Rhys Stanley for Pick #21

[stinger]

Everyone but Saints supporters are saying we have won this trade hands down.

Not unusual for supporters to overrate their own players.

not any of the ones i've spoken too....reckon that the saints are mad...or as one calton supporter said...the saints have lost the plot...

[LTN16]

Everyone but Saints supporters are saying we have won this trade hands down.

Not unusual for supporters to overrate their own players.

not any of the ones i've spoken too....reckon that the saints are mad...or as one calton supporter said...the saints have lost the plot...

And that's why there not AFL list managers becasue clearly they have no idea

[remboy]

Don't think there's too many Geelong supporters thinking they've won this trade. As for the 'what if Roo gets injured' line, well he didn't get injured this year and look at what happened.
I would have been happy keeping Rhys but he wasn't going to be the difference between us winning a flag and not winning a flag. Our list isn't good enough. We have to make changes. If we now do 1 for 4 & 7 we'll hopefully have 4 good kids to help us improve. If not we'll have to settle for three.

[stinger]

absolute pricks......the guy who runs my gym says that the saints have lost the f****** plot...i agree with him 100%

http://www.saints.com.au/news/2014-10-1 ... nley-trade

i will be writing to the president...and every time that rhys helps geelong do us over...i will be writing to him again.......they can beg all they like for money from me next year...they will get zilch.....

what a load of over reactionary crap, you make it sound like Rhys was the second coming!! He has been a fringe player at best his entire career, he has freakish athletic ability but he hasn't shown anything resembling desire or aggression for the contest.

Lewis Pierce will make us all say "Rhys who?" within 12 months.

i will bookmark your post....rhyc will be a good player for geelong....imho...he was the best tap ruckman we had,,,,better that any of the other three.....he basically won us the game against freo last year...that won't happen again.....i am really pissed off with the club...and that's my right....i do agree with you on the lack of aggression...but the club was working on that....

[Con Gorozidis]

Everyone but Saints supporters are saying we have won this trade hands down.

Not unusual for supporters to overrate their own players.

not any of the ones i've spoken too....reckon that the saints are mad...or as one calton supporter said...the saints have lost the plot...

Thats a good sign coming from a Blues fan
Ill take that as we are on the money.

[bigred]

absolute pricks......the guy who runs my gym says that the saints have lost the f****** plot...i agree with him 100%

http://www.saints.com.au/news/2014-10-1 ... nley-trade

i will be writing to the president...and every time that rhys helps geelong do us over...i will be writing to him again.......they can beg all they like for money from me next year...they will get zilch.....

This was thoroughly entertaining.

[stinger]

absolute pricks......the guy who runs my gym says that the saints have lost the f****** plot...i agree with him 100%

http://www.saints.com.au/news/2014-10-1 ... nley-trade

i will be writing to the president...and every time that rhys helps geelong do us over...i will be writing to him again.......they can beg all they like for money from me next year...they will get zilch.....

what a load of over reactionary crap, you make it sound like Rhys was the second coming!! He has been a fringe player at best his entire career, he has freakish athletic ability but he hasn't shown anything resembling desire or aggression for the contest.

Lewis Pierce will make us all say "Rhys who?" within 12 months.

i will bookmark your post....stanley will be a good player for geelong....imho...he was the best tap ruckman we had,,,,better that any of the other three.....he basically won us the game against freo last year...that won't happen again.....i am really pissed off with the club...and that's my right....i do agree with you on the lack of aggression...but the club was working on that....

[stinger]

absolute pricks......the guy who runs my gym says that the saints have lost the f****** plot...i agree with him 100%

http://www.saints.com.au/news/2014-10-1 ... nley-trade

i will be writing to the president...and every time that rhys helps geelong do us over...i will be writing to him again.......they can beg all they like for money from me next year...they will get zilch.....

This was thoroughly entertaining.

i'm not joking...writing my first letter now.......pricks....

[Con Gorozidis]

For the record I liked and was a supporter of Rhys. But this will not be a decion that makes or breaks the club.

All that matters is what we do with our top 3 draft picks. That will be our make or break. Critical decisions coming up!


MUST NAIL 2 out of 3 or were in deeeeeep trouble...

[LTN16]

absolute pricks......the guy who runs my gym says that the saints have lost the f****** plot...i agree with him 100%

http://www.saints.com.au/news/2014-10-1 ... nley-trade

i will be writing to the president...and every time that rhys helps geelong do us over...i will be writing to him again.......they can beg all they like for money from me next year...they will get zilch.....

what a load of over reactionary crap, you make it sound like Rhys was the second coming!! He has been a fringe player at best his entire career, he has freakish athletic ability but he hasn't shown anything resembling desire or aggression for the contest.

Lewis Pierce will make us all say "Rhys who?" within 12 months.

i will bookmark your post....rhyc will be a good player for geelong....imho...he was the best tap ruckman we had,,,,better that any of the other three.....he basically won us the game against freo last year...that won't happen again.....i am really pissed off with the club...and that's my right....i do agree with you on the lack of aggression...but the club was working on that....

Yeah bookmark it please so we can bring it up in a couple of years time and laugh at you at how wrong you are..

[LTN16]

absolute pricks......the guy who runs my gym says that the saints have lost the f****** plot...i agree with him 100%

http://www.saints.com.au/news/2014-10-1 ... nley-trade

i will be writing to the president...and every time that rhys helps geelong do us over...i will be writing to him again.......they can beg all they like for money from me next year...they will get zilch.....

This was thoroughly entertaining.

i'm not joking...writing my first letter now.......pricks....

What a waste of ink and paper.

[remboy]

absolute pricks......the guy who runs my gym says that the saints have lost the f****** plot...i agree with him 100%

http://www.saints.com.au/news/2014-10-1 ... nley-trade

i will be writing to the president...and every time that rhys helps geelong do us over...i will be writing to him again.......they can beg all they like for money from me next year...they will get zilch.....

what a load of over reactionary crap, you make it sound like Rhys was the second coming!! He has been a fringe player at best his entire career, he has freakish athletic ability but he hasn't shown anything resembling desire or aggression for the contest.

Lewis Pierce will make us all say "Rhys who?" within 12 months.

i will bookmark your post....rhyc will be a good player for geelong....imho...he was the best tap ruckman we had,,,,better that any of the other three.....he basically won us the game against freo last year...that won't happen again.....i am really pissed off with the club...and that's my right....i do agree with you on the lack of aggression...but the club was working on that....

It is your right Stinger. Unfortunately none of us get a say in who gets traded or for what. He was great against Freo but how long have we waited for that game and how long until he produces another one? He may be better at Geelong, he might not. But the deal is done and there's nothing we can do about it.
Hopefully pick 21 ends up being a 200 game player and you're wearing his number on your back at our next grand final appearance. Keep smiling Stinger.

[HitTheBoundary]

absolute pricks......the guy who runs my gym says that the saints have lost the f****** plot...i agree with him 100%

http://www.saints.com.au/news/2014-10-1 ... nley-trade

i will be writing to the president...and every time that rhys helps geelong do us over...i will be writing to him again.......they can beg all they like for money from me next year...they will get zilch.....

This was thoroughly entertaining.

i'm not joking...writing my first letter now.......pricks....

[Bunk_Moreland]

Pelchan and Bains and Richo should be congratulated on the way they are rebuilding our list.

Did a great job last season, looks like this one will be as good or better.

I support the club and team not a player. Good luck Rhys, but I am more interested in the development of our #21 going forward.

[stinger]

Everyone but Saints supporters are saying we have won this trade hands down.

Not unusual for supporters to overrate their own players.

not any of the ones i've spoken too....reckon that the saints are mad...or as one calton supporter said...the saints have lost the plot...

And that's why there not AFL list managers becasue clearly they have no idea

we will see.....i think the problem is that the saints group are list managers, but still have no idea.....

[stinger]

absolute pricks......the guy who runs my gym says that the saints have lost the f****** plot...i agree with him 100%

http://www.saints.com.au/news/2014-10-1 ... nley-trade

i will be writing to the president...and every time that rhys helps geelong do us over...i will be writing to him again.......they can beg all they like for money from me next year...they will get zilch.....

This was thoroughly entertaining.

i'm not joking...writing my first letter now.......pricks....

What a waste of ink and paper.

i will post the reply...

[stinger]

absolute pricks......the guy who runs my gym says that the saints have lost the f****** plot...i agree with him 100%

http://www.saints.com.au/news/2014-10-1 ... nley-trade

i will be writing to the president...and every time that rhys helps geelong do us over...i will be writing to him again.......they can beg all they like for money from me next year...they will get zilch.....

what a load of over reactionary crap, you make it sound like Rhys was the second coming!! He has been a fringe player at best his entire career, he has freakish athletic ability but he hasn't shown anything resembling desire or aggression for the contest.

Lewis Pierce will make us all say "Rhys who?" within 12 months.

i will bookmark your post....rhyc will be a good player for geelong....imho...he was the best tap ruckman we had,,,,better that any of the other three.....he basically won us the game against freo last year...that won't happen again.....i am really pissed off with the club...and that's my right....i do agree with you on the lack of aggression...but the club was working on that....

It is your right Stinger. Unfortunately none of us get a say in who gets traded or for what. He was great against Freo but how long have we waited for that game and how long until he produces another one? He may be better at Geelong, he might not. But the deal is done and there's nothing we can do about it.
Hopefully pick 21 ends up being a 200 game player and you're wearing his number on your back at our next grand final appearance. Keep smiling Stinger.

thanks for that mate...

[stinger]

Pelchan and Bains and Richo should be congratulated on the way they are rebuilding our list.

Did a great job last season, looks like this one will be as good or better.

I support the club and team not a player. Good luck Rhys, but I am more interested in the development of our #21 going forward.

if the pick's a dud...i will be pointing it out....repeatedly......and for years.....

[Fidelis]

Interesting that SEN claim Cats aim to play Clark forwards, Blicavs as a back and then groom Stanley as a ruckman - with injury concerns on both McIntosh and Vardy. Don't think we've really viewed him in this light.

[dragit]

Pelchan and Bains and Richo should be congratulated on the way they are rebuilding our list.

Did a great job last season, looks like this one will be as good or better.

I support the club and team not a player. Good luck Rhys, but I am more interested in the development of our #21 going forward.

if the pick's a dud...i will be pointing it out....repeatedly......and for years.....

You're still mad at the club for converting Barry Hall into Dal Santo…

So there's a pretty good chance you'll be spamming us regardless of the actual result.

[Con Gorozidis]

We just lost 0.5 goals per game.
Membrey surely can kick a goal a game.

[remboy]

Pelchan and Bains and Richo should be congratulated on the way they are rebuilding our list.

Did a great job last season, looks like this one will be as good or better.

I support the club and team not a player. Good luck Rhys, but I am more interested in the development of our #21 going forward.

if the pick's a dud...i will be pointing it out....repeatedly......and for years.....

And if he's not? Sounds as though you are hoping he's no good.

[Bunk_Moreland]

Pelchan and Bains and Richo should be congratulated on the way they are rebuilding our list.

Did a great job last season, looks like this one will be as good or better.

I support the club and team not a player. Good luck Rhys, but I am more interested in the development of our #21 going forward.

if the pick's a dud...i will be pointing it out....repeatedly......and for years.....

Fine. Do that if you like, but give the kid a go.

Remember it is not the kids fault that he was chosen from a pick you didn't like.

If Stanley is a bust, will you admit you were wrong also?

[LTN16]

absolute pricks......the guy who runs my gym says that the saints have lost the f****** plot...i agree with him 100%

http://www.saints.com.au/news/2014-10-1 ... nley-trade

i will be writing to the president...and every time that rhys helps geelong do us over...i will be writing to him again.......they can beg all they like for money from me next year...they will get zilch.....

This was thoroughly entertaining.

i'm not joking...writing my first letter now.......pricks....

What a waste of ink and paper.

i will post the reply...

And post the letter your writing too please. It'll be good for a laugh!

[remboy]

If Stanley is a bust, will you admit you were wrong also?

I don't think that's part of the deal for some reason.