in and outs

Ralphy · Post: # 599838Post **Ralphy** » Tue 08 Jul 2008 6:47pm

well they just said on ten news that
schneider, hayes, Gardy
are all fit so most likely i think theyll be selected

plugger66 · Post: # 599840Post **plugger66** » Tue 08 Jul 2008 6:49pm

ralphysaints35 wrote:well they just said on ten news that
schneider, hayes, Gardy
are all fit so most likely i think theyll be selected

I think you are right.
Outs would be Allen, Gardiner and Eddy.

Ralphy · Post: # 599841Post **Ralphy** » Tue 08 Jul 2008 6:49pm

plugger66 wrote:
ralphysaints35 wrote:well they just said on ten news that
schneider, hayes, Gardy
are all fit so most likely i think theyll be selected
I think you are right.
Outs would be Allen, Gardiner and Eddy.

dont think theyll drop both gardiner and allen.
think gwilt. maybe

bergsone · Post: # 599842Post **bergsone** » Tue 08 Jul 2008 6:51pm

ralphysaints35 wrote:well they just said on ten news that
schneider, hayes, Gardy
are all fit so most likely i think theyll be selected

Just saw that,who ever misses for Schneider,who i dont consider has earnt a spot,is stiff

Ralphy · Post: # 599843Post **Ralphy** » Tue 08 Jul 2008 6:56pm

bergsone wrote:
ralphysaints35 wrote:well they just said on ten news that
schneider, hayes, Gardy
are all fit so most likely i think theyll be selected
Just saw that,who ever misses for Schneider,who i dont consider has earnt a spot,is stiff

and the emergencies will prob be Birss,(think he should be in the team)
Fiora
Maybe Fisher

sax · Post: # 599854Post **sax** » Tue 08 Jul 2008 7:42pm

This is how I'd like us to line up this week.

F: Milne, Koschitzke, Armitage
HF: Jones, Riewoldt, Harvey
C: Gram, Hayes, Montagna
HB: Gilbert, S. Fisher, Goddard
B: Dempster, Hudghton, Baker
R: King, Dal Santo, Ball
Int: M. Gardiner, Blake, Schneider, Eddy
Emg (from): Gwilt, Allen, McQualtar, Allen
In: Hayes, M. Gardiner, Schneider, Baker
Out: McQualtar, Gwilt, Allen, C. Gardiner

Only 1 tag, Baker - Judd
Let them tag us with the others!

Ralphy · Post: # 599856Post **Ralphy** » Tue 08 Jul 2008 7:52pm

does amertidge playing for the scorps tell us that he is being dropped?

spiral2 · Post: # 599857Post **spiral2** » Tue 08 Jul 2008 7:55pm

well if Schneider does get a run I hope he's been watching mini and eddy over the last few weeks & has learnt how to have a crack!

bigcarl · Post: # 599858Post **bigcarl** » Tue 08 Jul 2008 7:56pm

ralphysaints35 wrote:dont think theyll drop both gardiner and allen.
think gwilt. maybe

i'd be surprised if they drop allen.

that would leave us a key forward marking target short when riewoldt lines up on the wing, where he is playing his best football for some time.

i wouldn't drop gwilt either.

perfectionist · Tue 08 Jul 2008 8:00pm

I think this is a bit harsh. Charlie looks good but simply does not have football smarts. It's not that he lacks pace - he simply does not use it wisely. He does not seem to have that "second sight" that good AFL players need - at least on the forward line. Has he ever been tried back? Can't remember it at the Pussies.

I am always inclined to give the younger players more of a chance. But -

If everyone is fit --

In: Hayes, Baker, M Gardiner, Clarke (either one)
Out: Gilbert, Eddy, C Gardiner, Gwilt

Saints Premiers 2008 · Tue 08 Jul 2008 8:01pm

ralphysaints35 wrote:does amertidge playing for the scorps tell us that he is being dropped?

no...the more game time he gets into him without over-doing it the better

if he was to play 100% of matches now at his usual output would hurt his confidence, because he does not get the major possession yet despite having a few good hard tough moments

Solar · Post: # 599867Post **Solar** » Tue 08 Jul 2008 8:08pm

my guess

in: M.gardiner, Hayes, schneider
out: mini, eddy, gardiner

eddy and mini are stiff and if schneider doesn't work his butt off both along with birss and baker will push for selection in following weeks

Close to the best team for awhile. Agree with bigcarl, allen must stay in and continue his presenting and breaking of packs.

Gardiner to help king destroy carlton in the rucks.

perfectionist · Tue 08 Jul 2008 8:09pm

Did he play in the Scorpions? There was no mention of him in the reports.

Ralphy · Post: # 599869Post **Ralphy** » Tue 08 Jul 2008 8:10pm

perfectionist wrote:Did he play in the Scorpions? There was no mention of him in the reports.

i heard his name mentioned,

perfectionist · Tue 08 Jul 2008 8:14pm

ralphysaints35 wrote:i heard his name mentioned,

What as, car park attendant?

Ralphy · Post: # 599872Post **Ralphy** » Tue 08 Jul 2008 8:14pm

perfectionist wrote:
ralphysaints35 wrote:i heard his name mentioned,
What as, car park attendant?

he was on the ground handballing it when i heard it mentioned

perfectionist · Tue 08 Jul 2008 8:20pm

ralphysaints35 wrote:
perfectionist wrote:
ralphysaints35 wrote:i heard his name mentioned,
What as, car park attendant?
he was on the ground hand balling it when i heard it mentioned

Crikey! I'm surprised they haven't struck a medal!

Having said that, I would keep him in the "1s", although I'm not convinced about his commitment ( playing OK in front of your 'mates' at the Gold Coast is one thing - repeating it week after week is another), but I would like to see him take Murphy and thrash him.

bergsone · Post: # 599878Post **bergsone** » Tue 08 Jul 2008 8:30pm

I rated Schneider at swans,but really hasnt done enough to walk back in to a winning side on what his shown .IMO Hayes Gardiner in Out C Gardiner Mini.

rexy · Post: # 599882Post **rexy** » Tue 08 Jul 2008 8:50pm

I would prefer to see only one change with Hayes coming in and possibly C.Gardiner going out. I would have thought that the only other guys with the runs on the board to come straight in to our side would be Baker and X.

Schneider definately not an automatic selection and M Gardiner may not be suited to running around in the VFL due to his injury history but if we are nursing him that much then Im not sure we need to risk him against an undersized Carlton ruck division. Save him for a team with strong tap Ruckman.

Ralphy · Post: # 599883Post **Ralphy** » Tue 08 Jul 2008 8:52pm

rexy wrote:I would prefer to see only one change with Hayes coming in and possibly C.Gardiner going out. I would have thought that the only other guys with the runs on the board to come straight in to our side would be Baker and X.

Schneider definately not an automatic selection and M Gardiner may not be suited to running around in the VFL due to his injury history but if we are nursing him that much then Im not sure we need to risk him against an undersized Carlton ruck division. Save him for a team with strong tap Ruckman.

save him for hawks

Saints Premiers 2008 · Tue 08 Jul 2008 9:11pm

bergsone wrote:I rated Schneider at swans,but really hasnt done enough to walk back in to a winning side on what his shown .IMO Hayes Gardiner in Out C Gardiner Mini.

we have won two games in a row.....

rexy · Post: # 599890Post **rexy** » Tue 08 Jul 2008 9:25pm

Saints Premiers 2008 wrote:
bergsone wrote:I rated Schneider at swans,but really hasnt done enough to walk back in to a winning side on what his shown .IMO Hayes Gardiner in Out C Gardiner Mini.
we have won two games in a row.....

feels heaps better than losing 2

bergsone · Post: # 599906Post **bergsone** » Tue 08 Jul 2008 10:07pm

Saints Premiers 2008 wrote:
bergsone wrote:I rated Schneider at swans,but really hasnt done enough to walk back in to a winning side on what his shown .IMO Hayes Gardiner in Out C Gardiner Mini.
we have won two games in a row.....

Rather be winning than losing

Saints Premiers 2008 · Tue 08 Jul 2008 11:02pm

bergsone wrote:
Saints Premiers 2008 wrote:
bergsone wrote:I rated Schneider at swans,but really hasnt done enough to walk back in to a winning side on what his shown .IMO Hayes Gardiner in Out C Gardiner Mini.
we have won two games in a row.....
Rather be winning than losing

really???

the way previous posts are worded it sounds like we are on some sort of roll...

Teflon · Post: # 599924Post **Teflon** » Tue 08 Jul 2008 11:18pm

Solar wrote:my guess

in: M.gardiner, Hayes, schneider
out: mini, eddy, gardiner

eddy and mini are stiff and if schneider doesn't work his butt off both along with birss and baker will push for selection in following weeks

Close to the best team for awhile. Agree with bigcarl, allen must stay in and continue his presenting and breaking of packs.

Gardiner to help king destroy carlton in the rucks.

This looks ok solar except I reckon Eddy might be handy to help out shut down a small Carlton option like Betts???......Im not sure with mini/geary out we have many other options to play this role and Eddy is at least fit and hard enough.