Mabior Chol

[B.M]

The need to replace Paddy should have us looking at Chol

Rowan to move to the #1 spot

The athletic Chol as back up

Should have a real dip at Quinton Narkle as well!!!

[bangaulegend]

Don't know much about Chol is he gettable ? I like the look of Narkle but what do you think it would to take to land either or both?

[BackFromUSA]

Chol has been on my radar too. Unrestricted free agent. Limited opportunities at the Tigers. Developing nicely and still young at 24 now and 25 at start of 2022. Plays forward, back and relief ruck. Can mark the ball. Not a champion but not a dud.

[George27]

Chol has been on my radar too. Unrestricted free agent. Limited opportunities at the Tigers. Developing nicely and still young at 24 now and 25 at start of 2022. Plays forward, back and relief ruck. Can mark the ball. Not a champion but not a dud.

Agree he would be a good acquisition. In addition to the other assets you have listed, he also is a lovely left foot kick.

[Freebird]

Lets fill up our list with fringe players - why have we not thought of this before?

[Wayne42]

If Richmond don't re-sign Chol then a number of AFL clubs will be making him offers, i don't believe Dimmamond have given Chol enough games to prove himself
as a bona fide AFL player.

[wally]

We have Hunter & McKernan as ruck / forward backup neither show much promise.
Chol shows promise and like our own Marshall may well improve with game time.

[Faulky63]

If you watch his games you will see that Chol does not like body contact.

[Ghost Like]

The need to replace Paddy should have us looking at Chol

Rowan to move to the #1 spot

The athletic Chol as back up

Should have a real dip at Quinton Narkle as well!!!

Good suggestions, certainly begins to fill some holes in our list. Both I imagine with points to prove.

[Impatient Sainter]

He cant get a get at Richmond he is not our answer!

[Scollop]

If we get Chol we are a very, very, very…

VERY good chance to also recruit his little mate Biggy (who had trained at Saints NGA)

Big bonus for us. Two for one. Are they both out of contract?

If Biggy gets the right development he could possibly be St Kilda’s version of Alliir Alliir.

http://saintsational.net/viewtopic.php? ... y#p1834559

[B.M]

I think Chol has the ability to play fwd/ruck

Therefore is a good partner to Rowan

Who is Ruck Fwd

[Wayne42]

He cant get a get at Richmond he is not our answer!

if he did get a get, what would he get ?

[skeptic]

The thing that makes the Ryder/Marshall combo a success is that Paddy is freakishly good at the hitouts and Marshall is freakishly good around the ground.

In the opposite role, both are good without being exceptional.

It works because generally opposition can’t get on top in one portion of the role e.g. in the centre, without us switching it up. Or if they do for example dominate the hitouts, Paddy can cause problems up forward and Marshall can be damaging across the ground

I reckon whoever replaces Paddy needs to be more Natanui style in terms of leap and tap work instead of McEvoy with contested grabs and round ground grunt and endurance

What’s Choi’s tap work like?