that he is not "taking his turn".

He refuses to put his head over the ball and do the disciplined thing for the team.

He has one or two serviceable games for this football club and one of those was against Melbourne.

He needs to go back to Casey and earn his spot back in the senior team. I'd rather a raw kid with enthusiasm and a big work rate who makes a few errors than an experienced player too lazy to work for his team mates.

aussiejones · Tue 29 Jul 2008 11:36am

Drop Scnieder......Fiora..... Gardiner

Have a talk to Gram about defensive game as he appears not to have one !

evertonfc · Post: # 611744Post **evertonfc** » Tue 29 Jul 2008 12:32pm

Brooksy_Babe_24 wrote:YES hasn't really played a good game all season.

Uh huh

FFS - you guys gave Blake 10 years to come good...

I reckon Schneider needs a LITTLE bit of support.

TimeToShineFellas · Tue 29 Jul 2008 1:34pm

evertonfc wrote:
Brooksy_Babe_24 wrote:YES hasn't really played a good game all season.
Uh huh

FFS - you guys gave Blake 10 years to come good...

I reckon Schneider needs a LITTLE bit of support.

Agreed everton.

Brooksy_Babe_24 wrote:YES hasn't really played a good game all season.

He snagged 5 against the Dees - 5 goals in a game of football would seem like a good game to me....

Brooksy_Babe_24 wrote:It would make alot of supporters happy to see that the coach doesn't just pick him because he was from Sydney

That is just a plainly ridiculous statement........

stinger · Post: # 611768Post **stinger** » Tue 29 Jul 2008 1:39pm

yes...i don't know why he is in the team anyway.....

Saints in 20?? · Tue 29 Jul 2008 2:43pm

I agree.
Schneider should be supported and dropped to the two's so he can earn his place as ALL players should.

Solar · Post: # 611793Post **Solar** » Tue 29 Jul 2008 2:44pm

Saints in 20?? wrote:I agree.
Schneider should be supported and dropped to the two's so he can earn his place as ALL players should.

agree, looking forward to seeing him play this week, will support his completely

for casey

Life Long Saint · Tue 29 Jul 2008 4:00pm

evertonfc wrote:FFS - you guys gave Blake 10 years to come good...

I'm not a massive fan of Blake but he has and shows two things that Schneider does not. He puts his body on the line each week and his commitment is beyond question.

Blake's skills let him down time and again. But Schnieder's skills aren't silky enough to counteract his faults.

WayneJudson42 · Tue 29 Jul 2008 4:09pm

Can't believe what I'm reading at times.

New team, lack of fitness, lack of regular game time.

If we agree that it takes time to learn how your team mates play, then he needs time.

Or do we expect ALL recruits to do for us what Judd has done for Carlton?

rodgerfox · Post: # 611836Post **rodgerfox** » Tue 29 Jul 2008 4:14pm

WayneJudson42 wrote:Can't believe what I'm reading at times.

New team, lack of fitness, lack of regular game time.

If we agree that it takes time to learn how your team mates play, then he needs time.

Or do we expect ALL recruits to do for us what Judd has done for Carlton?

But he was no good at Sydney either.

WayneJudson42 · Tue 29 Jul 2008 4:18pm

And Rodan was no good at Richmond... if he doesn't cut it, he goes. simple.

After all, traded for Dempster and Schneids was thrown in as part of the deal.

plugger66 · Post: # 611842Post **plugger66** » Tue 29 Jul 2008 4:19pm

WayneJudson42 wrote:And Rodan was no good at Richmond... if he doesn't cut it, he goes. simple.

After all, traded for Dempster and Schneids was thrown in as part of the deal.

100% sure it was the other way around. Dempster was thrown in with Schneider.

evertonfc · Post: # 611843Post **evertonfc** » Tue 29 Jul 2008 4:20pm

Unbelievable.

I look forward to the club delisting him at the end of the season before he turns around his career somewhere else.

I agree, let's turn our back on blokes who have potentially game-breaking qualities, rather than try and work out how to get this out of them.

WayneJudson42 · Tue 29 Jul 2008 4:23pm

Thanks P66.. no shyt? Threw it out to see who'd correct me

Was hoping for a stronger reply from someone.

plugger66 · Post: # 611848Post **plugger66** » Tue 29 Jul 2008 4:25pm

WayneJudson42 wrote:Thanks P66.. no shyt? Threw it out to see who'd correct me
Was hoping for a stronger reply from someone.

Sorry missed the sacastic post. Surely me if anyone would know one of those posts.

WayneJudson42 · Tue 29 Jul 2008 4:26pm

Who was #22 chasing him? EFC?

WayneJudson42 · Tue 29 Jul 2008 4:27pm

Sorry missed the sacastic post. Surely me if anyone would know one of those posts.

HHmmmm. Must say, I very dissapointed in you P66.

Maybe you ned to be dropped this week?

maverick · Post: # 611861Post **maverick** » Tue 29 Jul 2008 4:42pm

WayneJudson42 wrote:Can't believe what I'm reading at times.

New team, lack of fitness, lack of regular game time.

If we agree that it takes time to learn how your team mates play, then he needs time.

Or do we expect ALL recruits to do for us what Judd has done for Carlton?

Maybe he could do all that at Casey and training rather than in the 1's where it may cost us 4 points....

Not sure tackling and running to create space are different at our club to any others but hey, let's see if he can learn that soon....

WayneJudson42 · Tue 29 Jul 2008 4:49pm

Fair comment. But we don't know what his role is, do we?

Maybe he is required to play an outside role? He has finishing skills which we all agree we lack. so, if he goes in and under, how's he supposed to finish?

Same goes for Milne. Required to apply some pressure, but main job is to stay clear and crumb. Schneids isn't doing it at the moment.

Maybe the coach rates him highly enough that he'll stick with him. who knows? There were quite a few whocouldn't believe why he selected CJ.

Is Adam Schneider the new Fiora????????

AlpineStars · Tue 29 Jul 2008 4:54pm

Delisted, we don't except mediocraty.

Sobraz · Post: # 611871Post **Sobraz** » Tue 29 Jul 2008 4:55pm

WayneJudson42 wrote:Who was #22 chasing him? EFC?

Looked like Fiora from behind.... cant remember if he changed his no. the year after or not...pretty sure its him...

WayneJudson42 · Tue 29 Jul 2008 4:57pm

Looked like Fiora from behind....

F***... that man again? Cost us the Granny as well?

evertonfc · Post: # 611874Post **evertonfc** » Tue 29 Jul 2008 4:58pm

WayneJudson42 wrote: Is Adam Schneider the new Fiora????????

As I see it, Schneider has shown himself to be a more than a capable player at this level. Game breaking at times. Even with us.

The challenge for us, and for him, is to produce that consistenly.

He does have talent. Yes, he needs to work a bit harder but I think his interrupted pre-season has weighed on his ability to string together consistent games.

But he has played some good games for us. Really good. To suggest otherwise is ridiculous.

Blokes with talent you must give every opportunity to. Granted, if I played for St Kilda, I'd try my guts out and give everything for the cause, but if you want to succeed, you do actually need the element of skill Schneider has.

WayneJudson42 · Tue 29 Jul 2008 5:09pm

I agree EFC. Obviously, you're not in the mood for some sarcasm today. Read my other posts.

You have give him time to settle in... time to become the latest whipping boy... time to be dropped coz some supporters reckon he's a fav of RL being from Sydney and all that... timeto justify why he isn't as good as Judd.

Solar · Post: # 611885Post **Solar** » Tue 29 Jul 2008 5:18pm

yet to see him work hard and get to the contests

is in bad form and needs to go back to the VFL. Not writing him off by a long way, just struggling to contribute to the team.

I want him to be more consistant, cj despite his short comings (has half the skills) is in better form, working his arse off and putting in good performances. If schneider can get to that work rate level then we will have a very handy player