Battle of the D's

[desertsaint]

Rohan well and truly off the bandwagon now - article in The Age
Craig, Clarkson, Eade and Roos top 2008 class. June 15, 2008
http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/news/r ... 95696.html

Rates coaching performances this year
2 former assistants don't pass:

MARK HARVEY (Fremantle) D
A nightmare start to his first full season in charge, with only one win and five losses after the Dockers led at three-quarter-time. Some conservative team selection, ignoring the gun Palmer first-up, and has struggled in the media and public relations department at times. The Dockers are competitive, but Harvey can't afford to be too "bullish".

ROSS LYON (St Kilda) D
Hasn't been a great first half for club or coach. The much-discussed more defensive style hasn't delivered rewards, with the Saints seeming to have lost their attacking capabilities in the process. Lyon has been cautious on both the selection front, with too many kids not getting enough game time, and on match day, with not a lot of moves being made when things go awry. Heat will be on if Saints don't improve soon.


Accurate?
Wonder what they're saying re Harvey over at freo forums?
Do we have a trophy for games v freo - if not perhaps the losing coach this w'end wins a dunce's cap!