Has the MRP ever missed with us?

[CURLY]

Sneider a week for a tummy tap that was so soft it wouldnt have been felt through a jumper. What the hell have we done to cop this rubbish from these clowns.

[plugger66]

No idea. Do have a reason or a few reasons?

[luc1966]

We must remember that if he hadnt had carry over points then he wouldn't have got a week. Disappointed in Schneider more as its a massive game for us this week

[CURLY]

We must remember that if he hadnt had carry over points then he wouldn't have got a week. Disappointed in Schneider more as its a massive game for us this week

MRP viewed Maxwells high shirtfront on Cotchin as insufficent force. Why was this not considered the same?

[realdeal]

Do we challenge this one? Surely there was insufficient force, there was nothing in it at all..

To answer the question of this thread. No. We never get the benefit of doubt..

[noob]

Will Hawkins get one for the one on Langford today?

[Wayne42]

Will Hawkins get one for the one on Langford today?

What about the Hawks dude who scratched Hawkins chest, more than once, the girl should take up netball

[saintbrat]

doesn't help when it was replayed a zillion times-- keeps it to the forefront

[mr six o'clock]

NO !


they never miss us

with snides getting 1 , hawkins should get 2 , his seemed more forceful !

[CURLY]

Hodge cleared to play after his stomach punch into Syeve J. How the f*** do people even try to defend these bias cheating dickheads at the AFL.

[plugger66]

Hodge cleared to play after his stomach punch into Syeve J. How the f*** do people even try to defend these bias cheating dickheads at the AFL.

You still havent told us why they cheat. Anyway Hodge had to get off as it was nothing at all. Hawkins should have been cited based on Schneider.

[CURLY]

Hodge cleared to play after his stomach punch into Syeve J. How the f*** do people even try to defend these bias cheating dickheads at the AFL.

You still havent told us why they cheat. Anyway Hodge had to get off as it was nothing at all. Hawkins should have been cited based on Schneider.

Either was Sneiders yet bang miss a week.

[plugger66]

Hodge cleared to play after his stomach punch into Syeve J. How the f*** do people even try to defend these bias cheating dickheads at the AFL.

You still havent told us why they cheat. Anyway Hodge had to get off as it was nothing at all. Hawkins should have been cited based on Schneider.

Either was Sneiders yet bang miss a week.

One went to ground. Johnson just laughed. Forget Hodge and talk about hawkins which was the same as Schneider.

[CURLY]

Both are cleared no case to answer yet Sneider will miss a week Can anyone explain this?

[st_Trav_ofWA]

meh ... shnieds should cop a week for being stupid enough to throw a punch full stop .... never mind the intent or the force of the punch it was a stupid thing to do by a very senior player in his first game back.... play the ball not the man stupid acts like punching a bloke in the guts does nothing for the team

[plugger66]

Both are cleared no case to answer yet Sneider will miss a week Can anyone explain this?

Hodge had to be cleared. Cant explain hawkins. maybe ring the MRP.

[CURLY]

meh ... shnieds should cop a week for being stupid enough to throw a punch full stop .... never mind the intent or the force of the punch it was a stupid thing to do by a very senior player in his first game back.... play the ball not the man stupid acts like punching a bloke in the guts does nothing for the team

Thats fine but Hodge and Hawkins are both cleared to play.

[Junior]

No problem with Schneider coping a week, he was stupid. Hodge decision correct, but Langford left the field and vomited so I have no idea how the hell Hawkins got off.

Surely he was charged and gets of with an early plea. If not the system is stuffed.

[plugger66]

meh ... shnieds should cop a week for being stupid enough to throw a punch full stop .... never mind the intent or the force of the punch it was a stupid thing to do by a very senior player in his first game back.... play the ball not the man stupid acts like punching a bloke in the guts does nothing for the team

Thats fine but Hodge and Hawkins are both cleared to play.

You really struggle to see the difference in incidents Curly. Forget Hodge and talk about hawkins. It will add more weight to your arguement.

[CURLY]

There is no differance at all. Baguley wasnt hurt either was Johnson yet one is a week the other nil.

[plugger66]

There is no differance at all. Baguley wasnt hurt either was Johnson yet one is a week the other nil.

Seriously your bias is just madness. johnson laughed, Baguley went down. You lose all credibility because you watch things through one eye. Look at Hawkins and complain but forget Hodge. By the way Cloke wasnt hurt either. they must hate North as well and love Geelong.

[CURLY]

There is no differance at all. Baguley wasnt hurt either was Johnson yet one is a week the other nil.

Seriously your bias is just madness. johnson laughed, Baguley went down. You lose all credibility because you watch things through one eye. Look at Hawkins and complain but forget Hodge. By the way Cloke wasnt hurt either. they must hate North as well and love Geelong.

Baguley staged FFS no grown man would go down for a tummy tap like that and everyone knows it. So youd be happy if Johnson collapsed at the knees and Hodge could then be cited.

[plugger66]

There is no differance at all. Baguley wasnt hurt either was Johnson yet one is a week the other nil.

Seriously your bias is just madness. johnson laughed, Baguley went down. You lose all credibility because you watch things through one eye. Look at Hawkins and complain but forget Hodge. By the way Cloke wasnt hurt either. they must hate North as well and love Geelong.

Baguley staged FFS no grown man would go down for a tummy tap like that and everyone knows it.

Ok. Did you speak to him? So i actually dont know what you want then. You want Hodge to be suspended but you want Schneider off. Surely only one incident is the bad call and that is Schneider and also Thompson based on your theory. It seems you think Hodge and Hawkins should have got off. Agree with you then.

[CURLY]

I want them to either both go or both be cleared. The same day they suspend Sneider, Hodge does the same yet receives nothing. Only last week Maxwell was cleared for a head high bump due to insufficent force while others had gone as the head is out of bounds.

[plugger66]

I want them to either both go or both be cleared. The same day they suspend Sneider, Hodge does the same yet receives nothing. Only last week Maxwell was cleared for a head high bump due to insufficent force while others had gone as the head is out of bounds.

So you want someone to go after the other player laughed. Why are you upset about Hodge but not Hawkins. Losing crdibility. And two wrongs dont make a right.