ST Kilda Team Rd 15 2008

saintbrat · Post: # 600549Post **saintbrat** » Thu 10 Jul 2008 6:33pm

http://sportal.com.au/afl-news-display/ ... eams-52147
2008 ROUND 15 TEAMS

CARLTON v ST KILDA
Friday, 7:40pm AEST, MCG
ST KILDA
B: Gram, Hudghton, Dempster
HB: Goddard, Gilbert, S.Fisher
C: McQualter, Dal Santo, Hayes
HF: Harvey, Riewoldt, Eddy
F: Jones, Koschitzke, Armitage
FOLL: King, Ball, Montagna
I/C: Gwilt, Blake, Milne, Allen
EMG: C.Gardiner, Fiora, Schneider
IN: Hayes
OUT: C.Gardiner

Field umpires: Donlon, Vozzo, James

CARLTON
B: Carrazzo, Jamison, Thornton
HB: Gibbs, Waite, Browne
C: Simpson, Stevens, Scotland
HF: Wiggins, Fisher, Murphy
F: Betts, Fevola, Kreuzer
FOLL: Cloke, Bentick, Judd
I/C: Anderson, Edwards, Grigg, Russell
EMG: Pfeiffer, O'hAilpin, Walker
IN: Judd
OUT: O'hAilpin

Ralphy · Post: # 600552Post **Ralphy** » Thu 10 Jul 2008 6:34pm

Only change i think will happen but i dont want it to exactly is maybe schneider in for Allen or Gwilt

Spinner · Post: # 600556Post **Spinner** » Thu 10 Jul 2008 6:36pm

Damn.

No M Gardiner

stevos2151 · Post: # 600559Post **stevos2151** » Thu 10 Jul 2008 6:37pm

Good Stuff Ross

saintsrus · Post: # 600565Post **saintsrus** » Thu 10 Jul 2008 6:43pm

Yes i like the fact of one change. They all deserve their spots.

st_Trav_ofWA · Thu 10 Jul 2008 6:45pm

thank goodness drop the worst performer from last week and replace him with an out and out star !!!

snoopygirl · Post: # 600570Post **snoopygirl** » Thu 10 Jul 2008 6:50pm

Happy with the in for this week. Won't mind sitting in the freezing cold now.

Umpires aren't tooooo bad either.

stinger · Post: # 600572Post **stinger** » Thu 10 Jul 2008 6:55pm

oh sh!t...the dropped the irish git...that's a shame.....

saintboy · Post: # 600574Post **saintboy** » Thu 10 Jul 2008 6:56pm

Lenny will get another 16 touches in the 1st quarter but instead of doing his hammy he will repeat the dose in the 2nd, 3rd& 4th as well!!!

milney044 · Post: # 600581Post **milney044** » Thu 10 Jul 2008 7:00pm

Very good. Things always look brighter with Lenny in the team

Good to see just the one change, i hope it stays that way and Schneider gets a run in the twos before making his return. I think he's a valuable member of our team but needs maybe just a week with Casey before coming back.
Good changes, Charlie had to make way, he was the weakest link.
Welcome back Lenny, keep up the form, 16 1st quarter touches would be nice

Eastern · Post: # 600582Post **Eastern** » Thu 10 Jul 2008 7:03pm

snoopygirl wrote:
Umpires aren't tooooo bad .

Sooooooooooooo. The truth finally comes out. snoopygirl has the hots for umpire Vosso

!!

saintsRrising · Thu 10 Jul 2008 7:06pm

I can't wait for the game...despite the cold snap!!!

saintdooley · Thu 10 Jul 2008 7:10pm

no need to repeat your self saintsRrising!!!

saintdooley · Thu 10 Jul 2008 7:13pm

no need to repeat yourself saintsRrising

Solar · Post: # 600590Post **Solar** » Thu 10 Jul 2008 7:16pm

good team

its what most of us wanted the sunday night after the game 2 weeks ago.

bergsone · Post: # 600592Post **bergsone** » Thu 10 Jul 2008 7:17pm

Still reckon Birss should at least get a gig as emerg in front of the 3 named

saintsrus · Post: # 600596Post **saintsrus** » Thu 10 Jul 2008 7:23pm

bergsone wrote:Still reckon Birss should at least get a gig as emerg in front of the 3 named

Great point, may not be a coach favorite

noob · Post: # 600597Post **noob** » Thu 10 Jul 2008 7:25pm

good change. good team.

Winmarvellous · Thu 10 Jul 2008 7:27pm

Would've liked M Gardiner back. Looks like Kosi's got Kruezer.

midas_touch · Thu 10 Jul 2008 7:36pm

Looks like RL is going for the continuity approach, not wanting to disrupt team dynamics. In saying that, Allen is lucky to be still in the side, with Gardi taking his spot.

bigcarl · Post: # 600611Post **bigcarl** » Thu 10 Jul 2008 7:45pm

midas_touch wrote:Allen is lucky to be still in the side, with Gardi taking his spot.

i guess the thinking is that if he can develop as a key forward it releases roo to wing or kosi to ruck.

agree that schneider and m. gardiner are probably in our best 22, but what sort of message would wholesale changes send after our best win for the season.

starsign · Post: # 600616Post **starsign** » Thu 10 Jul 2008 7:50pm

Looks like RL is going for the continuity approach, not wanting to disrupt team dynamics. In saying that, Allen is lucky to be still in the side, with Gardi taking his spot.

and i think balance comes into it here too
Kozi seems to perform much better down forward when he's given the chance to run around in the ruck a bit and last week it worked well
So Allen plays a big role in this and it seems that we get better balance and are more effective by not having all 3 of king/kozi/gardner in with blake up the sleeve as well
its an intresting situation and i think one they are still messing with on a weekly basis, particularly with regard to the opposition followers

Quixote · Post: # 600621Post **Quixote** » Thu 10 Jul 2008 8:14pm

They are saying on SEN that Max is doubtful.

Any word on this?

Gutted if true... but not the end of the world. Big Blakey to Fev!! Give Jason the chance to towel him up!!!

evertonfc · Post: # 600622Post **evertonfc** » Thu 10 Jul 2008 8:17pm

The youth in the team is good.

But why would have Jason Blake in the team over Schneider, especially if he's fit?

Mystifying.

perfectionist · Thu 10 Jul 2008 8:19pm

Gee, it would be nice to know who was available and who wasn't.

Playing games with team selection is a complete joke - it has never won one game. All it does is serve to alienate the supporters.

What is hard about the club saying:

Michael Gardiner is fit to play, but we don't like him or he's too much of a risk or we really don't know what we are doing!

And Steven Baker? Let's forget about putting pressure on the opposition.

There is only one rule in picking teams - you continue to pick the BEST available despite what happened last week. It always works.