Votes v Blues

[George27]

Great finish to the season.

Very even performance.

4. Jack Sinclair. Poise .

3. Zak Jones. Endeavour.

2. Darcy Wilson.

2. Mattaes Philippou.

1. Hunter Clark. Very good inside.

1. Jack Steele. Last quarter vital.

1. Jack Higgins. That goal deserves a vote.

1. Jimmy Webster. Clamped their small forwards

[B.M]

5-Sinclair
4-Phillipou
3-Wood
2-Nas
1-Jones

Byrnes just misses out

[saynta]

5. Sinclair.
4. Wilson.
3. Phillipou.
2. Jones.
1. Higgins.

[desertsaint]

Sincs
Poo
Roma
Wood
Steele

[avid]

Sinclair 4
jones 3
clark 3
philipou 2
wood 2
higgins 1

[King Max]

Sinclair
Pou
Jones
NWM
HIGGINSSSSSSS!

[Banger9798]

5 Sinclair
4. Higgins
3. Phillipou
2. Clark
1. Wilson


Pretty even performance

[JR23]

Based on outcome and big efforts

1. Higgins ( very few players can kick that goal)
2. NWM ( silky what can you say)
3. Pou ( skill, poise, can kick for goal better.... )
4. Jones ( great smother)
5. Battle ( we need to keep him)

[saintbob]

5 Sinclair
4 NWM
3 Pou
2 Battle
1 Wood

[Scollop]

5 Clark
4 Pou
3 Steele
1 Wilson
1 Webster
1 Higgins

[StPeter]

5 Sinclair
2 Jones
2 Pou
1 Clark
1 Wilson
1 Steele
1 NWM
1 Marshall
1 Byrnes

Sinclair clearly Best for Saints and BOG according to at least one radio station.
Probably the only player on the ground to make something of all of his (28) possessions.
Very even performance from several other Saints players.

Scollop once again couldn't find a place for Sinclair in his top 6 players for the Saints.

[silverhalo]

Surprised to see Battle in a couple of posters' votes.... I thought he wasn't as prominent as usual today, neither was Cal Wilkie

[Scollop]

Sinclair clearly Best for Saints and BOG according to at least one radio station.
Probably the only player on the ground to make something of all of his (28) possessions.
Very even performance from several other Saints players.

Scollop once again couldn't find a place for Sinclair in his top 6 players for the Saints.

Stalker…

By the way…I’m not Robinson Crusoe. You’ll find not everyone voted for him. It’s not clear at all that he was BOG. If Pou hits that last goal it’s a no brainer that he is BOG

Sinclair is playing back in defence. He gets plenty of cheap possessions from kicking out when oppo teams kick a behind. Today he got 4 and Nas got 4. Take out his 4 kicks and judge him on 24 possessions and compare what he does with Hunter or Pou or Steele

I generally value our mids. Clark, Pou and Steele had the bulk of our inside 50’s and centre clearances.

[WellardSaint]

Surprised to see Battle in a couple of posters' votes.... I thought he wasn't as prominent as usual today, neither was Cal Wilkie

Cal was rated by Champion Data as being in the bottom 5 of our team, AF points- 31, same as Garcia.
Cal got 4 kicks, 2 marks, 7 handballs

[1965 Saint]

5 Wilson
4 Jones
3 NWS
2 Sinclair
1 Webster

[StPeter]

Sinclair clearly Best for Saints and BOG according to at least one radio station.
Probably the only player on the ground to make something of all of his (28) possessions.
Very even performance from several other Saints players.

Scollop once again couldn't find a place for Sinclair in his top 6 players for the Saints.

Stalker…

By the way…I’m not Robinson Crusoe. You’ll find not everyone voted for him. It’s not clear at all that he was BOG. If Pou hits that last goal it’s a no brainer that he is BOG

Sinclair is playing back in defence. He gets plenty of cheap possessions from kicking out when oppo teams kick a behind. Today he got 4 and Nas got 4. Take out his 4 kicks and judge him on 24 possessions and compare what he does with Hunter or Pou or Steele

I generally value our mids. Clark, Pou and Steele had the bulk of our inside 50’s and centre clearances.

I would hardly call Sinclair's possessions cheap! He had 10 contested, the most of any player in the side, plus 5 intercepts. I suggest you have another look at the game and maybe you might see how effective his game was. You have judged him harshly most of the year and undervalued his contribution.

[Scollop]

You have judged him harshly most of the year and undervalued his contribution.

That's not true. I have only judged him harshly in a few games. You forget I'm one of his strongest supporters

https://www.saintsational.net/viewtopic ... r#p2066898

[spert]

5. Sincs
4. NWM
3. Jones
2. Higgins
1. Sharman (played a purely defensive forward role very well- smart player)

[perfectionist]

Funny game, I thought Carlton had at least 4 of the best 5 on the ground and that their effort at the ball was slightly greater than that ours, but in the end, our turnovers proved less costly.
3. Jack Sinclair.

2. Zak Jones.

2. Rowan Marshall

2. Darcy Wilson.

2. Mattaes Phillipou.

1. Hunter Clark.

1. Jack Steele.

1. Mason Wood

1. Jack Higgins

[MCG-Unit]

4 - Marshall
3 - Sinclair
3 - NWM
2 - Wilson
1 - Steele
1 - Clark
1 - Phillipou

[terry smith rules]

5. Sinclair.
4. Wilson.
3. Phillipou.
2. Jones.
1. Higgins.

Ditto

[Josh Battle]

3 Jones
3 Clark
2 Sinclair
2 Steele
2 Pou
1 Wilson
1 Higgins
1 Nas

[older saint]

5. Marshall
4. Sinclair
3. Poo
2. NAS - lot of it but wasn't clean
1.Wilson - Best first season I can recall in a long time.

[Sainter_Dad]

Oh No!!!!!

[Sainter_Dad]

Bump