Votes vs Dees

[The_Dud]

Games like this (and others this year) are perfect examples of why B&Fs aren’t necessarily the best way to rate players

[Otiman]

Games like this (and others this year) are perfect examples of why B&Fs aren’t necessarily the best way to rate players

I can't speak for other clubs, but the Trevor Barker Award rules help here.

[B.M]

Players can still play well in losses

We did not get beaten by 20-30 goals

[The_Dud]

Games like this (and others this year) are perfect examples of why B&Fs aren’t necessarily the best way to rate players

I can't speak for other clubs, but the Trevor Barker Award rules help here.

What is the current system we run? I think last I saw every player gets votes?

[avid]

4 NWM
4 Steele
3 King
2 Sinclair
2 Higgins

[SaintWiki]

Today is my birthday. All the Saints gave me was some junk time goals. So depressing.

5. Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera. Far from perfect , but our best ball user. At age 21, seems to be our most poised, mature player.

4. Jack Steele. Our best midfielder ( yes I know that equates to being the best ice hockey player in Jamaica)

3. Mason Wood. I thought he was our best in first half. Faded.

2. Max King. Should have beaten May in one particular one-on-one , or at least buried his knees in May’s kidneys in attempting to mark) , but did present a bit better and kicked straight .

1. Liam Stocker. Good early .

Liam Henry showed glimpses. Sinclair late, but not enough early. Not much else.

Yes, which brings up the bleeding obvious, why have the players (and the coach) lost the plot and look like they wish they were somewhere else?

[kosifantutti]

Games like this (and others this year) are perfect examples of why B&Fs aren’t necessarily the best way to rate players

Thanks for the contribution.

King
Henry
Wood
NWM
Stocker

[Josh Battle]

5. Steele
4. Sinclair
2. Higgins
2. Nasiah
1. King
1. Webster

Marshall kept trying until the end. Wood, Hill, Henry, Dow, Owens were ok

[terry smith rules]

5 Steele
4 Sinclair
3 Higgins
2 Dow
1 Henry

[Sainter_Dad]

40 Steele
36 Wanganeen-Milera
31 King
23 Wood
22 Sinclair
18 Henry
10 Higgins
9 Stocker
9 Wilson
6 Hill
5 Dow
5 Marshall
5 Wilkie
3 Battle
2 Webster
1 Bonner

Therefore:
5 Steele
4 Wanganeen-Milera
3 King
2 Wood
1 Sinclair

[Scollop]

40 Steele
36 Wanganeen-Milera
31 King
23 Wood
22 Sinclair
18 Henry
10 Higgins
9 Stocker
9 Wilson
6 Hill
5 Dow
5 Marshall
5 Wilkie
3 Battle
2 Webster
1 Bonner

Therefore:
5 Steele
4 Wanganeen-Milera
3 King
2 Wood
1 Sinclair

I only counted 36 for Steele, 31 for NWM, 29 for King, and equal 20 for Mason Wood and Jack Sinclair

After the 2 threads were merged, George27 voted again. I think you might have counted George27's votes twice

Sorry for the extra work

[Sainter_Dad]

40 Steele
36 Wanganeen-Milera
31 King
23 Wood
22 Sinclair
18 Henry
10 Higgins
9 Stocker
9 Wilson
6 Hill
5 Dow
5 Marshall
5 Wilkie
3 Battle
2 Webster
1 Bonner

Therefore:
5 Steele
4 Wanganeen-Milera
3 King
2 Wood
1 Sinclair

I only counted 36 for Steele, 31 for NWM, 29 for King, and equal 20 for Mason Wood and Jack Sinclair

After the 2 threads were merged, George27 voted again. I think you might have counted George27's votes twice

Sorry for the extra work

Hey Scollop - you are technically correct - which of course if the best kind of correct.


36 Steele
31 Wanganeen-Milera
29 King
22 Sinclair
20 Wood
18 Henry
10 Higgins
9 Wilson
8 Stocker
6 Hill
5 Dow
5 Marshall
5 Wilkie
3 Battle
2 Webster
1 Bonner

Therefore:
5 Steele
4 Wanganeen-Milera
3 King
2 Sinclair
1 Wood

[Otiman]

My understanding of the TBA is that votes are given to each player based on their contribution.

The total number of votes given is not fixed, so that for a loss, a lot less votes are awarded than in a win.

[George27]

Sorry I was the cause of confusion. Normally I fire off my votes right on the siren, but this time I struggled to find 5 players so took a little time - then after I posted I realised someone else had started another thread, so I reposted in that thread. I was trying to be helpful but turned out to be unhelpful!

This week I will open the thread straight after the game , so to avoid confusion. Let’s hope there are many worthy candidates for votes !