Should we bring schnieder straight back for carlton match

SaintWodonga · Mon 07 Jul 2008 6:03pm

question 1st: Is he fit?

evertonfc · Post: # 599610Post **evertonfc** » Mon 07 Jul 2008 7:16pm

I have realised I'm his only fan.

I'll leave the porch light on your Schneids, just like I did for Guerra...

Saints Premiers 2008 · Mon 07 Jul 2008 8:02pm

evertonfc wrote:I have realised I'm his only fan.

I'll leave the porch light on your Schneids, just like I did for Guerra...

x 2

he cops so much garbage from 'fans' here expecting instant results

also guerra should still be at the club..a disgrace he was delisted

plugger66 · Post: # 599618Post **plugger66** » Mon 07 Jul 2008 8:05pm

I actually heard yesterday at Scorps that he probably will come straight back in this week. Not sure I agree with that.

saint patrick · Mon 07 Jul 2008 9:12pm

I would play Schneider if fit before Mini.....

Would also put some seriouss acid on him ...perform or it's Casey for a few weeks

and play him forward with Milne where he is dangerous...has big game runs on the board...time to walk the walk schneiderman

Solar · Post: # 599631Post **Solar** » Mon 07 Jul 2008 9:15pm

happy to play him but if he doesn't put in 100% effort with chasing, 1%'s etc. then its back to casey it goes.

bergsone · Post: # 599823Post **bergsone** » Tue 08 Jul 2008 6:02pm

Make him EARN his spot at casey first, didnt do NDS Milne any harm

Ralphy · Post: # 599825Post **Ralphy** » Tue 08 Jul 2008 6:04pm

im another one of his only fans,
he wasnt going to come straight into a new side, at the start of the year, and kick 5 every week, we dont expect that of him.

he will get better when each week progresses, he is still only young
i say
IN:
hayes,Schneids,Gardy

OUTS:
gwilt,Minnie,maybe either allen or Charlie gardiner

st_Trav_ofWA · Tue 08 Jul 2008 6:08pm

Saints Premiers 2008 wrote:
evertonfc wrote:I have realised I'm his only fan.

I'll leave the porch light on your Schneids, just like I did for Guerra...
x 2

he cops so much garbage from 'fans' here expecting instant results

also guerra should still be at the club..a disgrace he was delisted

to be precise we didnt delist him it just we didnt agree the price he put on his head suited the results he gave in return i was also a fan of Guerra and have defended his name many a time from those who blame the prelim loss on him in 2004 . as for shnides i dunno i just cant warm to the bloke maybe when he plays a few more games for us he will but at the moment he reminds me of Croad at freo

perfectionist · Tue 08 Jul 2008 8:12pm

Yes, we should bring him back at the MCG - as a rumble strip. Talk about being sold a pup! Jeeeesssshhh!

Winmarvellous · Tue 08 Jul 2008 9:51pm

Was wrapped we got him, now not so much. Think he needs to earn his place back, as opposed to those who've got us over the line the last 2.

Otiman · Post: # 599939Post **Otiman** » Wed 09 Jul 2008 12:22am

evertonfc wrote:I have realised I'm his only fan.

I'm a fan.

The bloke just doesn't deserve a spot based on form and effort (ala Milne + Dal Santo), compounded with coming back from injury (ala Gilbert).

Saints Premiers 2008 · Wed 09 Jul 2008 1:11am

st_Trav_ofWA wrote:
Saints Premiers 2008 wrote:
evertonfc wrote:I have realised I'm his only fan.

I'll leave the porch light on your Schneids, just like I did for Guerra...
x 2

he cops so much garbage from 'fans' here expecting instant results

also guerra should still be at the club..a disgrace he was delisted
to be precise we didnt delist him it just we didnt agree the price he put on his head suited the results he gave in return i was also a fan of Guerra and have defended his name many a time from those who blame the prelim loss on him in 2004 . as for shnides i dunno i just cant warm to the bloke maybe when he plays a few more games for us he will but at the moment he reminds me of Croad at freo

you really have no comprehension of anything remotely english do you

i have to put on a dumb voice inside my head to actually read what you have typed...