Saints list...who will miss??

saintsRrising · Fri 07 Mar 2008 12:22pm

NAB CUP GRAND FINAL SQUADS

ADELAIDE
B: Johncock, Rutten, Stevens
HB: Symes, Bock, van Berlo
C: McLeod, Thompson, Mackay
HF: Porplyzia, Tippett, Goodwin
F: Vince, McGregor, Burton
Foll: Maric, Reilly, Knights
I/C: Moran, Griffin, Bassett, Edwards, Doughty, Shirley, Douglas, Campbell
EMG: Massie, Sellar, Jericho
ST KILDA
B: Gilbert, Hudghton, Baker
HB: Gram, S Fisher, L Fisher
C: Fiora, Hayes, Montagna
HF: Harvey, Riewoldt, Clarke
F: Schneider, Koschitzke, Gardiner
Foll: King, Dal Santo, Ball 14
I/C (from): Gardiner, Clarke, Rix, Geary, Milne, Jones, Birss, Armitage, Eddy, McQualter, Blake, Allen

Strong looking Saints list...but the squad has to be narrowed down.

Who will miss.....and will it be by rotation...or by going for best available team instead??

If on form you would think Rix, Mini, Allen (has looked ok, but Roo, Kosi and Charlie area better 3) ...............and wow this last one is tough ...Eddy.

Going to very tough for Round 1 when you will have to narrow it futher to only 22.

Ralphy · Post: # 528020Post **Ralphy** » Fri 07 Mar 2008 12:44pm

Max wont play..... think he will be a late withdrawal.

maybe rix....mcqualter, allen

Dan Warna · Post: # 528022Post **Dan Warna** » Fri 07 Mar 2008 12:46pm

I think some won't come up from injury and the team might select itself.

as for round 1, better to hve a full list than plug through which of players from 30 to 38 can play CHF, FF, FP, RR, and CHB...

riccardo · Post: # 528024Post **riccardo** » Fri 07 Mar 2008 12:50pm

Can someone please tell me which Clarke is on the ground, please?

Does anyone know?

ausfatcat · Post: # 528028Post **ausfatcat** » Fri 07 Mar 2008 1:01pm

riccardo wrote:Can someone please tell me which Clarke is on the ground, please?

Does anyone know?

he's a HFF so 99.9% sure it would be x clarke

riccardo · Post: # 528031Post **riccardo** » Fri 07 Mar 2008 1:08pm

ausfatcat wrote:
riccardo wrote:Can someone please tell me which Clarke is on the ground, please?

Does anyone know?
he's a HFF so 99.9% sure it would be x clarke

Cool. Thanks.

Bernard Shakey · Fri 07 Mar 2008 1:14pm

Max will play!

As I said on another thread he needs the run. How many minutes is anyones guess.

Quixote · Post: # 528036Post **Quixote** » Fri 07 Mar 2008 1:18pm

Bit of trivia...

Three Crows players left from the '97 Granny - McLeod, Goodwin, Edwards.

Two Saints players remain from same game - Max and Harves. Of which I expect only the latter to play.

No player from either list born the last time St Kilda won a day Premiership.

chook23 · Post: # 528043Post **chook23** » Fri 07 Mar 2008 1:30pm

Quixote wrote:Bit of trivia...

Three Crows players left from the '97 Granny - McLeod, Goodwin, Edwards.

Two Saints players remain from same game - Max and Harves. Of which I expect only the latter to play.

No player from either list born the last time St Kilda won a day Premiership.

It is coming up 42 years!!!

Quixote · Post: # 528046Post **Quixote** » Fri 07 Mar 2008 1:43pm

chook23 wrote:
Quixote wrote:Bit of trivia...

Three Crows players left from the '97 Granny - McLeod, Goodwin, Edwards.

Two Saints players remain from same game - Max and Harves. Of which I expect only the latter to play.

No player from either list born the last time St Kilda won a day Premiership.
It is coming up 42 years!!!

Oh When the Saints · Fri 07 Mar 2008 1:45pm

Doubt they would have named Maxie if he wasn't going to play, but RL likes playing ducks and drakes with team selection.

IMO McQualter and Rix are almost certain to miss, and Allen likely to miss too ...

Geez, imagine chucking BJ, Goose and Gehrig into that lineup ...

plugger66 · Post: # 528050Post **plugger66** » Fri 07 Mar 2008 2:05pm

Bernard Shakey wrote:Max will play!

As I said on another thread he needs the run. How many minutes is anyones guess.

Wheres G then.

barks4eva · Post: # 528054Post **barks4eva** » Fri 07 Mar 2008 2:18pm

plugger66 wrote:
Wheres G then.

It's the letter after F and the one before H, hope that helps, if you need anymore help with the alphabet or even the english language, be sure to ask.

plugger66 · Post: # 528055Post **plugger66** » Fri 07 Mar 2008 2:23pm

barks4eva wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
Wheres G then.
It's the letter after F and the one before H, hope that helps, if you need anymore help with the alphabet or even the english language, be sure to ask.

Thanks for your help. Another one for the alphabet. Whers G and T.

barks4eva · Post: # 528057Post **barks4eva** » Fri 07 Mar 2008 2:32pm

plugger66 wrote:
Thanks for your help. Another one for the alphabet. Whers G and T.

Where's not Whers

I already told you where G is, please pay attention.

T is between S and U

S T U sometimes I like to be creative, mix the letters up a bit and instead of the usual order of STU, throw in another one just to keep things interesting such as STFU.

Hope that's not too confusing for you.

plugger66 · Post: # 528060Post **plugger66** » Fri 07 Mar 2008 2:41pm

barks4eva wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
Thanks for your help. Another one for the alphabet. Whers G and T.
Where's not Whers

I already told you where G is, please pay attention.

T is between S and U

S T U sometimes I like to be creative, mix the letters up a bit and instead of the usual order of STU, throw in another one just to keep things interesting such as STFU.

Hope that's not too confusing for you.

English isnt a strong point. Thanks for help. Stats and averages is also not good for me. Now if there are 16 sides in the comp and you are last in hitouts and 13th in hitouts to advantage what is your average.

Bernard Shakey · Fri 07 Mar 2008 2:56pm

Mr Train is obviously having a rest.

In the words of the great Mr Loaf, 2 out of 3 aint bad.

borderbarry · Fri 07 Mar 2008 3:11pm

Does Birss deserve a place before some of the young ones?

barks4eva · Post: # 528068Post **barks4eva** » Fri 07 Mar 2008 3:11pm

plugger66 wrote: English isnt a strong point. Thanks for help. Stats and averages is also not good for me. Now if there are 16 sides in the comp and you are last in hitouts and 13th in hitouts to advantage what is your average.

Really I think we should deal with your english and the alphabet first before moving on, but I'll give you a clue about the stat you inquired about, if you do the maths, you'll find the squares are rooted.

barks4eva · Post: # 528069Post **barks4eva** » Fri 07 Mar 2008 3:15pm

borderbarry wrote:Does Birss deserve a place before some of the young ones?

definitely not, IMHO

The upside with younger players is potentially massive, whereas with Birss you know what to expect and it's just not enough to justify his selection above players such as Armitage, Geary, Eddy etc...etc...etc...etc...etc...etc...etc...etc...

Armoooo · Post: # 528074Post **Armoooo** » Fri 07 Mar 2008 3:45pm

barks4eva wrote:
borderbarry wrote:Does Birss deserve a place before some of the young ones?
definitely not, IMHO

The upside with younger players is potentially massive, whereas with Birss you know what to expect and it's just not enough to justify his selection above players such as Armitage, Geary, Eddy etc...etc...etc...etc...etc...etc...etc...etc...

Are we talking for this match or round 1? for this match I would rather have Birss over Steven however for round one I would rather Armo over Birss, so really it depends on the variables...

plugger66 · Post: # 528132Post **plugger66** » Fri 07 Mar 2008 5:26pm

Bernard Shakey wrote:Mr Train is obviously having a rest.

In the words of the great Mr Loaf, 2 out of 3 aint bad.

I havent heard of the song one out of three aint bad though.

Bernard Shakey · Fri 07 Mar 2008 9:34pm

It's haven't.

Max is distraught.

Ralphy · Post: # 528207Post **Ralphy** » Fri 07 Mar 2008 9:42pm

is max playing?

saint66au · Post: # 528215Post **saint66au** » Fri 07 Mar 2008 9:50pm

ralphysaints35 wrote:is max playing?

NO he isnt..as at least two other threads on here will tell you..

Please please please have a little look around before you post