Why AFL is so hard to umpire
Moderators: Saintsational Administrators, Saintsational Moderators
- The_Dud
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 13782
- Joined: Sun 27 May 2007 9:53pm
- Location: Bendigo
- Has thanked: 1313 times
- Been thanked: 2052 times
Why AFL is so hard to umpire
Great article from someone who knows what they're talking about pretty much summing up this whole issue. I think all supporters should read it, then some read it again.
https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/mos ... 586uy.html
https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/mos ... 586uy.html
All posters are equal, but some posters are more equal than others.
- skeptic
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 16891
- Joined: Wed 10 Mar 2004 7:10pm
- Has thanked: 3583 times
- Been thanked: 2851 times
Re: Why AFL is so hard to umpire
About 5 or 6 years ago I had some friends come down from overseas and took them to a game. Going through the rule, I was struck by the number of free kicks that were paid that I had absolutely no idea what they were for and they were incredibly inconsistent.
In a marking contest, free kicks are paid for incidental contact and sometimes there is heavy wrestling with nothing.
The biggest issue for me personally is that we appear to have moved away from the mantra of paying only the super obvious frees (like I was taught when i umpired years ago) to selectively paying pissy incidental frees whenever the mood dictates.
One week their hot on holding the ball, the next week it’s deliberate out of bounds.
All in all, I think the umpiring has shifted way too much towards paying free kicks where possible (pbly to speed the game up) and to me, it’s made the game unwatchable
Game is there to be won, 30s to go, Saints down by 3. Kicked longed to a 1v1, King vs whoever… whistle
Holding
Pushing
Over the shoulder
Slapping the arms
Blocking
Tunnelling
Front on contact
Head high contact
That’s 8 different infringements off the top of my head for one contest. Give me a break
How hard is this game that teams are giving away 60 odd free kicks a match?
In a marking contest, free kicks are paid for incidental contact and sometimes there is heavy wrestling with nothing.
The biggest issue for me personally is that we appear to have moved away from the mantra of paying only the super obvious frees (like I was taught when i umpired years ago) to selectively paying pissy incidental frees whenever the mood dictates.
One week their hot on holding the ball, the next week it’s deliberate out of bounds.
All in all, I think the umpiring has shifted way too much towards paying free kicks where possible (pbly to speed the game up) and to me, it’s made the game unwatchable
Game is there to be won, 30s to go, Saints down by 3. Kicked longed to a 1v1, King vs whoever… whistle
Holding
Pushing
Over the shoulder
Slapping the arms
Blocking
Tunnelling
Front on contact
Head high contact
That’s 8 different infringements off the top of my head for one contest. Give me a break
How hard is this game that teams are giving away 60 odd free kicks a match?
- The_Dud
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 13782
- Joined: Sun 27 May 2007 9:53pm
- Location: Bendigo
- Has thanked: 1313 times
- Been thanked: 2052 times
Re: Why AFL is so hard to umpire
I always like when it gets to Finals and for some reason they let the game go a bit more, much better way to go IMO, not sure why they don't do that all year
All posters are equal, but some posters are more equal than others.
-
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 10126
- Joined: Fri 16 Feb 2007 3:24pm
- Location: WARBURTON
- Has thanked: 145 times
- Been thanked: 1299 times
Re: Why AFL is so hard to umpire
Not sure why umpires choose to umpire differently depending on the player and or club.
NO IFS OR BUTS HARVS IS KING OF THE AFL
-
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 12077
- Joined: Thu 04 Jul 2019 8:53pm
- Has thanked: 5 times
- Been thanked: 2605 times
Re: Why AFL is so hard to umpire
Too much interpretation
Seriously, the deliberate out of bounds rule is now ‘insufficient intent’
So the umpire has to know what the player is thinking
Laughable
That rule should be black and white
If disposed over the boundary line by handball or kick or hit out it should just be a free
If it’s touched, fumbled or tackled over the line - throw in
Seriously, the deliberate out of bounds rule is now ‘insufficient intent’
So the umpire has to know what the player is thinking
Laughable
That rule should be black and white
If disposed over the boundary line by handball or kick or hit out it should just be a free
If it’s touched, fumbled or tackled over the line - throw in
- Sainter_Dad
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 6285
- Joined: Thu 05 Jun 2008 1:04pm
- Has thanked: 260 times
- Been thanked: 1097 times
Re: Why AFL is so hard to umpire
I agree that Umpires make mistakes - I made a few myself when doing Junior games - and some were f@rking howlers - but for the Umpires delegates to come out and rubber stamp almost EVERY one as being right is the frustration - admit that there are errors and we can say that they are human - keep telling us that the Umpires got it 100% right and we will assume ......... incompetence, cheating, inconsistencies - just be open. {I have a headache works better than implying you have lost the spark - lol}Wayne Campbell wrote: The last reason consistency in umpiring is unattainable is that umpires make mistakes.
Put simply - and I know that it is open to interpretation - but why is there not two rules:
- Did the action put the opposition in danger (tripping, dangerous tackle)?
- Did the action unfairly restrict the player from having a fair contest at the ball?
If so pay the free
Don't care what they call it - just pay it as an infringement.
If play stops (from tackle or whatever) - ball up (no free) - but do it quickly - no nominations - not piss farting around.
Also - as an aside - I have always called for a 4th umpire in the ARC to be watching - not as a means of correcting all decisions - but as a failsafe if the umpire completely cocked it up - like a ball clearly bouncing before it was marked and the vision can be seen at normal speed, a ball up being the result - It may save some televisions or remotes!
“Youth ages, immaturity is outgrown, ignorance can be educated, and drunkenness sobered, but stupid lasts forever.”
― Aristophanes
If you have a Bee in your Bonnet - I can assist you with that - but it WILL involve some smacking upside the head!
― Aristophanes
If you have a Bee in your Bonnet - I can assist you with that - but it WILL involve some smacking upside the head!
- desertsaint
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 10404
- Joined: Sun 27 Apr 2008 2:02pm
- Location: out there
- Has thanked: 186 times
- Been thanked: 701 times
Re: Why AFL is so hard to umpire
deliberate out of bounds and insufficient intent are both interpretations of a players mindset. a fumble could be deliberate, a kick a mistake. just make any out of bounds an automatic free kick to the other team. if tackled over its the same thing paid against the carrier. if that's likely to create unfair shots at goal make it a rule you cant shoot directly from a boundary free. just simplify the rules and its a much easier game to officiate. get tackled with the ball = free kick. who cares about prior or not - you chose to receive or pick up the ball. drop the ball in a tackle = free kick. and so on.
"The starting point of all achievement is desire. "
-
- Club Player
- Posts: 919
- Joined: Sun 29 Jan 2012 12:37pm
- Has thanked: 3 times
- Been thanked: 94 times
Re: Why AFL is so hard to umpire
I think everyone understands the game is not easy to umpire..
All everyone wants is consistency....why do the bulldogs consistently get the rub of the green and st kilda do not?
All everyone wants is consistency....why do the bulldogs consistently get the rub of the green and st kilda do not?
-
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 23011
- Joined: Wed 10 Mar 2004 3:53pm
- Has thanked: 8909 times
- Been thanked: 3883 times
- Bowey Boy
- Club Player
- Posts: 1145
- Joined: Mon 22 Aug 2005 7:15pm
- Location: Animal Enclosure
- Has thanked: 182 times
- Been thanked: 93 times
Re: Why AFL is so hard to umpire
Funny how the same teams consistently benefit from the inconsistent umpiring.
"I think, 'You kick a footy mate, you kick a footy. It's not like you've got a cure for cancer. You kick a footy, stop thinking you are so special'." - Samantha Black
-
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 23011
- Joined: Wed 10 Mar 2004 3:53pm
- Has thanked: 8909 times
- Been thanked: 3883 times
- The_Dud
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 13782
- Joined: Sun 27 May 2007 9:53pm
- Location: Bendigo
- Has thanked: 1313 times
- Been thanked: 2052 times
Re: Why AFL is so hard to umpire
Since 1965 we're 5th (out of 20) on the 'free kick ladder' with 33773-32918 (for-against), which is a percentage of 102.6
So yes, maybe the umps need to stop looking after us so much.
So yes, maybe the umps need to stop looking after us so much.
All posters are equal, but some posters are more equal than others.
-
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 23011
- Joined: Wed 10 Mar 2004 3:53pm
- Has thanked: 8909 times
- Been thanked: 3883 times
Re: Why AFL is so hard to umpire
How about you give us the stats since the turn of the century. You won't will you as it wont suit your biased pro maggot view . f*** me, some posters.
- The_Dud
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 13782
- Joined: Sun 27 May 2007 9:53pm
- Location: Bendigo
- Has thanked: 1313 times
- Been thanked: 2052 times
Re: Why AFL is so hard to umpire
I've given the largest sample size I could find to give the most accurate results, which clearly disproves your frequent claims, and instead of taking this data on board to educate yourself and update your thinking, you demand the parameters are changed (I imagine this will keep going) until your desired outcome is met.
Can't say I'm surprised, at least you're true to form!
Boomers gonna boom!
Can't say I'm surprised, at least you're true to form!
Boomers gonna boom!
All posters are equal, but some posters are more equal than others.
- Bowey Boy
- Club Player
- Posts: 1145
- Joined: Mon 22 Aug 2005 7:15pm
- Location: Animal Enclosure
- Has thanked: 182 times
- Been thanked: 93 times
Re: Why AFL is so hard to umpire
I would any suggest that any advantage we used to get would have evaporated after we stopped having a home ground.
Oh look, West Coast - what a surprise !!
https://www.sen.com.au/news/2019/12/03/ ... ince-2012/
Oh look, West Coast - what a surprise !!
https://www.sen.com.au/news/2019/12/03/ ... ince-2012/
"I think, 'You kick a footy mate, you kick a footy. It's not like you've got a cure for cancer. You kick a footy, stop thinking you are so special'." - Samantha Black
-
- Club Player
- Posts: 709
- Joined: Thu 06 Dec 2007 3:14pm
- Has thanked: 3 times
- Been thanked: 115 times
Re: Why AFL is so hard to umpire
very technical game with a lot of grey area which makes up the interpretation.
However "Rule of the Week" makes life for umpires, players and supporters impossible.
Although Rule of the Week could change between games and umpires within the same game
However "Rule of the Week" makes life for umpires, players and supporters impossible.
Although Rule of the Week could change between games and umpires within the same game
-
- Club Player
- Posts: 709
- Joined: Thu 06 Dec 2007 3:14pm
- Has thanked: 3 times
- Been thanked: 115 times
Re: Why AFL is so hard to umpire
In that article. If Tippa's tackle is not holding the ball it has to be incorrect disposal.
Either way it should be a free kick. If it is not (which the author claims it isnt a free) there must be an interpretation of "not a free as the ball is dislodged in the tackle". Which occurred some weeks ago with Stkilda when they had an enormous number of tackles for little to no reward.
Either way it should be a free kick. If it is not (which the author claims it isnt a free) there must be an interpretation of "not a free as the ball is dislodged in the tackle". Which occurred some weeks ago with Stkilda when they had an enormous number of tackles for little to no reward.
-
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 5212
- Joined: Mon 07 Aug 2006 9:50pm
- Location: Queensland - Beautiful one day ... you know the rest
- Has thanked: 65 times
- Been thanked: 318 times
Re: Why AFL is so hard to umpire
why dont you ???
you wont will you
it wont suit your biased view
Seeya
*************
*************
-
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 5212
- Joined: Mon 07 Aug 2006 9:50pm
- Location: Queensland - Beautiful one day ... you know the rest
- Has thanked: 65 times
- Been thanked: 318 times
Re: Why AFL is so hard to umpire
how bout when a player deliberately fumbles the ball over the line?
is that "insufficient intent"
Seeya
*************
*************
-
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 10598
- Joined: Tue 14 Jun 2005 7:04pm
- Location: North
- Has thanked: 1011 times
- Been thanked: 1055 times
Re: Why AFL is so hard to umpire
I thought the same thing. It’s a free kick either way. If it’s not holding the ball, it’s what I used to call dropping the ball and might now be called incorrect disposal. Am curious to know why it’s not a free kick. Campbell said in the article, “it’s not a free kick, trust me”. Why not. He takes possession, is tackled and doesn’t dispose of the ball correctly. Why is that not a free?repta wrote: ↑Thu 08 Jul 2021 6:28pm In that article. If Tippa's tackle is not holding the ball it has to be incorrect disposal.
Either way it should be a free kick. If it is not (which the author claims it isnt a free) there must be an interpretation of "not a free as the ball is dislodged in the tackle". Which occurred some weeks ago with Stkilda when they had an enormous number of tackles for little to no reward.
- The_Dud
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 13782
- Joined: Sun 27 May 2007 9:53pm
- Location: Bendigo
- Has thanked: 1313 times
- Been thanked: 2052 times
Re: Why AFL is so hard to umpire
Yeah it would have been nice if he went in to more detail, maybe it’s quite technical? He did admit he played footy for 20 years without knowing the correct rule, which I assume is the same boat many of us supporters are in.st.byron wrote: ↑Thu 08 Jul 2021 7:01pmI thought the same thing. It’s a free kick either way. If it’s not holding the ball, it’s what I used to call dropping the ball and might now be called incorrect disposal. Am curious to know why it’s not a free kick. Campbell said in the article, “it’s not a free kick, trust me”. Why not. He takes possession, is tackled and doesn’t dispose of the ball correctly. Why is that not a free?repta wrote: ↑Thu 08 Jul 2021 6:28pm In that article. If Tippa's tackle is not holding the ball it has to be incorrect disposal.
Either way it should be a free kick. If it is not (which the author claims it isnt a free) there must be an interpretation of "not a free as the ball is dislodged in the tackle". Which occurred some weeks ago with Stkilda when they had an enormous number of tackles for little to no reward.
All posters are equal, but some posters are more equal than others.