Who's the most over rated, under rated player

[The Craw]

Along the same lines as the under rated player thread, there is always a player who is constantly referred to as under rated but clearly doesn't deserve the tag.

For mine it is Scott Lucas, most over rated player in any category.

[esaint66]

Along the same lines as the under rated player thread, there is always a player who is constantly referred to as under rated but clearly doesn't deserve the tag.

For mine it is Scott Lucas, most over rated player in any category.

seeing as we already have a post on this can you just post in there to save space and time.

[Spinner]

Along the same lines as the under rated player thread, there is always a player who is constantly referred to as under rated but clearly doesn't deserve the tag.

For mine it is Scott Lucas, most over rated player in any category.

seeing as we already have a post on this can you just post in there to save space and time.

Totally different topic dude.

[Spinner]

Along the same lines as the under rated player thread, there is always a player who is constantly referred to as under rated but clearly doesn't deserve the tag.

For mine it is Scott Lucas, most over rated player in any category.

Hit the nail on the head...

...I think you will find most Essendon and Collingwood players are rated way above their actual worth because of the hype and media associated with those teams.

[i_luv_nick_riewoldt]

sam fisher is underrated by media personnel!

[saint66au]

2/3 of Freo's playing list

Always annoys me when Freo play well that suddenly they have 12 "underrated" players in their side

What they actually have is bunch of GOP's who. to beat the good sides, rely on the only actual superstar in their squad to play a blinder

[Eastern]

Using the form of some on this forum over the years;

Max Hudghton

Lenny Hayes

Brendan Goddard

!!

[st_Trav_ofWA]

2/3 of Freo's playing list

Always annoys me when Freo play well that suddenly they have 12 "underrated" players in their side

What they actually have is bunch of GOP's who. to beat the good sides, rely on the only actual superstar in their squad to play a blinder

2/3 of Freo thats being gernerous i would say their whole list is full of soft front runners who hope and pray pavlova can put something brilliant out of his arse to get them into the finals