Aboriginal Players
Moderators: Saintsational Administrators, Saintsational Moderators
-
- Club Player
- Posts: 412
- Joined: Wed 05 May 2004 11:13pm
- Has thanked: 1 time
- Been thanked: 1 time
Aboriginal Players
Would we be the only club without an indigenous player playing this weekend?
Personally I find this dissapointing and the club should really be looking at recruiting some Indigenous talent, not because they are Aboriginal per say but because it would add an additional dimension to our side that is lacking; pace and flair.
Personally I find this dissapointing and the club should really be looking at recruiting some Indigenous talent, not because they are Aboriginal per say but because it would add an additional dimension to our side that is lacking; pace and flair.
- Saints Premiers 2008
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 4335
- Joined: Thu 27 Oct 2005 11:21pm
- Location: Brisbane
Re: Aboriginal Players
indigenous players only are ever pocket players really apart from the occassional johnson from freo or ryder from the dons...oh and franklin...jackal wrote:Would we be the only club without an indigenous player playing this weekend?
Personally I find this dissapointing and the club should really be looking at recruiting some Indigenous talent, not because they are Aboriginal per say but because it would add an additional dimension to our side that is lacking; pace and flair.
they look good cause they pull something from their behind once a game but apart from that they do bugger all (look at the kanga's forward pockets...do nothing but one decent tackle or goal a game)
very overrated due to their ability to make the highlight reel...
"It's a work in progress," Lyon said.
- saintsRrising
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 30094
- Joined: Mon 15 Mar 2004 11:07am
- Location: Melbourne
- Has thanked: 711 times
- Been thanked: 1234 times
Re: Aboriginal Players
So you have not seen Goodes play??Saints Premiers 2008 wrote:indigenous players only are ever pocket players really apart from the occassional johnson from freo or ryder from the dons...oh and franklin...jackal wrote:Would we be the only club without an indigenous player playing this weekend?
Personally I find this dissapointing and the club should really be looking at recruiting some Indigenous talent, not because they are Aboriginal per say but because it would add an additional dimension to our side that is lacking; pace and flair.
they look good cause they pull something from their behind once a game but apart from that they do bugger all (look at the kanga's forward pockets...do nothing but one decent tackle or goal a game)
very overrated due to their ability to make the highlight reel...
Or the Burgoynes?????
Polly Farmer reinvented how ruckman play.....
Winmar I thought was handy on a wing....and in the top handful of Saints ever....
Flying the World in comfort thanks to FF Points....
- mad saint guy
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 7077
- Joined: Tue 26 Jul 2005 9:44pm
- Location: Melbourne
- Has thanked: 52 times
- Been thanked: 366 times
Re: Aboriginal Players
Wouldn't mind having a few players like Kerr, P. Burgoyne, S. Burgoyne, Goodes, Wirrpanda, Al. Davey, Davis, Farmer or Rioli at St Kilda. Put any two or three of those players into the team and we instantly become a much better team.Saints Premiers 2008 wrote:they look good cause they pull something from their behind once a game but apart from that they do bugger all
Even known inconsistent players like Medhurst and Betts would be automatic starters for their pace and skill.
A decent tackle and a goal per game is more than what we've been getting from some guys getting games.(look at the kanga's forward pockets...do nothing but one decent tackle or goal a game) very overrated due to their ability to make the highlight reel...
Re: Aboriginal Players
Kerr isnt aboringinal.mad saint guy wrote:Wouldn't mind having a few players like Kerr, P. Burgoyne, S. Burgoyne, Goodes, Wirrpanda, Al. Davey, Davis, Farmer or Rioli at St Kilda. Put any two or three of those players into the team and we instantly become a much better team.Saints Premiers 2008 wrote:they look good cause they pull something from their behind once a game but apart from that they do bugger all
Even known inconsistent players like Medhurst and Betts would be automatic starters for their pace and skill.
A decent tackle and a goal per game is more than what we've been getting from some guys getting games.(look at the kanga's forward pockets...do nothing but one decent tackle or goal a game) very overrated due to their ability to make the highlight reel...
- Spinner
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 8502
- Joined: Sat 02 Dec 2006 3:40pm
- Location: Victoria
- Has thanked: 185 times
- Been thanked: 133 times
Re: Aboriginal Players
What a stupid post.jackal wrote:Would we be the only club without an indigenous player playing this weekend?
Personally I find this dissapointing and the club should really be looking at recruiting some Indigenous talent, not because they are Aboriginal per say but because it would add an additional dimension to our side that is lacking; pace and flair.
Why not recruit players based on their individual talents.....Rather then by stereotyping them because of the color of their skin.
Maybe we could bring back Alan Murray, fair bit of flair there.
- Saints Premiers 2008
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 4335
- Joined: Thu 27 Oct 2005 11:21pm
- Location: Brisbane
Re: Aboriginal Players
that was my point...not so susinctly putSpinner wrote:What a stupid post.jackal wrote:Would we be the only club without an indigenous player playing this weekend?
Personally I find this dissapointing and the club should really be looking at recruiting some Indigenous talent, not because they are Aboriginal per say but because it would add an additional dimension to our side that is lacking; pace and flair.
Why not recruit players based on their individual talents.....Rather then by stereotyping them because of the color of their skin.
Maybe we could bring back Alan Murray, fair bit of flair there.
"It's a work in progress," Lyon said.
- st_Trav_ofWA
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 8886
- Joined: Wed 13 Sep 2006 7:10pm
- Location: Perth
- Contact:
Re: Aboriginal Players
neither is medhurst Kerr is of indian decent and Medhurst is of macedonian decent .plugger66 wrote:Kerr isnt aboringinal.mad saint guy wrote:Wouldn't mind having a few players like Kerr, P. Burgoyne, S. Burgoyne, Goodes, Wirrpanda, Al. Davey, Davis, Farmer or Rioli at St Kilda. Put any two or three of those players into the team and we instantly become a much better team.Saints Premiers 2008 wrote:they look good cause they pull something from their behind once a game but apart from that they do bugger all
Even known inconsistent players like Medhurst and Betts would be automatic starters for their pace and skill.
A decent tackle and a goal per game is more than what we've been getting from some guys getting games.(look at the kanga's forward pockets...do nothing but one decent tackle or goal a game) very overrated due to their ability to make the highlight reel...
but serioulsy if we wish to fully embrace equallity in this country we gotta stop classing players cause they have aboriginal herritage Nicky Winmar was a great player who was aboriginal not a great aboriginal player......see the player not the race !!
"The team that wins in the most positions and makes the least amount of mistakes, usually wins the game." -- Allan Jeans
http://westernsaints.wordpress.com/
http://westernsaints.wordpress.com/
- Spinner
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 8502
- Joined: Sat 02 Dec 2006 3:40pm
- Location: Victoria
- Has thanked: 185 times
- Been thanked: 133 times
Re: Aboriginal Players
st_Trav_ofWA wrote:neither is medhurst Kerr is of indian decent and Medhurst is of macedonian decent .plugger66 wrote:Kerr isnt aboringinal.mad saint guy wrote:Wouldn't mind having a few players like Kerr, P. Burgoyne, S. Burgoyne, Goodes, Wirrpanda, Al. Davey, Davis, Farmer or Rioli at St Kilda. Put any two or three of those players into the team and we instantly become a much better team.Saints Premiers 2008 wrote:they look good cause they pull something from their behind once a game but apart from that they do bugger all
Even known inconsistent players like Medhurst and Betts would be automatic starters for their pace and skill.
A decent tackle and a goal per game is more than what we've been getting from some guys getting games.(look at the kanga's forward pockets...do nothing but one decent tackle or goal a game) very overrated due to their ability to make the highlight reel...
but serioulsy if we wish to fully embrace equallity in this country we gotta stop classing players cause they have aboriginal herritage Nicky Winmar was a great player who was aboriginal not a great aboriginal player......see the player not the race !!
cha ching!!!!
- my les foote
- Club Player
- Posts: 1024
- Joined: Tue 12 Dec 2006 6:03pm
- Location: Beside the seaside
- Been thanked: 2 times
Re: Aboriginal Players
I don't think it was your point.Saints Premiers 2008 wrote:that was my point...not so susinctly putSpinner wrote:What a stupid post.jackal wrote:Would we be the only club without an indigenous player playing this weekend?
Personally I find this dissapointing and the club should really be looking at recruiting some Indigenous talent, not because they are Aboriginal per say but because it would add an additional dimension to our side that is lacking; pace and flair.
Why not recruit players based on their individual talents.....Rather then by stereotyping them because of the color of their skin.
Maybe we could bring back Alan Murray, fair bit of flair there.
Win it for HIM!
- Enrico_Misso
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 11662
- Joined: Tue 13 Jun 2006 12:11am
- Location: Moorabbin Chapter of The Royal Society of Hagiographers
- Has thanked: 315 times
- Been thanked: 720 times
-
- Club Player
- Posts: 1129
- Joined: Thu 16 Sep 2004 5:32pm
- Has thanked: 18 times
- Been thanked: 30 times
Re: Aboriginal Players
mate are you crazy. you obviously have issues.Saints Premiers 2008 wrote:
indigenous players only are ever pocket players really apart from the occassional johnson from freo or ryder from the dons...oh and franklin...
they look good cause they pull something from their behind once a game but apart from that they do bugger all (look at the kanga's forward pockets...do nothing but one decent tackle or goal a game)
very overrated due to their ability to make the highlight reel...
goodes, darryl white, o'loughlin... pocket players?
wirapanda has been hard nut week in week out for 10 years now.
winmar was the best tackler i have ever seen. andy mcleod has been doing it for 10 years now week in week out. johncock, burgoynes, all consitenet all round players for long periods... cant believe we are having this discussion. maybe your view has been tainted by the clarke brothers.
but i agree with the poster. disapointing we have missed out on new guys like cyril and josh hill.
-
- Club Player
- Posts: 1129
- Joined: Thu 16 Sep 2004 5:32pm
- Has thanked: 18 times
- Been thanked: 30 times
Re: Aboriginal Players
kerr is sri lankan!mad saint guy wrote:Wouldn't mind having a few players like Kerr, P. Burgoyne, S. Burgoyne, Goodes, Wirrpanda, Al. Davey, Davis, Farmer or Rioli at St Kilda. Put any two or three of those players into the team and we instantly become a much better team.Saints Premiers 2008 wrote:they look good cause they pull something from their behind once a game but apart from that they do bugger all
Even known inconsistent players like Medhurst and Betts would be automatic starters for their pace and skill.
A decent tackle and a goal per game is more than what we've been getting from some guys getting games.(look at the kanga's forward pockets...do nothing but one decent tackle or goal a game) very overrated due to their ability to make the highlight reel...
-
- SS Life Member
- Posts: 2537
- Joined: Mon 27 Jun 2005 1:27pm
- Location: Abiding
- Has thanked: 171 times
- Been thanked: 384 times
Re: Aboriginal Players
aside from the obvious offensiveness of this post , I will make the following observationsSaints Premiers 2008 wrote:indigenous players only are ever pocket players really apart from the occassional johnson from freo or ryder from the dons...oh and franklin...jackal wrote:Would we be the only club without an indigenous player playing this weekend?
Personally I find this dissapointing and the club should really be looking at recruiting some Indigenous talent, not because they are Aboriginal per say but because it would add an additional dimension to our side that is lacking; pace and flair.
they look good cause they pull something from their behind once a game but apart from that they do bugger all (look at the kanga's forward pockets...do nothing but one decent tackle or goal a game)
very overrated due to their ability to make the highlight reel...
I believe that the St. Kilda FC was one of the first clubs to consistently recruit and play indigenous players.
I think you will find Hawthorn and a couple of other clubs have only recently begun to recruit indigenous players.
We now have X and R , but over the last 40 years we have had sides with many great indigenous players, obviously winmar muir ,mcadam, jeffrey, narkle, mitchell
It is fantastic to have a round to celebrate the contribution that indigenous players have made.
Trite comments like why not celebrate Italian players, do nothing to improve the posters standing.
Please go and read about Australia and the games history before making posts like that.
fqf
what we want is an aboriginal player who can kick a couple of goals, lay off a couple, frustrate the opposition, offer a bit of forward pressure and support the big men with a bit of flair and dash
I reckon we are pretty luck to have Stephen Milne in the side...
I reckon we are pretty luck to have Stephen Milne in the side...
Bewaire krime, da krimson bolt is comeing to yure nayborhood to smach krime
SHUT UP KRIME!
SHUT UP KRIME!
- killa_gram
- Club Player
- Posts: 1820
- Joined: Wed 21 Jul 2004 2:53pm
- Location: Camp X-Ray
Re: Aboriginal Players
I thought Kerr was of Mauritiun heritage.congorozides wrote:kerr is sri lankan!mad saint guy wrote:Wouldn't mind having a few players like Kerr, P. Burgoyne, S. Burgoyne, Goodes, Wirrpanda, Al. Davey, Davis, Farmer or Rioli at St Kilda. Put any two or three of those players into the team and we instantly become a much better team.Saints Premiers 2008 wrote:they look good cause they pull something from their behind once a game but apart from that they do bugger all
Even known inconsistent players like Medhurst and Betts would be automatic starters for their pace and skill.
A decent tackle and a goal per game is more than what we've been getting from some guys getting games.(look at the kanga's forward pockets...do nothing but one decent tackle or goal a game) very overrated due to their ability to make the highlight reel...
Innocent until proven guilty!
I'm Baaaaaaaaack!!!!!!
I'm Baaaaaaaaack!!!!!!
Re: Aboriginal Players
Kerr is definitley half Indian. Theres not many of us indians playing, so we need all all the credit we can get!!!congorozides wrote: kerr is sri lankan!
BTW here is a great wikipedia page that lists players by their ethnicity
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_VF ... _ethnicity
_________________
Silly customer, you cannot hurt a twinkie
Silly customer, you cannot hurt a twinkie
- degruch
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 8948
- Joined: Mon 19 May 2008 4:29pm
- Location: Croydonia
- Has thanked: 146 times
- Been thanked: 237 times
Re: Aboriginal Players
BTW here is a great wikipedia page that lists players by their ethnicity
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_VF ... _ethnicity[/quote]
Interesting, but gawd there's some drivel there...Nick Riewoldt speaks with a German accent and eats sour kraut for lunch, does he? Just because you've got a surname of Germanic extract doesn't make you German...I'm not French! Wikipedia...it's not an encyclopedia, it's a role playing game!!!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_VF ... _ethnicity[/quote]
Interesting, but gawd there's some drivel there...Nick Riewoldt speaks with a German accent and eats sour kraut for lunch, does he? Just because you've got a surname of Germanic extract doesn't make you German...I'm not French! Wikipedia...it's not an encyclopedia, it's a role playing game!!!
-
- Club Player
- Posts: 1058
- Joined: Tue 08 Feb 2005 1:18pm
- Location: Malvern East
- Has thanked: 86 times
- Been thanked: 34 times
Well, it's bad luck we don't have any indigenous players on the turf this Sunday but we can't just go and pick players for this point alone - and we should't be recruiting indigenous players on race alone.jackal wrote:Would we be the only club without an indigenous player playing this weekend?
Personally I find this disappointing and the club should really be looking at recruiting some Indigenous talent, not because they are Aboriginal per say but because it would add an additional dimension to our side that is lacking; pace and flair.
However, I have no problems in you opening this thread on the issue and believe that you, and many others, are licking their lips at some of the smaller pacey indigenous players going around at the moment - especially Saints supporters, because of our perceived lack of pace and x factor.
If footy matches can significantly help any community sub cultural group I can't see any problems with our club and the AFL supporting the cause. If awareness and promotion can improve peoples way of life, surely it will strengthen our community in general, 'Italians, Greeks and Kazakhstans' included, if and when we believed they needed it. We even have a match to help promote awareness of cancer research and our club is involved with various schemes to improve the lives of disadvantaged people.Enrico_Misso wrote:In which rounds are we honouring players from Italy, Greece and Kazakhstan ?
I can remember when Italian and Greek people/players were marginalised and called "Filthy Dago's", "Greezy Greeks" and worse by supporters, opposition players and myself included - Just as well they came from a less fragile cultural background and the racial vilification laws weren't around then.
-
- Club Player
- Posts: 792
- Joined: Sat 26 Apr 2008 10:45pm
- Has thanked: 52 times
- Been thanked: 97 times
Re: Aboriginal Players
\\\\Saints Premiers 2008 wrote:indigenous players only are ever pocket players really apart from the occassional johnson from freo or ryder from the dons...oh and franklin...jackal wrote:Would we be the only club without an indigenous player playing this weekend?
Personally I find this dissapointing and the club should really be looking at recruiting some Indigenous talent, not because they are Aboriginal per say but because it would add an additional dimension to our side that is lacking; pace and flair.
they look good cause they pull something from their behind once a game but apart from that they do bugger all (look at the kanga's forward pockets...do nothing but one decent tackle or goal a game)
very overrated due to their ability to make the highlight reel...
Possibly the biggest load of bs that i have ever heard...does this bloke know anything about footy?...Or maybe there is something more to this than an honest assessment of playing abilty?
- cowboy18
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 5795
- Joined: Tue 09 Mar 2004 1:05pm
- Location: in my duffle coat
- Has thanked: 3 times
- Been thanked: 5 times
I'm quite comfortable with a special weekend for aboriginal footballers - it's a unique case (IMO) where the indigenous community has had a deep and positive impact on the broader community. The racially driven stereotypes of flashy, explosive and exciting players hold up to scrutiny from my perspective. It's probably one of the first workplaces in greater Australia that aboriginals were accepted on their merits.Enrico_Misso wrote:In which rounds are we honouring players from Italy, Greece and Kazakhstan ?
Having said that, two facts lead me to support your quest for an annual AFL Wogfest.
a) I have a woggy surname and
b) my 5yo chose to go to mufti day in the heritage away strip (coupled with saints shorts, socks and his 2008 members scarf - he's indoctrinated now! )He needs something to celebrate when he runs out for us in 2021.
I'm thinking it was a bit of a pysstake but I could be wrong.
I love winmar not because he was aboriginal but because of the way he played.
stereotyping occurs, yes, 4 clubs tried to turn Dale Kickett into a high marking dashing HFF/FP, played his best footy off the HBF
Wirrapanda was originally seen as a dashing HFF, now a brilliant B/P
wanganeen, BP/HBF/wingman occassional forward.
Michael O'laughlin, most overrated FP, for a guy of his size, build and skill, he's a lazy prick, nothing to do with being aboriginal, just another doc whealdon
Folks look and point at the aboriginal HFF/FP running around essendon, Richmond and Melbourne and say 'where's ours" I point to schneider and Milne and say 'THERE!'
Judge the player for the player not by the colour.
The comments I make about Mal Michael, I'd make the same about micky martyn and Mick Gayfer and at the end of his career Gary Pert too. Stupid thug gorilla backmen, nothing racist in it, just a description of their style.
I used to love the PRE GF highlights reel for winmar, barker, Dale Kickett, Locket a dn Loewe's marks that made about 20 of the 200 odd marks they took, about 5 from barker and winmar each, one screamer from plugger over Dougie Hawkins (I was there at western Oval, Plugger kicked 3.5 that day ) and a couple of risers from buckets.
I admire the amazing atheleticism of Buddy but <injunction> makes him a protected player.
Folks make comments about Goodes being a 'protected species" because of his aboriginality, I would say he is a protected species because he's a swan.
Get over the colour thing, its not 1995 any more, and even the filth have embraced our indiginous brothers in their team (well most of them Joffa probably still squirms when Neon Leon scores a goal)
I love winmar not because he was aboriginal but because of the way he played.
stereotyping occurs, yes, 4 clubs tried to turn Dale Kickett into a high marking dashing HFF/FP, played his best footy off the HBF
Wirrapanda was originally seen as a dashing HFF, now a brilliant B/P
wanganeen, BP/HBF/wingman occassional forward.
Michael O'laughlin, most overrated FP, for a guy of his size, build and skill, he's a lazy prick, nothing to do with being aboriginal, just another doc whealdon
Folks look and point at the aboriginal HFF/FP running around essendon, Richmond and Melbourne and say 'where's ours" I point to schneider and Milne and say 'THERE!'
Judge the player for the player not by the colour.
The comments I make about Mal Michael, I'd make the same about micky martyn and Mick Gayfer and at the end of his career Gary Pert too. Stupid thug gorilla backmen, nothing racist in it, just a description of their style.
I used to love the PRE GF highlights reel for winmar, barker, Dale Kickett, Locket a dn Loewe's marks that made about 20 of the 200 odd marks they took, about 5 from barker and winmar each, one screamer from plugger over Dougie Hawkins (I was there at western Oval, Plugger kicked 3.5 that day ) and a couple of risers from buckets.
I admire the amazing atheleticism of Buddy but <injunction> makes him a protected player.
Folks make comments about Goodes being a 'protected species" because of his aboriginality, I would say he is a protected species because he's a swan.
Get over the colour thing, its not 1995 any more, and even the filth have embraced our indiginous brothers in their team (well most of them Joffa probably still squirms when Neon Leon scores a goal)
Bewaire krime, da krimson bolt is comeing to yure nayborhood to smach krime
SHUT UP KRIME!
SHUT UP KRIME!