Massive outs for carlton this week

[mordi]

CHRIS Judd will miss Carlton's Anzac Day clash with St Kilda in New Zealand on Saturday.

Judd did not board the plane with teammates at Melbourne Airport on Thursday morning and is battling hamstring tightness

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2015-04-23/s ... -day-clash

[Devilhead]

Hmmmm - someone in another thread said this thread looks silly but with the news of Judd being ruled out it is now looking pretty spot on - throw in Jameison being a likely out then these OUTS for Carlton are very significant - thinks the odds are now tipped in our favour

[plugger66]

Hmmmm - someone in another thread said this thread looks silly but with the news of Judd being ruled out it is now looking pretty spot on - throw in Jameison being a likely out then these OUTS for Carlton are very significant - thinks the odds are now tipped in our favour

Wow. What a post.

[Devilhead]

Hmmmm - someone in another thread said this thread looks silly but with the news of Judd being ruled out it is now looking pretty spot on - throw in Jameison being a likely out then these OUTS for Carlton are very significant - thinks the odds are now tipped in our favour

Wow. What a post.

Cheers

Good to see that you have come around and that you agree that Yarran and Judd are MASSIVE for the Blues!!

[St DAC]

So who kicks our goals? Looks to me like we have about 50 games of forward experience tops in our forward line ... I still think Carlton should start as firm favourites.

[Bunk_Moreland]

So who kicks our goals?

Bruce, McCartin, Membrey, and Sinclair, 4 each should do.

Who defends for Carlton?

[Saint wagga]

So who kicks our goals? Looks to me like we have about 50 games of forward experience tops in our forward line ... I still think Carlton should start as firm favourites.

Bruce to kick a bag, Membrey a couple, McCartin a handy few and an even spread of goalkicking mids

I'm an optimist

[St DAC]

Bruce, McCartin, Membrey, and Sinclair, 4 each should do.

Who defends for Carlton?

I hope you're right

The usual suspects excepting Jamison (possibly out).

It's the midfield as usual where this will be won, and I think at this stage they bat a bit deeper there than we do.

[plugger66]

Bruce, McCartin, Membrey, and Sinclair, 4 each should do.

Who defends for Carlton?

I hope you're right

The usual suspects excepting Jamison (possibly out).

It's the midfield as usual where this will be won, and I think at this stage they bat a bit deeper there than we do.

Yep this week is all about the mids. Both forward lines are poor. If Jack and Armo are better than Gibbs and Murphy we have a real chance. As you say they have a fraction more depth but both sides look very ordinary. The good thing for us though is we should have better younger players in the long run.

[Con Gorozidis]

Most disappointing out for me is Weller. Murphy is a little front runner and just the kind of player Weller would destroy.
Murphy likely to have a good game now unopposed.

[SMS]

We MUST win this for our KIWI supporters. With Judd and others out we SHOULD win too.

[Sobraz]

Most disappointing out for me is Weller. Murphy is a little front runner and just the kind of player Weller would destroy.
Murphy likely to have a good game now unopposed.

Carlton in the white shorts would've been very embarrassing for Gibbs had Weller been assigned to him. Real shame he is out, having a much better year than I expected.

[The Fireman]

too many players out..will most likely be an ordinary spectacle.

[WinnersOnly]

Jamieson out for Carlton also!

[Devilhead]

MASSIVE!!

What a silly thread!

[Devilhead]

Jamieson out for Carlton also!

Presumably the inexperienced Jaksch will come in?

[Teflon]

we simply can not afford to be out-tanked this week....

[bergholt]

Carlton with Judd since 2008: 67-2-71 = 47.9% wins
Carlton without Judd since 08: 12-0-11 = 52.2% wins

Maybe it would have been better if he'd played? Then again:

St Kilda with Riewoldt since 2001: 141-5-137 = 49.8% wins
St Kilda without Riewoldt since 01: 23-0-22 = 51.1% wins

Statistics can prove anything!

[dragit]

Jamieson out for Carlton also!

Doesn't sound like it, he trained well apparently.

[Jacks Back]

Carlton with Judd since 2008: 67-2-71 = 47.9% wins
Carlton without Judd since 08: 12-0-11 = 52.2% wins

Maybe it would have been better if he'd played? Then again:

St Kilda with Riewoldt since 2001: 141-5-137 = 49.8% wins
St Kilda without Riewoldt since 01: 23-0-22 = 51.1% wins

Statistics can prove anything!

Those stats don't mean to much IMHO as they are basically 50/50 with or without each player. If you had of said 25/75 for example then you'd be onto something.

[Dr Spaceman]

Carlton with Judd since 2008: 67-2-71 = 47.9% wins
Carlton without Judd since 08: 12-0-11 = 52.2% wins

Maybe it would have been better if he'd played? Then again:

St Kilda with Riewoldt since 2001: 141-5-137 = 49.8% wins
St Kilda without Riewoldt since 01: 23-0-22 = 51.1% wins

Statistics can prove anything!

Those stats don't mean to much IMHO as they are basically 50/50 with or without each player.

More chance of a draw if Rooey plays

[bergholt]

Carlton with Judd since 2008: 67-2-71 = 47.9% wins
Carlton without Judd since 08: 12-0-11 = 52.2% wins

Maybe it would have been better if he'd played? Then again:

St Kilda with Riewoldt since 2001: 141-5-137 = 49.8% wins
St Kilda without Riewoldt since 01: 23-0-22 = 51.1% wins

Statistics can prove anything!

Those stats don't mean to much IMHO as they are basically 50/50 with or without each player. If you had of said 25/75 for example then you'd be onto something.

Yep, agreed, really I was just being a smart-arse.