rodgerfox wrote:Mr Magic wrote:
Maybe I'm not explaining myself clearly enough?
I accept that RL and his Coaching/Selection/Match Committee know more about why Armo was dropped and why he is getting played in the postitions he is being played, than I or any other person on this Forum.
For posters to state that they know better is clearly nonsense.
So because of the positions they hold, you trust them?
I don't.
I'd trust their judgement and ability to make those judgements based on their performances so far.
Based on that, I have no doubt that Lyon has reasons for his use of Armitage, and other players, however I strongly question whether or not they are the right judgements.
What has Lyon done since he's had the job to suggest he has good judgement when it comes to anything?
Fine, don't trust them - that is your perogative.
Just as it is mine to choose to trust those empowered by the members to run the Club (the Board) and their employees (the Coach and his sub-committees in this case).
Just because you have a differing opionion to others doesn't necessarily make your opinion correct. It may or may not be, yet you seem to refuse to accecpt any other opinion than your own and go even further - you dismiss out of hand any possibility that your opinion could be wrong, because afterall you are Rodgerfox, The Great Debater' of Saintsational.
Even your reason for not trusting them 'smacks' of your smug overinflated opinion of your knowledge on the subject.
You presume to judge their decisions on Armo because of your perception of their 'performance so far'?
Do you actually know what their decisions are and what they are based on?
Do you know what instructions they have given Armo pre-game and whether he has carried them out or not?
Do you know what discussions they have had with Armo during the week and what his response/performance has been re those instructions?
Can you truthfully answer yes to any of those questions?
I'd bet you cannot and yet you presume to tell us all that you know better.
Rodger, this time why don't you do something different than your normal pattern of behaviour and actually answer the questions I've just posed to you, instead of either 'deflecting' them or disappearing to another thread.