Nice one.
![Rolling Eyes :roll:](./images/smilies/icon_rolleyes.gif)
Moderators: Saintsational Administrators, Saintsational Moderators
As I've been saying since October last year, Bytel was always only going to get one or two games this season. He was given a really good amount of freedom in his debut by Geelong and has never really looked AFL standard. Similarly Byrnes is a good couple of years off being capable of playing against men at the elite level.Ghost Like wrote: βThu 17 Sep 2020 7:55pm Certainly lost pace but quality went through the roof.
Kent I think owes someone a very large beer & certainly a game to keep him in a final's side. Someone suggested Hanners to spend time in the forward line with some crucial guest appearances in the middle & allow Bytel / Byrnes a crack. I would have preferred that to Kent.
How would I know what you said in October last year when you only joined this morning? What was your nic in October? Were you still Highettman or had you changed to Secret Kiel by then?Vortex wrote: βFri 18 Sep 2020 10:49amAs I've been saying since October last year, Bytel was always only going to get one or two games this season. He was given a really good amount of freedom in his debut by Geelong and has never really looked AFL standard. Similarly Byrnes is a good couple of years off being capable of playing against men at the elite level.Ghost Like wrote: βThu 17 Sep 2020 7:55pm Certainly lost pace but quality went through the roof.
Kent I think owes someone a very large beer & certainly a game to keep him in a final's side. Someone suggested Hanners to spend time in the forward line with some crucial guest appearances in the middle & allow Bytel / Byrnes a crack. I would have preferred that to Kent.
I suggest you go and find a forum that talks about your club clownVortex wrote: βFri 18 Sep 2020 10:49amAs I've been saying since October last year, Bytel was always only going to get one or two games this season. He was given a really good amount of freedom in his debut by Geelong and has never really looked AFL standard. Similarly Byrnes is a good couple of years off being capable of playing against men at the elite level.Ghost Like wrote: βThu 17 Sep 2020 7:55pm Certainly lost pace but quality went through the roof.
Kent I think owes someone a very large beer & certainly a game to keep him in a final's side. Someone suggested Hanners to spend time in the forward line with some crucial guest appearances in the middle & allow Bytel / Byrnes a crack. I would have preferred that to Kent.
Doesn't matter if you remember, what matters is I've have been saying it since then and that is exactly how it has worked out for both those young lads. It has puzzled and amused me why posters on this site would keep talking up thier credentials on the approach to selection each week. I would have thought some might have got it by round 11or 12ish but here we are in the final round and there is still a rusted on belief by some posters that they are AFL capable.Ghost Like wrote: βFri 18 Sep 2020 10:59amHow would I know what you said in October last year when you only joined this morning? What was your nic in October? Were you still Highettman or had you changed to Secret Kiel by then?Vortex wrote: βFri 18 Sep 2020 10:49amAs I've been saying since October last year, Bytel was always only going to get one or two games this season. He was given a really good amount of freedom in his debut by Geelong and has never really looked AFL standard. Similarly Byrnes is a good couple of years off being capable of playing against men at the elite level.Ghost Like wrote: βThu 17 Sep 2020 7:55pm Certainly lost pace but quality went through the roof.
Kent I think owes someone a very large beer & certainly a game to keep him in a final's side. Someone suggested Hanners to spend time in the forward line with some crucial guest appearances in the middle & allow Bytel / Byrnes a crack. I would have preferred that to Kent.
Vortex is cute, quite fitting. Welcome aboard V!
How on earth can you say that Bytel didn't look AFL standard? UMMM Vortex, are you trying to take the piss?Vortex wrote: βFri 18 Sep 2020 10:49amAs I've been saying since October last year, Bytel was always only going to get one or two games this season. He was given a really good amount of freedom in his debut by Geelong and has never really looked AFL standard. Similarly Byrnes is a good couple of years off being capable of playing against men at the elite level.Ghost Like wrote: βThu 17 Sep 2020 7:55pm Certainly lost pace but quality went through the roof.
Kent I think owes someone a very large beer & certainly a game to keep him in a final's side. Someone suggested Hanners to spend time in the forward line with some crucial guest appearances in the middle & allow Bytel / Byrnes a crack. I would have preferred that to Kent.
Big chance I have contributed more to this club than you are ever likely to. What grade is it you play for again?CURLY wrote: βFri 18 Sep 2020 11:09amI suggest you go and find a forum that talks about your club clownVortex wrote: βFri 18 Sep 2020 10:49amAs I've been saying since October last year, Bytel was always only going to get one or two games this season. He was given a really good amount of freedom in his debut by Geelong and has never really looked AFL standard. Similarly Byrnes is a good couple of years off being capable of playing against men at the elite level.Ghost Like wrote: βThu 17 Sep 2020 7:55pm Certainly lost pace but quality went through the roof.
Kent I think owes someone a very large beer & certainly a game to keep him in a final's side. Someone suggested Hanners to spend time in the forward line with some crucial guest appearances in the middle & allow Bytel / Byrnes a crack. I would have preferred that to Kent.
Rubbish post.Move on, most supporters have.SaintPelican66 wrote: βThu 17 Sep 2020 9:17pmI hope I don't offend here but Geary is only getting selected because he is captain. There are at least 4 players that I would select before him. Unfortunately our selectors have already shown they will not drop him. Lets just hope that Geary doesn't cost us the win. This situation was brought upon us by Richo and his obsession with mediocrity. If Geary is not "retired" by the end of THIS season then I will be asking some very embarrassing questions at the AGM later this year that Basset may find difficult to answer.fugazi wrote: βThu 17 Sep 2020 8:57pm I'd love to hear an independent opinion about Gearys place in the team.
I know we have probably done it to death
But having a captain who is the least skilled player, a player that the opposition zone off so he DOES get the ball at kick ins, is a real concern.
I wish we could graft his attitude and commitment onto Carlisles body.
Are you the poster that everyone was warning me of? How f****** dare you say rubbish post? Who the f*** are you to speak to me like that? How about you give a reason why you don't like my post instead of playing the man? I'm reporting you!!!!!saynta wrote: βFri 18 Sep 2020 11:23amRubbish post.Move on, most supporters have.SaintPelican66 wrote: βThu 17 Sep 2020 9:17pmI hope I don't offend here but Geary is only getting selected because he is captain. There are at least 4 players that I would select before him. Unfortunately our selectors have already shown they will not drop him. Lets just hope that Geary doesn't cost us the win. This situation was brought upon us by Richo and his obsession with mediocrity. If Geary is not "retired" by the end of THIS season then I will be asking some very embarrassing questions at the AGM later this year that Basset may find difficult to answer.fugazi wrote: βThu 17 Sep 2020 8:57pm I'd love to hear an independent opinion about Gearys place in the team.
I know we have probably done it to death
But having a captain who is the least skilled player, a player that the opposition zone off so he DOES get the ball at kick ins, is a real concern.
I wish we could graft his attitude and commitment onto Carlisles body.![]()
Why should posters move on? Just because you want them too? How about you move on and allow people to post their views?saynta wrote: βFri 18 Sep 2020 11:23amRubbish post.Move on, most supporters have.SaintPelican66 wrote: βThu 17 Sep 2020 9:17pmI hope I don't offend here but Geary is only getting selected because he is captain. There are at least 4 players that I would select before him. Unfortunately our selectors have already shown they will not drop him. Lets just hope that Geary doesn't cost us the win. This situation was brought upon us by Richo and his obsession with mediocrity. If Geary is not "retired" by the end of THIS season then I will be asking some very embarrassing questions at the AGM later this year that Basset may find difficult to answer.fugazi wrote: βThu 17 Sep 2020 8:57pm I'd love to hear an independent opinion about Gearys place in the team.
I know we have probably done it to death
But having a captain who is the least skilled player, a player that the opposition zone off so he DOES get the ball at kick ins, is a real concern.
I wish we could graft his attitude and commitment onto Carlisles body.![]()
I am sick and tire of reading crap threads being posted about Geary. You think you know better than the coach? Well I have some f****** news for you. You don't.SaintPelican66 wrote: βFri 18 Sep 2020 11:34amWhy should posters move on? Just because you want them too? How about you move on and allow people to post their views?saynta wrote: βFri 18 Sep 2020 11:23amRubbish post.Move on, most supporters have.SaintPelican66 wrote: βThu 17 Sep 2020 9:17pmI hope I don't offend here but Geary is only getting selected because he is captain. There are at least 4 players that I would select before him. Unfortunately our selectors have already shown they will not drop him. Lets just hope that Geary doesn't cost us the win. This situation was brought upon us by Richo and his obsession with mediocrity. If Geary is not "retired" by the end of THIS season then I will be asking some very embarrassing questions at the AGM later this year that Basset may find difficult to answer.fugazi wrote: βThu 17 Sep 2020 8:57pm I'd love to hear an independent opinion about Gearys place in the team.
I know we have probably done it to death
But having a captain who is the least skilled player, a player that the opposition zone off so he DOES get the ball at kick ins, is a real concern.
I wish we could graft his attitude and commitment onto Carlisles body.![]()
Smarter than you sunshine,
I am sure you are smart enough to work it out.SaintPelican66 wrote: βFri 18 Sep 2020 11:41amHow about you cut the crap and tell us why our posts are rubbish?
Sorry you feel that way Saynta. My post was not meant to be offensive. Richo appointed Geary which means that he set the standard low. How could he make a captain that was not in the top 10 players on the list? This is what I meant by mediocrity. So now our selectors are stuck and have to keep playing him. And my other point of 4 players better than him that are not in the team, I think most people would agree with that. At the end of the day Saynta, if you don't like what I post you can either not read it or put me on your ignore list.saynta wrote: βFri 18 Sep 2020 11:41amI am sick and tire of reading crap threads being posted about Geary. You think you know better than the coach? Well I have some f****** news for you. You don't.SaintPelican66 wrote: βFri 18 Sep 2020 11:34amWhy should posters move on? Just because you want them too? How about you move on and allow people to post their views?saynta wrote: βFri 18 Sep 2020 11:23amRubbish post.Move on, most supporters have.SaintPelican66 wrote: βThu 17 Sep 2020 9:17pmI hope I don't offend here but Geary is only getting selected because he is captain. There are at least 4 players that I would select before him. Unfortunately our selectors have already shown they will not drop him. Lets just hope that Geary doesn't cost us the win. This situation was brought upon us by Richo and his obsession with mediocrity. If Geary is not "retired" by the end of THIS season then I will be asking some very embarrassing questions at the AGM later this year that Basset may find difficult to answer.fugazi wrote: βThu 17 Sep 2020 8:57pm I'd love to hear an independent opinion about Gearys place in the team.
I know we have probably done it to death
But having a captain who is the least skilled player, a player that the opposition zone off so he DOES get the ball at kick ins, is a real concern.
I wish we could graft his attitude and commitment onto Carlisles body.![]()
And for what it is worth your comment about Geary and Richo were offensive. In the extreme.
This is a forum ffs. You are allowed to post your views just as I am. So suck it up sunshine.
I don't believe for one moment that this is your first rodeo either.![]()
![]()
![]()
SaintPelican66 wrote: βFri 18 Sep 2020 11:47amSorry you feel that way Saynta. My post was not meant to be offensive. Richo appointed Geary which means that he set the standard low. How could he make a captain that was not in the top 10 players on the list? This is what I meant by mediocrity. So now our selectors are stuck and have to keep playing him. And my other point of 4 players better than him that are not in the team, I think most people would agree with that. At the end of the day Saynta, if you don't like what I post you can either not read it or put me on your ignore list.saynta wrote: βFri 18 Sep 2020 11:41amI am sick and tire of reading crap threads being posted about Geary. You think you know better than the coach? Well I have some f****** news for you. You don't.SaintPelican66 wrote: βFri 18 Sep 2020 11:34amWhy should posters move on? Just because you want them too? How about you move on and allow people to post their views?saynta wrote: βFri 18 Sep 2020 11:23amRubbish post.Move on, most supporters have.SaintPelican66 wrote: βThu 17 Sep 2020 9:17pmI hope I don't offend here but Geary is only getting selected because he is captain. There are at least 4 players that I would select before him. Unfortunately our selectors have already shown they will not drop him. Lets just hope that Geary doesn't cost us the win. This situation was brought upon us by Richo and his obsession with mediocrity. If Geary is not "retired" by the end of THIS season then I will be asking some very embarrassing questions at the AGM later this year that Basset may find difficult to answer.fugazi wrote: βThu 17 Sep 2020 8:57pm I'd love to hear an independent opinion about Gearys place in the team.
I know we have probably done it to death
But having a captain who is the least skilled player, a player that the opposition zone off so he DOES get the ball at kick ins, is a real concern.
I wish we could graft his attitude and commitment onto Carlisles body.![]()
And for what it is worth your comment about Geary and Richo were offensive. In the extreme.
This is a forum ffs. You are allowed to post your views just as I am. So suck it up sunshine.
I don't believe for one moment that this is your first rodeo either.![]()
![]()
![]()
Move along toots go play with your toys.Vortex wrote: βFri 18 Sep 2020 11:18amBig chance I have contributed more to this club than you are ever likely to. What grade is it you play for again?CURLY wrote: βFri 18 Sep 2020 11:09amI suggest you go and find a forum that talks about your club clownVortex wrote: βFri 18 Sep 2020 10:49amAs I've been saying since October last year, Bytel was always only going to get one or two games this season. He was given a really good amount of freedom in his debut by Geelong and has never really looked AFL standard. Similarly Byrnes is a good couple of years off being capable of playing against men at the elite level.Ghost Like wrote: βThu 17 Sep 2020 7:55pm Certainly lost pace but quality went through the roof.
Kent I think owes someone a very large beer & certainly a game to keep him in a final's side. Someone suggested Hanners to spend time in the forward line with some crucial guest appearances in the middle & allow Bytel / Byrnes a crack. I would have preferred that to Kent.
StrangeCURLY wrote: βFri 18 Sep 2020 12:10pmMove along toots go play with your toys.Vortex wrote: βFri 18 Sep 2020 11:18amBig chance I have contributed more to this club than you are ever likely to. What grade is it you play for again?CURLY wrote: βFri 18 Sep 2020 11:09amI suggest you go and find a forum that talks about your club clownVortex wrote: βFri 18 Sep 2020 10:49amAs I've been saying since October last year, Bytel was always only going to get one or two games this season. He was given a really good amount of freedom in his debut by Geelong and has never really looked AFL standard. Similarly Byrnes is a good couple of years off being capable of playing against men at the elite level.Ghost Like wrote: βThu 17 Sep 2020 7:55pm Certainly lost pace but quality went through the roof.
Kent I think owes someone a very large beer & certainly a game to keep him in a final's side. Someone suggested Hanners to spend time in the forward line with some crucial guest appearances in the middle & allow Bytel / Byrnes a crack. I would have preferred that to Kent.