Votes v Cats

[George27]

I'll kick it off.

5. Jack Steven
4. Seb Ross
3. Dylan Roberton
2. Jack Steele
1. Tossing up between Nathan Brown and Darren Minchington. If Meatball kicked that 4th one, I would have him in, but will go for Brown .

[Bluthy]

5 Jack Steven - our most devastating player on the field with his burst speed. Cats worked hard to shut him down in the second half which killed some of our run.
4 Seb Ross - tried his guts out. Gone up a notch but still not quite at that really devastating a-grade level with the footy yet although did a few nice passes.
3 Dyalan Robbo - STacks of the footy again. Was huge in the first half with his intercepting play. You do get the good and bad with him though. Wish he was a bit better with the ball
2 Blake Acres - I thought he was really dangerous out on the field with his height back and forward and pretty composed with the footy which is a step up for him. Made a few bad errors but not Robinson Crusoe there.
1 Minch - 3 goals set us alight. Pretty good in general play too. Needs to back this up now.

Apologies: Nathan Brown - brilliant job on keeping Hawkins quiet

[skeptic]

I'll kick it off.

5. Jack Steven
4. Seb Ross
3. Dylan Roberton
2. Jack Steele
1. Tossing up between Nathan Brown and Darren Minchington. If Meatball kicked that 4th one, I would have him in, but will go for Brown .

Agreed. I give the 1 vote to Brown as Minch faded late like so many others

[avid]

5 Steven
4 Ross
3 Roberton
2 Acres
1 Minchinton

[Sainternist]

5 Seb Ross
4 Jackie Steven
3 Roberton
2 Minchington
1 Nate Brown

[White Winmar]

5 Seb Ross
4 Jackie Steven
3 Roberton
2 Minchington
1 Nate Brown

I concur.

[saintbob]

5 Ross
4 Steven
3 Minchington
2 Steele
1 Acres

[BigMart]

Ross
Steven
Roberton
Brown
Minch

[bergsone]

Steven
Ross
Brown
Roberton
Montagna

[Sainternist]

Montagna

Fair call. If it weren't for Minchington's very solid return, I could have gone for Joey.

[elizabethr]

Ludicrous votes

[elizabethr]

5 Gilbert
4 Steven
3 Newnes
2 Ross
1 Dunstan

[desertsaint]

well they all went missing in the last quarter, so my votes for the first three:
roberton
ross
brown
steven
dunstan

[BigMart]

If Luke Dunstan can get votes for getting 4 kicks as a midfielder, Nathan Brown should get 10 votes

[elizabethr]

If Luke Dunstan can get votes for getting 4 kicks as a midfielder, Nathan Brown should get 10 votes

You're telling the story champion

[BigMart]

No

But champion data might?

Seriously, even Luke would be embarrassed by that, he'd be disappointed by his own game, .... he needs to build an AFL tank

[elizabethr]

No

But champion data might?

Seriously, even Luke would be embarrassed by that, he'd be disappointed by his own game, .... he needs to build an AFL tank

Brown...what # number was he ??

[MCG-Unit]

No

But champion data might?

Seriously, even Luke would be embarrassed by that, he'd be disappointed by his own game, .... he needs to build an AFL tank

Brown...what # number was he ??

Brown is no 22

Votes tomorrow when I've had a better look at the stats - but Ross & Roberton will be the top 2

[elizabethr]

Oh Farren Ray
Didn't notice him
We saw #2 get back-slammed in last quarter though..

[MCG-Unit]

Yes Ray's old number

You probably didn't notice Brown, but he kept Hawkins to 0 goals until the last qtr, when he got 2 easy ones, including a 'joe the goose'

#2 is Carlisle

[WellardSaint]

Oh Farren Ray
Didn't notice him
We saw #2 get back-slammed in last quarter though..

You're still hurting because your nephew Dave (#20)
is injured?

[elizabethr]

DAve will be back
I'm not worried about HIS future

[WellardSaint]

DAve will be back
I'm not worried about HIS future

He's still young and he's a proven tough nut and dedicated.
I like to support most of the guys and not pick one or two

[elizabethr]

Pick the ones that CAN actually make a difference

[SemperFidelis]

5. Seb
4. Jack S. They had to put a giant on him.
3. Robbo
2. Minch. You can't kick 3 and not get something.
1. Brown

Defenders good again. Starting to really gel.