Saintsational Fan Forum - A passionate community of St Kilda Football Club fans discussing news, history, players, trade rumours, results, AFL stats and more.
Good luck to these blokes, but the fact Goddard and Freeman might only get a go at the two bottom clubs probably says alot as to why we delisted them.
And then what of Minchington and Hickey?
I don't disagree with some of what you said, but we've let players go in the past and it's come back to bite us. And it is usually because we didn't develop the players properly. Tom Lynch and jamie Cripps anyone?
The_Dud wrote: ↑Mon 12 Nov 2018 11:30pm
Good luck to him, another player Richo (and I suppose the rest of the geniuses who ended up getting the sack) absolutely butchered.
wow when did it come out that Ritcho took a razor blade to his Achilles?
I’d take Hugh in the lineup over Brown any day.
Just another example of a pattern of Richo playing ordinary players with no upside over young players with unknown potential (who especially should have been a priority with our season effectively being over after round 2)
If I had to choose between having Brown-Longer-Geary or Goddard-Freeman-Minchington on our list for next year,I know which way I’d go every time...
thank god you don't work for the club!! Goddard moves likes a glacier, cannot jump at all and has the turning circle of the Queen Mary, he was struggling at Sandy. Freeman went from a super quick outside mid to a muddling paced inside mid and couldn't kick further than 40 metres because of his dodgy hammies. Minchington does have great skills, unfortunately he doesn't find the pill often enough to utilise them
I saw goddard play at Sandy on tv once this year,. and once was enough. he looked like he couldn't be bother chasing the footy
Good luck to these blokes, but the fact Goddard and Freeman might only get a go at the two bottom clubs probably says alot as to why we delisted them.
Couldn't agree more Ted we obviously don't have a spot for them on our list so if they can resurrect their careers somewhere else then so be it. I personally wish them all the best even if it means we screwed up by moving them on
The_Dud wrote: ↑Mon 12 Nov 2018 11:30pm
Good luck to him, another player Richo (and I suppose the rest of the geniuses who ended up getting the sack) absolutely butchered.
wow when did it come out that Ritcho took a razor blade to his Achilles?
I’d take Hugh in the lineup over Brown any day.
Just another example of a pattern of Richo playing ordinary players with no upside over young players with unknown potential (who especially should have been a priority with our season effectively being over after round 2)
If I had to choose between having Brown-Longer-Geary or Goddard-Freeman-Minchington on our list for next year,I know which way I’d go every time...
That's why your an arm-chair expert, no clue what-so-ever!!!!!
'Cause StoneCold Said So'!!!!! We will be great again once Billy is back playing!!!!!
saynta wrote: ↑Thu 15 Nov 2018 12:47pm
Delisting Goddard and Freeman were two terrible mistakes.
it is slightly weird that when a player is on our list we have to support them unconditionally without criticism or candour
but once they get dropped ...
saynta wrote: ↑Thu 15 Nov 2018 12:47pm
Delisting Goddard and Freeman were two terrible mistakes.
it is slightly weird that when a player is on our list we have to support them unconditionally without criticism or candour
but once they get dropped ...
Do you mean once they leave the club everyone s***s on them and says they are no good.......yeah..funny that...and weird.