Votes v Power

[MCG-Unit]

I don't know B.M., I guess it must have been for his tackling, surely not the quality of his possessions, some quite cheap.

No one said he's in our bottom 6 players. I have said the quicker he is in our bottom 6, the better we will be.

I do believe Marshall beat Lycett, certainly beat him with his work around the ground and shaded in the ruck.

How did Ports mids go against ours? Did Steele, Ross, Crouch, Jones come out on top? No wonder our defence was under siege and our forwards with little to no hope.

I think BM was being sarcastic - he gave Ross top votes

[Ghost Like]

I don't know B.M., I guess it must have been for his tackling, surely not the quality of his possessions, some quite cheap.

No one said he's in our bottom 6 players. I have said the quicker he is in our bottom 6, the better we will be.

I do believe Marshall beat Lycett, certainly beat him with his work around the ground and shaded in the ruck.

How did Ports mids go against ours? Did Steele, Ross, Crouch, Jones come out on top? No wonder our defence was under siege and our forwards with little to no hope.

I think BM was being sarcastic - he gave Ross top votes

No, he was serious. He was quoting "Sainter of the Week" to pat himself on the back & have a crack at those who don't rate Seb. I gave Seb 3 votes I think, I do admire Seb's grit, just not his skills. Seb has set a high bar for himself, I wish he'd reach it more often.

[saynta]

https://www.saints.com.au/news/921726/d ... tands-tall

The fans have voted.

[Sainter_Dad]

76 Marshall
58.5 Ross
48.5 Steele
25 Howard
12 Coffield
8 Sinclair
7 McKenzie
4 Wilkie
2 Crouch
1 Higgins
1 Membrey

Therefore:
5 Marshall
4 Ross
3 Steele
2 Howard
1 Coffield

[Ghost Like]

The supporters have voted

[saynta]

The supporters have voted

Yep, including the anti Ross brigade.

[SinCitySainter]

Ross 5 was our best by the length of the Flemington straight (I should say Morphettville Straight but it just doesn't have the same ring).
Steele 4 As always was whole hearted and just kept working.
Marshall 3 tried hard the whole game and broke even with Lycette.
Howard 2 Did as well as he could given the ease and regularity the ball was coming in.
McKenzie 1 Just always works hard from start to finish.

[The Billings Method]

76 Marshall
58.5 Ross
48.5 Steele
25 Howard
12 Coffield
8 Sinclair
7 McKenzie
4 Wilkie
2 Crouch
1 Higgins
1 Membrey

Therefore:
5 Marshall
4 Ross
3 Steele
2 Howard
1 Coffield

That's a fair cop, guv.

[B.M]

Ross would have to get 50+ to get 5 votes

And Marshall not be playing!!

[Ghost Like]

Ross would have to get 50+ to get 5 votes

And Marshall not be playing!!

That's rubbish.

[saynta]

Ross would have to get 50+ to get 5 votes

And Marshall not be playing!!

That's rubbish.

No it's not. Seb has been under appreciated and denigrated on this forum for years.

[Ghost Like]

Ross would have to get 50+ to get 5 votes

And Marshall not be playing!!

That's rubbish.

No it's not. Seb has been under appreciated and denigrated on this forum for years.

Yet the voting for last match disagrees with that comment.

[B.M]

Pretty hard to ignore him since he was easily the best player

You begrudgingly gave him 2nd didn’t you?

[saynta]

Ross would have to get 50+ to get 5 votes

And Marshall not be playing!!

That's rubbish.

No it's not. Seb has been under appreciated and denigrated on this forum for years.

Yet the voting for last match disagrees with that comment.

Have another look at the votes and those who begrudgingly gave Seb low vote, no votes or a half share of 1 vote FFS.

Stand by what I said..

How Marshall got 18 more votes than Ross is beyond me.

[Ghost Like]

"Easily the best"??? You are taking the p1SS with that.

You said Lycett shaded Marshall so who was it that Ross beat? Following it up with his decision making & laser like passes?

Perhaps another B&F vote but I doubt a Brownlow vote. Both super important in determining a players worth, allegedly.

[B.M]

Yes

Best and Fairests and Brownlow’s go to players who’ve had a great year.

Who’s our Dud B&Fs?

Robert Harvey? Nathan Burke?? Lenny Hayes??? Sam Fisher... Maybe Winmar or Lockett??!!

To win a B&F at an AFL club is a huge achievement, no matter how you try and spin it

To win a Brownlow medal even more so!