Grundy & Swan out CJ sub!

[saintspremiers]

He must need some more tatts!
No changes for us.

[Wayne42]

Good one SP

St Kilda v Collingwood at Etihad Stadium, 7.50pm

LATE CHANGES
St Kilda: Nil
Collingwood: Brodie Grundy and Dane Swan replaced in the selected side by Josh Thomas and Paul Seedsman

FINAL INTERCHANGES
St Kilda: Sebastian Ross, Rhys Stanley, Luke Dunstan
Substitute: Clint Jones
Collingwood: Taylor Adams, Clinton Young, Josh Thomas
Substitute: Paul Seedsman

[saintbob]

Don't understand the use of Jones as a sub, he shouldn't be in the team if this is the only spot for him.

We should be playing kids as the sub, rather than giving it to Jones....

[saint6709]

Don't understand the use of Jones as a sub, he shouldn't be in the team if this is the only spot for him.

We should be playing kids as the sub, rather than giving it to Jones....

I think at this point in the season - I would much rather seeing Dunell or Simpkin out of the emergencies for CJ's sub role. I have loved his 'all heart' effort - but we must now be looking forward.

[BigMart]

Poor choice for Sub IMO

Even if he does come on and use legs to get 10 in a quarter.... Will they hurt that much? Not so sure

I like Saunders as a sub.... Maybe Dunell for his smarts a and versatility or Savage

[Sobraz]

Poor choice for Sub IMO

Even if he does come on and use
legs to get 10 in a quarter.... Will they hurt that much? Not so sure

I like Saunders as a sub.... Maybe Dunell for his smarts a and versatility or Savage

Saunders, Dunell & Savage aren't in the selected side..

Good sub imo, shows Jones is near the fringes.

[Jacks Back]

Poor choice for Sub IMO

Even if he does come on and use
legs to get 10 in a quarter.... Will they hurt that much? Not so sure

I like Saunders as a sub.... Maybe Dunell for his smarts a and versatility or Savage

Saunders, Dunell & Savage aren't in the selected side..

Good sub imo, shows Jones is near the fringes.

Terrible sub choice. Either a player like him is in from the start or right out. What's the point of him as sub?

[perfectionist]

... What's the point of him as sub?

Experience and flexibility. Having a newbie as sub is nuts. That's obvious.

[BigMart]

What flexibility?

Can he play as a lock down back... No ... Weak in the air

Can he play as a dangerous fwd ... No

Can he play as a damaging mid .... He will find the ball, not so damaging.

Can he play a lock role .... Yes

Can he play as a defensive fwd... Yes

I would suggest a sub needs to come on and take advantage of tired legs.... Not sure CJ will hurt too much.

His asset is great effort, which cannot be questioned
If he were a talented player, he'd be a champion

[gringo]

Maybe they see him as an emergency for an injury. If Murdoch or seb are struggling he can take the spot off them also. The need for a burst sub might be irrelevant as we ned to just put development time into kids not win.

[Wayne42]

Jones subbed in early due to that dog act by Sidebottom on Weller

[saintspremiers]

Jones subbed in early due to that dog act by Sidebottom on Weller

We need red and yellow cards.

Saying that tinarse will probably only get a week.

[Old Mate]

Jones subbed in early due to that dog act by Sidebottom on Weller

We need red and yellow cards.

Saying that tinarse will probably only get a week.

We need revenge. Who is gonna stand up and get a few weeks off for the cause?

[lloyd21]

Jones should not be in the side had enough seen enough .
We don't have a midfield ... Steven not fit enough Hayes is finished anyone who says different are you kidding ?
Great player but finished.
Selection poor again ..Schneider should be the sub nearly every week .
Play Dunnell
Play Markworth
We are not learning anything playing the same players in the same positions week in week out


Expect to lose but we have play Simpkin & Sipposs as key forwards try it nothing to lose
Stanley is trade bait for GWS they need 2nd ruck we need mids.

Murdoch is a plus keep playing him all year

[magnifisaint]

Bye Jones. Can't expect to get a game next week on that effort.