Jack Steven V Joel Selwood V Sam Mitchell

[plugger66]

Ok ive been had.
seems the op is on a wind up session...

Same here, but we can all start dumb arse threads like this.

Going off Perfectionists premis about two sided and P66's response

Who is better Leon Cameron or James Hird.

What a troll

Bergholts response was even better. Perfectionist was saying we cant lose pick one because he will be a two sided player and then uses Mictchell, pick 35, as an example. Anyway jack kicks it both feet, I dont think Selwood does too much. Its all very confusing. I have a headache anyway. he has now made it worse.

[matrix]

oh i get it
the jack steven is not good thing and useless from what, last year, early this year
not rated etc blah yadda yadda dribble excuse me while i wipe my chin rubbish

i mean really
like 90% of people are going to choose joel
even if he cant handle a tag from langford

thats right
how long have he and sam been in the comp compared to jack?

never mind
jacks a dud


peanut

[Bunk_Moreland]

oh i get it
the jack steven is not good thing and useless from what, last year, early this year
not rated etc blah yadda yadda dribble excuse me while i wipe my chin rubbish

i mean really
like 90% of people are going to choose joel
even if he cant handle a tag from langford

thats right
how long have he and sam been in the comp compared to jack?

never mind
jacks a dud


peanut

like

[perfectionist]

...how long have he and sam been in the comp compared to jack?

Joel Selwood was taken in the 2006 draft. Jack was taken the following year.

[Stephen Theodore]

oh i get it
the jack steven is not good thing and useless from what, last year, early this year
not rated etc blah yadda yadda dribble excuse me while i wipe my chin rubbish

i mean really
like 90% of people are going to choose joel
even if he cant handle a tag from langford

thats right
how long have he and sam been in the comp compared to jack?

never mind
jacks a dud


peanut

like

+ 1

[ShanghaiSaint]

Tough choice. Who would you choose?

Selwood easy choice.

imo not fair rot compare Jack to those two.

[whiskers3614]

Ok ive been had.
seems the op is on a wind up session...

Same here, but we can all start dumb arse threads like this.

Going off Perfectionists premis about two sided and P66's response

Who is better Leon Cameron or James Hird.

What a troll

As players I would say Hird but as coaches I would have them as equals and both a fair way ahead of Choker Lyon as they both have less convictions in finals!

[Rosco]

Nice troll.
as for selwood v mitchell - over their career so far - mitchell.
r. harvey over both.

Agree.
Agree.
AGREE.

Now, to take the bait, if given the opportunity to recruit one of those three blokes to your club...

No contest... the Dud.

The others are at or nearer to the end of their careers. Jack is just warming up.

Jack just warming up? Selwood is only 26, jack 24

[Dave McNamara]

Nice troll.
as for selwood v mitchell - over their career so far - mitchell.
r. harvey over both.

Agree.
Agree.
AGREE.

Now, to take the bait, if given the opportunity to recruit one of those three blokes to your club...

No contest... the Dud.

The others are at or nearer to the end of their careers. Jack is just warming up.

Jack just warming up? Selwood is only 26, jack 24

You're correct re the ages Rosco, but not only is Selwood two years younger, but he's been in the Hillbilly's starting 22 since Round 1 (or whatever round he debuted in) in 2007.

In Jack's first few seasons he had to contend with osteitis pubis and Ro$$y's selection policies. He's only been given the chance to strut his stuff since injuries forced Ro$$y to move him onto the ball in late 2011.

So effectively, senior footy seasons played: Selwood - 8, Jack - 3 and a bit (even less again, remembering that most of this year was curtailed by that foot injury).

Anyway, that's the basis for my argument re saying that Jack, in term of his career, is actually just warming out.