Minchington signed by Hawks

[Jacks Back]

At the end of the day, Kent has far, far, far more upside and will help take us somewhere where as Minchington never would have.

They shouldn't be compared anyway as Kent is a much better footballer and had a more fruitful career. Not sure why it started.

Minchington is a Datsun where as Kent is an Audi Quattro from the 1980's...if you want to start comparing.

[dragit]

All the 'best 22' players in top 4 sides spend more time playing VFL than AFL, then get traded for a pick in the 60's just like Kent...

Teddy's myth checks out once again, game over Joff you douche.

[Joffa Burns]

Joffa B wrong again. Stop making stuff up mate.

Although to be fair to Joffa B, he did post below in an earlier post:

"My story is that Kent was going to delisted, I’m making it up but it’s as credible as your input on Kent"

Much ado about nothing really. Hope both Minch & Kent go well.

Nice pick up takeaway, yes I did write that I made up the Kent will be delisted story, to prove the point that if you fabricate stories and write them as gospel Saintsational posters will call out the bulls*** like Saynta, Ted and Kosi did.

Fact is Kent may or may not have been delisted, I have no idea, none of us do but after 6 seasons with more VFL than AFL appearances and little impact in 2018, issues getting his body right & Melbourne on the improve he may have been feeling nervous.

Also fact is Teddysainters repeated bulls*** that Kent would have played finals this year if fit, is in Melbournes best 22, would have played all 17 & 18 season if fit, etc etc. Teddy like my delisting story is just making it up, but by god he’s entertaining

If Kent was in their best 22 and really wanted to retain him, Melbourne would have either matched the offer or requested a trade that was befitting a best 22 required player reaching his prime not a throw away in the 60’s.

Good luck to Kent, we all hope he smashes it for the saints, but sorry Teddysainter he ain’t Keith Grieg just because he signed with us.

But I’m still your biggest fan

[kosifantutti]

Joffa B wrong again. Stop making stuff up mate.

Although to be fair to Joffa B, he did post below in an earlier post:

"My story is that Kent was going to delisted, I’m making it up but it’s as credible as your input on Kent"

Much ado about nothing really. Hope both Minch & Kent go well.

Nice pick up takeaway, yes I did write that I made up the Kent will be delisted story, to prove the point that if you fabricate stories and write them as gospel Saintsational posters will call out the bulls*** like Saynta, Ted and Kosi did.

Fact is Kent may or may not have been delisted, I have no idea, none of us do but after 6 seasons with more VFL than AFL appearances and little impact in 2018, issues getting his body right & Melbourne on the improve he may have been feeling nervous.

Also fact is Teddysainters repeated bulls*** that Kent would have played finals this year if fit, is in Melbournes best 22, would have played all 17 & 18 season if fit, etc etc. Teddy like my delisting story is just making it up, but by god he’s entertaining

If Kent was in their best 22 and really wanted to retain him, Melbourne would have either matched the offer or requested a trade that was befitting a best 22 required player reaching his prime not a throw away in the 60’s.

Good luck to Kent, we all hope he smashes it for the saints, but sorry Teddysainter he ain’t Keith Grieg just because he signed with us.

But I’m still your biggest fan

So you’re just trolling.

Could we have a colour coding system for outright lies. e.g.

Billy Longer is a gun

You can believe everything you read on Saintsational

Kent would have played finals if fit.

[saynta]

Joffa B wrong again. Stop making stuff up mate.

Although to be fair to Joffa B, he did post below in an earlier post:

"My story is that Kent was going to delisted, I’m making it up but it’s as credible as your input on Kent"

Much ado about nothing really. Hope both Minch & Kent go well.

Nice pick up takeaway, yes I did write that I made up the Kent will be delisted story, to prove the point that if you fabricate stories and write them as gospel Saintsational posters will call out the bulls*** like Saynta, Ted and Kosi did.

Fact is Kent may or may not have been delisted, I have no idea, none of us do but after 6 seasons with more VFL than AFL appearances and little impact in 2018, issues getting his body right & Melbourne on the improve he may have been feeling nervous.

Also fact is Teddysainters repeated bulls*** that Kent would have played finals this year if fit, is in Melbournes best 22, would have played all 17 & 18 season if fit, etc etc. Teddy like my delisting story is just making it up, but by god he’s entertaining

If Kent was in their best 22 and really wanted to retain him, Melbourne would have either matched the offer or requested a trade that was befitting a best 22 required player reaching his prime not a throw away in the 60’s.

Good luck to Kent, we all hope he smashes it for the saints, but sorry Teddysainter he ain’t Keith Grieg just because he signed with us.

But I’m still your biggest fan

What utter crap. Get caught out in a lie so make up a bulls*** story.

[Joffa Burns]

Joffa B wrong again. Stop making stuff up mate.

Although to be fair to Joffa B, he did post below in an earlier post:

"My story is that Kent was going to delisted, I’m making it up but it’s as credible as your input on Kent"

Much ado about nothing really. Hope both Minch & Kent go well.

Nice pick up takeaway, yes I did write that I made up the Kent will be delisted story, to prove the point that if you fabricate stories and write them as gospel Saintsational posters will call out the bulls*** like Saynta, Ted and Kosi did.

Fact is Kent may or may not have been delisted, I have no idea, none of us do but after 6 seasons with more VFL than AFL appearances and little impact in 2018, issues getting his body right & Melbourne on the improve he may have been feeling nervous.

Also fact is Teddysainters repeated bulls*** that Kent would have played finals this year if fit, is in Melbournes best 22, would have played all 17 & 18 season if fit, etc etc. Teddy like my delisting story is just making it up, but by god he’s entertaining

If Kent was in their best 22 and really wanted to retain him, Melbourne would have either matched the offer or requested a trade that was befitting a best 22 required player reaching his prime not a throw away in the 60’s.

Good luck to Kent, we all hope he smashes it for the saints, but sorry Teddysainter he ain’t Keith Grieg just because he signed with us.

But I’m still your biggest fan

What utter crap. Get caught out in a lie so make up a bulls*** story.

Learn to read you old <edited by mods> and you’ll see my original post quoted by takeaway.

You’ve always been a <edited by mods> illiterate <edited by mods> and that will never change.

Nice work gramps

<warning for abuse>

[Joffa Burns]

Joffa B wrong again. Stop making stuff up mate.

Although to be fair to Joffa B, he did post below in an earlier post:

"My story is that Kent was going to delisted, I’m making it up but it’s as credible as your input on Kent"

Much ado about nothing really. Hope both Minch & Kent go well.

Nice pick up takeaway, yes I did write that I made up the Kent will be delisted story, to prove the point that if you fabricate stories and write them as gospel Saintsational posters will call out the bulls*** like Saynta, Ted and Kosi did.

Fact is Kent may or may not have been delisted, I have no idea, none of us do but after 6 seasons with more VFL than AFL appearances and little impact in 2018, issues getting his body right & Melbourne on the improve he may have been feeling nervous.

Also fact is Teddysainters repeated bulls*** that Kent would have played finals this year if fit, is in Melbournes best 22, would have played all 17 & 18 season if fit, etc etc. Teddy like my delisting story is just making it up, but by god he’s entertaining

If Kent was in their best 22 and really wanted to retain him, Melbourne would have either matched the offer or requested a trade that was befitting a best 22 required player reaching his prime not a throw away in the 60’s.

Good luck to Kent, we all hope he smashes it for the saints, but sorry Teddysainter he ain’t Keith Grieg just because he signed with us.

But I’m still your biggest fan

So you’re just trolling.

Could we have a colour coding system for outright lies. e.g.

Billy Longer is a gun

You can believe everything you read on Saintsational

Kent would have played finals if fit.

Difference between my post and yours kosi is I clearly wrote that I had made up Kent would be delisted and that I would run with that and have continued to do so.

You have just made up or rehashed Teds story that Kent WOULD have played finals if fit.

You have no proof of that or you or Ted would have posted it.

I am sticking with my fabricated story that he would have been delisted as long as you go with your made up story story he would have played finals.

We gave 3 years to a player who was going to be delisted.

PS. You forgot to highlight your last sentence in red

[kosifantutti]

As good as your posts are JB, I don’t read every one of them. But even if you say in an earlier post that you’re making something up, subsequent posts just look like trolling.

As for Kent playing finals if not injured, there’s no way to be sure. But he was picked for the last two games, and I would say it’s LIKELY he would have played finals. In factI heard Petracca was saved from being dropped by Kent’s injury.

[Joffa Burns]

As good as your posts are JB, I don’t read every one of them. But even if you say in an earlier post that you’re making something up, subsequent posts just look like trolling.

As for Kent playing finals if not injured, there’s no way to be sure. But he was picked for the last two games, and I would say it’s LIKELY he would have played finals. In factI heard Petracca was saved from being dropped by Kent’s injury.

I'm deeply hurt that you don't read all my posts kosi and have you ever noticed how much Tom Elliott resembles the painting of Mozart you use as an avatar?

Now onto the Kent topic, as I feel the need to bore a few more people on this topic.

What you are intimating is it is OK to make up Kent stories from assumptions as long as they are positive.
example: Kent played round 21 & 22 so would have played finals if fit and was in Melbournes best 22.

But it is trolling if you fabricate a negative story on assumptions.
example: Kent has played more VFL than AFL, has played 60 AFL games in 6 or 7 seasons, has struggled to get his body right, his club didn't match saints offer, they let him go for a low throw away pick - so he would have been delisted if we didn't trade for him.

[kosifantutti]

As good as your posts are JB, I don’t read every one of them. But even if you say in an earlier post that you’re making something up, subsequent posts just look like trolling.

As for Kent playing finals if not injured, there’s no way to be sure. But he was picked for the last two games, and I would say it’s LIKELY he would have played finals. In factI heard Petracca was saved from being dropped by Kent’s injury.

I'm deeply hurt that you don't read all my posts kosi and have you ever noticed how much Tom Elliott resembles the painting of Mozart you use as an avatar?

Now onto the Kent topic, as I feel the need to bore a few more people on this topic.

What you are intimating is it is OK to make up Kent stories from assumptions as long as they are positive.
example: Kent played round 21 & 22 so would have played finals if fit and was in Melbournes best 22.

But it is trolling if you fabricate a negative story on assumptions.
example: Kent has played more VFL than AFL, has played 60 AFL games in 6 or 7 seasons, has struggled to get his body right, his club didn't match saints offer, they let him go for a low throw away pick - so he would have been delisted if we didn't trade for him.

Thanks for the heads up on Tom Elliott. I’ll check it out.

As for the two Kent stories, one is a made up story that can easily be proven false with a quick search.

The other is an assumption based on facts. We’ll never know if it was right or wrong but I’d say there’s not many players who play in two wins at the end of the season and get dropped for the finals. Maybe you could provide the stats on that.

[tedtheodorelogan2018]

Kent was finals bound in a top 4 side before getting injured in Rd 23.

Minch didn't even play a game in a bottom 4 side.

One has played 3 x as many games and kicked 3 x as many goals.

Pretty sure I know who I would prefer. Case closed. Kent is one to keep an eye on.

[dragit]

Maybe you could provide the stats on that.

I can give you the stats on how many 24 year old, 'best 22' players from top 4 sides get traded for picks over 60.

None.

[dragit]

Kent's first 28 games yielded 3 wins, that gives you a reasonable gauge of the kind of side he was getting regular games in.

He should fit in well to a side coming off a 4 win season.

[kosifantutti]

Maybe you could provide the stats on that.

I can give you the stats on how many 24 year old, 'best 22' players from top 4 sides get traded for picks over 60.

None.

Agreed. Bargain!

[Joffa Burns]

Kent was finals bound in a top 4 side before getting injured in Rd 23.

Minch didn't even play a game in a bottom 4 side.

One has played 3 x as many games and kicked 3 x as many goals.

Pretty sure I know who I would prefer. Case closed. Kent is one to keep an eye on.

I think Kosi and I agreed to glow the bulls***.

For the record I have no issue recruiting Kent and he may or may not be better than Minchington, though I don't ever recall him playing.

The comment he was going to play finals is absolutely fabricated, perhaps give Baily Fritsch a call and get his opinion.

[saynta]

He was offered a two year contract by the Melbourne Football club though.

[Joffa Burns]

He was offered a two year contract by the Melbourne Football club though

In 2016!

[tedtheodorelogan2018]

Joffa forgets he brought up Kent on a Minchington thread. It was purely done to cause mischief and to troll.

[kosifantutti]

Is this a thread about Minchington?

Coincidentally I saw him in a cafe yesterday morning. He looked healthy and happy. I don’t think he was reading Saintsational.

[Joffa Burns]

Joffa forgets he brought up Kent on a Minchington thread. It was purely done to cause mischief and to troll.

- Billings to Essendon #9 – done
- More trades to follow Hannebery & Kent
- Hannebery for future 2nd round pick
- Kent was in Melbournes best 22 and was set top play finals
- Saints to trade for Amon
- Shiel says no to Essendon
- Bugg can play
- Choco Williams to take role at saints
- Saints do not have a bottom 4 list
- In the box seat for McGovern
- 75% of clubs or more would have taken paddy #1
- Hawthorn Shiels preferred destination
- We should swoop on Scrimshaw

[stonecold]

Oh Joffa, really?????

And 'liked' by 3 of the biggest trolls on here!!!!!

Some supporters should just get off, please don't buy membership's, some of you are really not true 'supporters'!!!!!

Get on board or f*** off, your not providing any value!!!!!

[Joffa Burns]

Oh Joffa, really?????

And 'liked' by 3 of the biggest trolls on here!!!!!

Some supporters should just get off, please don't buy membership's, some of you are really not true 'supporters'!!!!!

Get on board or f*** off, your not providing any value!!!!!

I guess I have a date in the car park at Marvel Stadium

[saynta]

I thought altering a posters posts was against the rules.

[stonecold]

Oh Joffa, really?????

And 'liked' by 3 of the biggest trolls on here!!!!!

Some supporters should just get off, please don't buy membership's, some of you are really not true 'supporters'!!!!!

Get on board or f*** off, your not providing any value!!!!!

I guess I have a date in the car park at Marvel Stadium

You'd have to ask the 'other 3', maybe they would interested, sorry Joffa, your not my type!!!!!

[tedtheodorelogan2018]

Sad thing is, Joffa probably keeps a spreadsheet on my posts, but most importantly...he totally ignores the full story on what I post, clarifying future posts, facts and only uses snippets. Childish stuff really. The fact some equally dumb people like and think using 4 or 5 words to inaccurately explain the full story of what I have posted is telling.