If StKilda drafted Degoey

[CURLY]

Would have been forced out at StKilda media would have made sure of it.

[The_Dud]

American spud has zero touches.

Almost BOG in a prelim and now 2 goals in the GF.

Such a spud...

[Sainter_Dad]

If St Kilda drafted Superman, Captain America, Wonder Woman, if, if, if..............

We would play them all off the half back line, or as small forwards!!!!

[Barneysaint]

Irrelevant. We didn't. He wouldn't be the player he is now as he wouldn't have the support if with us. Collingwoods list is better than hours and by a long way. Their forward set up is better than ours. And their midfield is one of the best in the league with pendelbury, Adams, treloar and the best ruckman in the league. He gets excellent delivery and support. He wouldn't get that with us. De goey plays for Buckley. Our players don't play for richo. That's the difference. Richo should be organising a deal with St kilda to end his coaching reign and go back to Eastern football. He doesn't have a game plan and De goey wouldn't benefit front that.

[BenLong#21]

Irrelevant. We didn't. He wouldn't be the player he is now as he wouldn't have the support if with us. Collingwoods list is better than hours and by a long way. Their forward set up is better than ours. And their midfield is one of the best in the league with pendelbury, Adams, treloar and the best ruckman in the league. He gets excellent delivery and support. He wouldn't get that with us. De goey plays for Buckley. Our players don't play for richo. That's the difference. Richo should be organising a deal with St kilda to end his coaching reign and go back to Eastern football. He doesn't have a game plan and De goey wouldn't benefit front that.

The East Burwood Rams in the EFL 4th Division would welcome the Cho back with open arms. The prodigal sun.
I am sure he could take them back up as least as high as Div 2 or 3.

[rodgerfox]

Every club could have drafted a number of different kids across every draft since its very inception.

If only the club didn't draft Steve Sims back in 86.

St Kilda are overall well below average over the journey
We have enough data points.
1 flag in 120 years.
33% win rate in the last 5 seasons under the current regime.

I never understand why people bother to reference anything that happened before 1987.

It's like me telling everyone how good I was as a junior footballer. Who cares?

Different comp. Different rules. Different opposition.


The Saints, and all other clubs compete in the AFL now. What relevance does what some suburban amateur club did in a state comp 100 years ago have?

[CURLY]

All missing the point DeGoey gets drafted by StKilda has the off field issues he has had he’d have been sacked. The outside pressure from media and the AFL would have made it impossible for us to keep him.

[BenLong#21]

All missing the point DeGoey gets drafted by StKilda has the off field issues he has had he’d have been sacked. The outside pressure from media and the AFL would have made it impossible for us to keep him.

Another piece of curly " what if" hypothetical speculation not connected to reality.

What if . What if. If if if.
If the umps did that. If the afl didnt do that. If if if.

[CURLY]

All missing the point DeGoey gets drafted by StKilda has the off field issues he has had he’d have been sacked. The outside pressure from media and the AFL would have made it impossible for us to keep him.

Another piece of curly " what if" hypothetical speculation not connected to reality.

What if . What if. If if if.
If the umps did that. If the afl didnt do that. If if if.

Well answered bellend Con.