Coaching Panel

[1eyedNever]

Totally out Coach on the day

allowed Lynch to run riot in last half and didnt even move Blake to run with him

Totally out Coach before the game by playing Gardiner,Fiona and Sneider
Gardiner no form
Fiona minus zero form and a lazy crap player F him off please
Sneider zero form


So we go into a game without a tall forward to take pressure away from Roo

And 3 players short all day


C Gardiner should have played before Snieder
J Allen should have player before M Gardiner
Geary should have played before Fiona

[plugger66]

[quote="1eyedNever"]Totally out Coach on the day

allowed Lynch to run riot in last half and didnt even move Blake to run with him

Totally out Coach before the game by playing Gardiner,Fiona and Sneider
Gardiner no form
Fiona minus zero form and a lazy crap player F him off please
Sneider zero form


So we go into a game without a tall forward to take pressure away from Roo

And 3 players short all day


C Gardiner should have played before Snieder
J Allen should have player before M Gardiner
Geary should have played before Fiona[/quote

You actually thought these should have been the changes before the game or is this that great skill hindsight. How could they have dropped Fiora and Schneider after our great win last week. Both did well and didnt deserve to be dropped. Now whether they deserved to be picked in the first place is a different story.

[saintsRrising]

Armo had 6 disposals and 93% TOG.
But no criticism?

Fiora is evidently a demon even though his game was ok. Not good...not bad.

[Otiman]

Schneider was good against the Hawks. His spot may be in jeopardy this week though.

Fiora has been servicable the last two games.

C. Gardiner has played one good game this year, and struggles to kick goals at VFL level.

Allen has had what, 10 posessions in 3 games, for a return of 0 goals? Even M. Gardiner was more useful than that.

Geary and Birss should have been playing in the side. Ahead of Armitage and one other.

[Moccha]

We let them into the game with that absolute s*** game plan of chipping it around backwards until you get a turnover. Even the Eagles supporters could see it was letting them into the game. Why is it that the players and coaches can't see that when that doesn't work you change and do something better.

[WayneJudson42]

Sack Lyon for trying to play like Sydney

[maverick]

Totally out Coach on the day

allowed Lynch to run riot in last half and didnt even move Blake to run with him

Totally out Coach before the game by playing Gardiner,Fiona and Sneider
Gardiner no form
Fiona minus zero form and a lazy crap player F him off please
Sneider zero form


So we go into a game without a tall forward to take pressure away from Roo

And 3 players short all day


C Gardiner should have played before Snieder
J Allen should have player before M Gardiner
Geary should have played before Fiona[/quote

You actually thought these should have been the changes before the game or is this that great skill hindsight. How could they have dropped Fiora and Schneider after our great win last week. Both did well and didnt deserve to be dropped. Now whether they deserved to be picked in the first place is a different story.

Neither Schneider nor Fiora played well last week against Hawthorn, unless of course not playing a shocker is considered OK for these two.

[Saints43]

Sack Lyon for trying to play like Sydney

Can you please give the "sack the coach rolly eyes", "sack the players rolly eyes", "withdraw from the AFL rolly eyes" posts a rest?

It adds nothing.

And you've stuck one in nearly every thread.

We get it.

[3rd generation saint]

Schneider last week did what he is suppose to do, he kicked a couple of goals and like Milne benefited from the ball coming down quickly into the forward line and spilling from Roo and Kosi.

Yesterday, he didn't play where he is most dangerous, bad coaching, bad forward structure.

[maverick]

Schneider last week did what he is suppose to do, he kicked a couple of goals and like Milne benefited from the ball coming down quickly into the forward line and spilling from Roo and Kosi.

Yesterday, he didn't play where he is most dangerous, bad coaching, bad forward structure.

Last week he played almost the first half in defence, and was awful, was lucky to be OK last week, IMO of course....

[Eastern]

Back to what I thought the OP was about !!

I think you will find that the contracts for Silvagni, Rock & Barker all expire at the end of this year. With Ross having another year of his current contract to run I would expect that there will be at least 1 and possibly 2 changes to the coaching panel at the end of the year.

Thoughts? !!

[maverick]

Back to what I thought the OP was about !!

I think you will find that the contracts for Silvagni, Rock & Barker all expire at the end of this year. With Ross having another year of his current contract to run I would expect that there will be at least 1 and possibly 2 changes to the coaching panel at the end of the year.

Thoughts? !!

Barker - GONE
Silvagni - Shaky
Rock - unsure
Elshaug - What does he do? Never liked that appointment....
Lyon - Well...

[Solar]

Back to what I thought the OP was about !!

I think you will find that the contracts for Silvagni, Rock & Barker all expire at the end of this year. With Ross having another year of his current contract to run I would expect that there will be at least 1 and possibly 2 changes to the coaching panel at the end of the year.

Thoughts? !!

my guess is rock will be moved on, this will be barkers last coaching gig. Not sure who the two to come in