Delistings and list management
Moderators: Saintsational Administrators, Saintsational Moderators
Delistings and list management
My post from 24/9 is below. The 3 guys I thought should be delisted were yesterday (Brooks, Mini, Watts). Gwilt with a ? wasnt. Raymond and Sweeney had already gone. Its not often you pick up 4 AFL quality players with basically one pick (forget about pick 90), with 3 of those having Premiership experience. Well done Ross and Trout. ***Well done Ross on your final delisting of the day. Trout, the last week has shown that you have the qualities to be a good General Manager - Football***. Ruck-wise, we now have King, Gardiner, Van Rheenan and Rix. Id throw in someone like Dawson Simpson with our last pick next month as well.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sept 29, 2007
We are now paying the price of poor list management:
This year we had 44 on our list (incl Rookies).
Players retired (5):
M. Clarke
Thompson
Voss
Hamill
Gehrig
Injured for 2008 (1):
Attard
Injured coming back for 2008 (so dont expect full seasons) (2):
Gardiner
Goddard
44-6=36 with another 2 doubtful.
Players that shouldnt be there next season include:
Watts
Brooks
McQualter
Gwilt?
Raymond
Sweeney
That leaves us with 30 and 2 doubtful. Unfortunately we cant go having 12 picks in the draft so we are in a bit of strife for the next couple of years until the Armitage's and Gilberts etc get more games under their belt. Areas like this is where the prvious Coach severely let the club down.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sept 29, 2007
We are now paying the price of poor list management:
This year we had 44 on our list (incl Rookies).
Players retired (5):
M. Clarke
Thompson
Voss
Hamill
Gehrig
Injured for 2008 (1):
Attard
Injured coming back for 2008 (so dont expect full seasons) (2):
Gardiner
Goddard
44-6=36 with another 2 doubtful.
Players that shouldnt be there next season include:
Watts
Brooks
McQualter
Gwilt?
Raymond
Sweeney
That leaves us with 30 and 2 doubtful. Unfortunately we cant go having 12 picks in the draft so we are in a bit of strife for the next couple of years until the Armitage's and Gilberts etc get more games under their belt. Areas like this is where the prvious Coach severely let the club down.
- my les foote
- Club Player
- Posts: 1024
- Joined: Tue 12 Dec 2006 6:03pm
- Location: Beside the seaside
- Been thanked: 2 times
Re: Delistings and list management
Some punctuation might help here.Bono wrote: The 3 guys I thought should be delisted were yesterday (Brooks, Mini, Watts).
Are you saying they were delisted yesterday?
Or are they they guys you thought about yesterday as being candidates for delisting?
If it's the first option, that is breaking news.
Win it for HIM!
- my les foote
- Club Player
- Posts: 1024
- Joined: Tue 12 Dec 2006 6:03pm
- Location: Beside the seaside
- Been thanked: 2 times
-
- SS Life Member
- Posts: 3465
- Joined: Fri 29 Oct 2004 1:01pm
- Has thanked: 91 times
- Been thanked: 162 times
- Animal Enclosure
- SS Hall of Fame
- Posts: 2364
- Joined: Mon 04 Apr 2005 2:37pm
- Location: Saints Footy Central
- Art Vandelay
- Club Player
- Posts: 92
- Joined: Sat 06 Oct 2007 1:45pm
One thing that everyone should have learnt from visiting footy forums on the web is that most of the speculationa nd inuendo turns out to be false.
It is so easy for some anonymous poster to come on and reveal that a close 'source' linked to club has told him/her something in confidence, only to find out later on that it turns out to be a pile of sh!t.
Until the club makes an official media release regarding any delistings, I will treat the above as speculation only. It may turn out that some/all of these guys actually do get delisted, but blind freddy could npminate these guys - there is nothing there that is earth shattering.
It is so easy for some anonymous poster to come on and reveal that a close 'source' linked to club has told him/her something in confidence, only to find out later on that it turns out to be a pile of sh!t.
Until the club makes an official media release regarding any delistings, I will treat the above as speculation only. It may turn out that some/all of these guys actually do get delisted, but blind freddy could npminate these guys - there is nothing there that is earth shattering.
- Oh When the Saints
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 5621
- Joined: Wed 29 Mar 2006 4:25pm
- Location: QLD
- Contact:
-
- Club Player
- Posts: 105
- Joined: Mon 03 Sep 2007 12:59am
i dont think we have had poor list management at all...we have possibly the most depth we have had for quite some time. and surely the saints wouldnt delist themselves down to 32 players when now they can only get themselves back up to 37? that would be foolish imo and a professional club in the elite league would not do such a thing....
such is life
[quote="Art Vandelay"]One thing that everyone should have learnt from visiting footy forums on the web is that most of the speculationa nd inuendo turns out to be false.
It is so easy for some anonymous poster to come on and reveal that a close 'source' linked to club has told him/her something in confidence, only to find out later on that it turns out to be a pile of sh!t.
Until the club makes an official media release regarding any delistings, I will treat the above as speculation only. It may turn out that some/all of these guys actually do get delisted, but blind freddy could npminate these guys - there is nothing there that is earth shattering.[/quote]
Why do you read these forums then!?
Trout is Elshaug.
It is so easy for some anonymous poster to come on and reveal that a close 'source' linked to club has told him/her something in confidence, only to find out later on that it turns out to be a pile of sh!t.
Until the club makes an official media release regarding any delistings, I will treat the above as speculation only. It may turn out that some/all of these guys actually do get delisted, but blind freddy could npminate these guys - there is nothing there that is earth shattering.[/quote]
Why do you read these forums then!?
Trout is Elshaug.
[quote="Bono"][quote="Art Vandelay"]One thing that everyone should have learnt from visiting footy forums on the web is that most of the speculationa nd inuendo turns out to be false.
It is so easy for some anonymous poster to come on and reveal that a close 'source' linked to club has told him/her something in confidence, only to find out later on that it turns out to be a pile of sh!t.
Until the club makes an official media release regarding any delistings, I will treat the above as speculation only. It may turn out that some/all of these guys actually do get delisted, but blind freddy could npminate these guys - there is nothing there that is earth shattering.[/quote]
Why do you read these forums then!?
Trout is Elshaug.[/quote]
Hand in your Avatar Art and spend a $1.40 on the Age. At least you'll be supporting our sponsors. Bono's stuff is the lifeblood of the forums.
It is so easy for some anonymous poster to come on and reveal that a close 'source' linked to club has told him/her something in confidence, only to find out later on that it turns out to be a pile of sh!t.
Until the club makes an official media release regarding any delistings, I will treat the above as speculation only. It may turn out that some/all of these guys actually do get delisted, but blind freddy could npminate these guys - there is nothing there that is earth shattering.[/quote]
Why do you read these forums then!?
Trout is Elshaug.[/quote]
Hand in your Avatar Art and spend a $1.40 on the Age. At least you'll be supporting our sponsors. Bono's stuff is the lifeblood of the forums.
I'm loving this - underdogs at 3 to 1, grand final experience in our favor and Pies over confident. Go Saints - I'm loading up!
- Riewoldting
- SS Life Member
- Posts: 2883
- Joined: Thu 05 May 2005 1:34am
- Location: Perth WA
- Scoop
- Club Player
- Posts: 807
- Joined: Tue 09 Mar 2004 10:29pm
- Location: On a New Street Corner
- Has thanked: 516 times
- Been thanked: 43 times
My you are a doubting Thomas (freudian slip?) Art.Art Vandelay wrote:One thing that everyone should have learnt from visiting footy forums on the web is that most of the speculationa nd inuendo turns out to be false.
It is so easy for some anonymous poster to come on and reveal that a close 'source' linked to club has told him/her something in confidence, only to find out later on that it turns out to be a pile of sh!t.
Until the club makes an official media release regarding any delistings, I will treat the above as speculation only. It may turn out that some/all of these guys actually do get delisted, but blind freddy could npminate these guys - there is nothing there that is earth shattering.
Bono's news aint no pile of sh!t....as you so eloquently put it.
Extra! Extra! Read all about it......no I don't want to read about it anymore!!!