Changes vs Carlton

[Jacks Back]

in real danger of finishing twelth - worst possible position to finish.

If were ever going to be any good we have to beat the better sides more often and so finishing 12th will give us a bit harder FIXture. I heard on the replay from the Cats game that them and Sydney are the only top 8 teams we've beaten this year (at the time of playing the other teams - I believe).

[Beno88]

in real danger of finishing twelth - worst possible position to finish.

If were ever going to be any good we have to beat the better sides more often and so finishing 12th will give us a bit harder FIXture. I heard on the replay from the Cats game that them and Sydney are the only top 8 teams we've beaten this year (at the time of playing the other teams - I believe).

Not true.

Gold Coast were 8th when we beat them.
Essendon were 8th when we beat them.

[WellardSaint]

In

Pou
Hayes
Campbell
McLennan

Out
Caminiti

Bench is from
Byrnes
Dow
Butler
Garcia
Wilson
Hayes
Campbell
McLennan

I suspect bench will be
Butler
Byrnes
Wilson
Maybe Garcia

Sub to be Hayes as a farewell game?
Or Dow...

[Stian]

As I mentioned on the other Hayes thread - I think that he (or Campbell) must play - otherwise the team would be too short.

[saintbob]

As I mentioned on the other Hayes thread - I think that he (or Campbell) must play - otherwise the team would be too short.

I disagree, the only advantage we have over Carlton is speed on the outside so why would we bring in Campbell or Hayes.
We need to run and spread as much as possible to expose their lack of speed.

[Stian]

As I mentioned on the other Hayes thread - I think that he (or Campbell) must play - otherwise the team would be too short.

I disagree, the only advantage we have over Carlton is speed on the outside so why would we bring in Campbell or Hayes.
We need to run and spread as much as possible to expose their lack of speed.

Yep, fair enough if we can deliver accurately to the small mobile forwards. However, what happens if we have to rely on pack marking?

[Stian]

As I mentioned on the other Hayes thread - I think that he (or Campbell) must play - otherwise the team would be too short.

I disagree, the only advantage we have over Carlton is speed on the outside so why would we bring in Campbell or Hayes.
We need to run and spread as much as possible to expose their lack of speed.

Yep, fair enough if we can deliver accurately to the small mobile forwards. However, what happens if we have to rely on pack marking?

By the way, for mobility, hands below the knees and stuff like that - it would be Hayes rather than Campbell.

[WellardSaint]

As I mentioned on the other Hayes thread - I think that he (or Campbell) must play - otherwise the team would be too short.

I disagree, the only advantage we have over Carlton is speed on the outside so why would we bring in Campbell or Hayes.
We need to run and spread as much as possible to expose their lack of speed.

Yep, fair enough if we can deliver accurately to the small mobile forwards. However, what happens if we have to rely on pack marking?

A lot of our goals last week were chaos balls into F50.
Sharman's goal after Skunk and he crashed 3 Pussies
Higgo's goal about 25-30 out when Owens crashed a pack with Skunk.
Wilson's first goal
Higgo's goal in 2nd qtr from Cooper handpass
Marshall
Skunk
Wood from a one on one

[Stian]

As I mentioned on the other Hayes thread - I think that he (or Campbell) must play - otherwise the team would be too short.

I disagree, the only advantage we have over Carlton is speed on the outside so why would we bring in Campbell or Hayes.
We need to run and spread as much as possible to expose their lack of speed.

Yep, fair enough if we can deliver accurately to the small mobile forwards. However, what happens if we have to rely on pack marking?

A lot of our goals last week were chaos balls into F50.
Sharman's goal after Skunk and he crashed 3 Pussies
Higgo's goal about 25-30 out when Owens crashed a pack with Skunk.
Wilson's first goal
Higgo's goal in 2nd qtr from Cooper handpass
Marshall
Skunk
Wood from a one on one

OK, I get your point - but do you still want a big body to crash the packs? (Although, I can see that Sharman, Skunk and Owens are all playing.)

[Vortex]

tank tank tank

[StPeter]

Curnow is out for Carlton.

Maybe will change who Saints select

[chook23]

Curnow is out for Carlton.

Maybe will change who Saints select

Howard
Willie
Battle

Match ups???

[chook23]

Curnow is out for Carlton.

Maybe will change who Saints select

Howard
Wilkie
Battle

Match ups???

[StPeter]

Curnow is out for Carlton.

Maybe will change who Saints select

Howard
Wilkie
Battle

Match ups???

Maybe Battle goes forward