Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs

noob · Post: # 1452812Post **noob** » Mon 21 Apr 2014 7:37pm

Out: Schneider
In: Milera

Old Mate · Post: # 1452818Post **Old Mate** » Mon 21 Apr 2014 7:44pm

You've gone early....did you s*** the bed? Plugs will be disappointed

In
Acres and Savage

Out
Gwilt and Schneider

plugger66 · Post: # 1452821Post **plugger66** » Mon 21 Apr 2014 7:46pm

Disappointing.

Cairnsman · Post: # 1452829Post **Cairnsman** » Mon 21 Apr 2014 7:57pm

noob wrote:Out: Schneider
In: Milera

You could be in breach of copyright.

noob · Post: # 1452832Post **noob** » Mon 21 Apr 2014 8:01pm

plugger66 wrote:Disappointing.

No fun haha?

plugger66 · Post: # 1452833Post **plugger66** » Mon 21 Apr 2014 8:02pm

noob wrote:
plugger66 wrote:Disappointing.
No fun haha?

Couldnt give a toss. Disappointing though.

#gosaintas · Mon 21 Apr 2014 8:11pm

Out

Gwilt (omitted)
Scneider (susp)

In

Simpkin
Milera

PJ · Post: # 1452844Post PJ » Mon 21 Apr 2014 8:20pm

I don't understand why people think that's important to have Savage in for NZ. Apart from his family and friends nobody is going to go just to see him.

It helps PR but it won't affect the sales, people will go if they want to see the game not because someone they don't know but comes from their country happens to be playing.

How much integrity would our selection process have if we selected people we thought the crowd might like to see regardless of their form. Let's put in Spencer White, who cares how he's going and who cares that none of the players and coaching staff think he warrants selection.

magnifisaint · Mon 21 Apr 2014 8:39pm

PJ wrote:I don't understand why people think that's important to have Savage in for NZ. Apart from his family and friends nobody is going to go just to see him.

It helps PR but it won't affect the sales, people will go if they want to see the game not because someone they don't know but comes from their country happens to be playing.

How much integrity would our selection process have if we selected people we thought the crowd might like to see regardless of their form. Let's put in Spencer White, who cares how he's going and who cares that none of the players and coaching staff think he warrants selection.

It's in his contract.

Con Gorozidis · Mon 21 Apr 2014 8:46pm

If Schneider cops a week - then Milera has to come in.

Maybe Weller or Savage for Eli as well.

citywest · Post: # 1452878Post **citywest** » Mon 21 Apr 2014 8:53pm

Out

Gwilt (Injured)
Schneider (Suspended)
Templeton (Omitted)

In

Fisher
Savage
Weller

plugger66 · Post: # 1452881Post **plugger66** » Mon 21 Apr 2014 8:57pm

citywest wrote:Out

Gwilt (Injured)
Schneider (Suspended)
Templeton (Omitted)

In

Fisher
Savage
Weller

What about your teams changes?

Playon · Post: # 1453197Post **Playon** » Tue 22 Apr 2014 7:33pm

Out: Schneider Gwilt
In: Milera Fisher

stinger · Post: # 1453209Post **stinger** » Tue 22 Apr 2014 7:56pm

Playon wrote:Out: Schneider Gwilt
In: Milera Fisher

out schneids...in savage....

borderbarry · Tue 22 Apr 2014 8:32pm

OUT.. Schneider (Disq.) Templeton (rested).

IN Milera. Savage.

Maybe Gwilt for Fisher as well.

We dont normally make a lot of changes after a win.

saintjake · Post: # 1453222Post **saintjake** » Tue 22 Apr 2014 8:48pm

Why is Gwilt getting dropped?

Played really well on the weekend

falka · Post: # 1453226Post **falka** » Tue 22 Apr 2014 8:58pm

So who didn't get on the plane?

mad saint guy · Tue 22 Apr 2014 9:07pm

Gwilt made three horrible clangers that resulted in goals but otherwise had his best game; doubt he'll be dropped. It will be very interesting to see if Savage plays - his VFL game was good but Weller was far better and Fisher is a likely inclusion. It would be very strange to deprive Chips of a run in the VFL if he isn't in the senior side.

Ideally from a marketing perspective we'd want both Savage (NZ) and Templeton (marketable cult figure) in the side. From a purely football perspective, I'm not sure I'd play either this week.

plugger66 · Post: # 1453238Post **plugger66** » Tue 22 Apr 2014 9:10pm

mad saint guy wrote:Gwilt made three horrible clangers that resulted in goals but otherwise had his best game; doubt he'll be dropped. It will be very interesting to see if Savage plays - his VFL game was good but Weller was far better and Fisher is a likely inclusion. It would be very strange to deprive Chips of a run in the VFL if he isn't in the senior side.

Ideally from a marketing perspective we'd want both Savage (NZ) and Templeton (marketable cult figure) in the side. From a purely football perspective, I'm not sure I'd play either this week.

He will still play in the VFL side if he doesnt play on Friday. All over there will if fit and didnt play in the main game.

Playon · Post: # 1453251Post **Playon** » Tue 22 Apr 2014 9:23pm

saintjake wrote:Why is Gwilt getting dropped?

Played really well on the weekend

He hasn't been dropped yet. It's only guesswork, Fisher has flown over and Gwilt was told by AR that there is no guarantee that he will play this week.

Smoke and mirrors? Dunno

Playon · Post: # 1453254Post **Playon** » Tue 22 Apr 2014 9:29pm

stinger wrote:
Playon wrote:Out: Schneider Gwilt
In: Milera Fisher

out schneids...in savage....

Hard to call with the NZ game and all, but I'm thinking if like for like, Milera and TDL should get a go ahead of him based on their form at Sandy. Perhaps Savage needs some time in the 2s to convince otherwise. I'm happy with the clubs call on this either way, but it'd be great to see how some of the other guys might go.

Old Mate · Post: # 1453259Post **Old Mate** » Tue 22 Apr 2014 9:53pm

Savage, Fisher, TDL and Longer (and the NZ rookie) flew over with the team vs Ess minus Schneider.

bigcarl · Post: # 1453368Post **bigcarl** » Wed 23 Apr 2014 12:02pm

Playon wrote:
saintjake wrote:Why is Gwilt getting dropped?

Played really well on the weekend
He hasn't been dropped yet. It's only guesswork, Fisher has flown over and Gwilt was told by AR that there is no guarantee that he will play this week.

Smoke and mirrors? Dunno

Maybe an injury concern. He looked pretty sore when he came off at one stage after being tunnelled

WinnersOnly · Wed 23 Apr 2014 12:11pm

citywest wrote:Out

Gwilt (Injured)
Schneider (Suspended)
Templeton (Omitted)

In

Fisher
Savage
Weller

I reckon you are on the money City - did Weller travel with the team?

Con Gorozidis · Wed 23 Apr 2014 12:20pm

I know they don't pick the side - Going on the Saints.com.au article Savage is a certainty.

Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs

Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs

Re: Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs

Re: Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs

Re: Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs

Re: Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs

Re: Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs

Re: Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs

Re: Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs

Re: Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs

Re: Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs

Re: Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs

Re: Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs

Re: Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs

Re: Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs

Re: Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs

Re: Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs

Re: Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs

Re: Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs

Re: Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs

Re: Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs

Re: Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs

Re: Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs

Re: Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs

Re: Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs

Re: Round 6: Guess this weeks ins and outs